Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Top 50 2013

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

From Round 11 - Adel vs Syd:
9. Hannebery
8. O'Keefe
7. Jack, Mitchell
6. McVeigh, Douglas, Rampe
5. Talia, Rutten, Dangerfield, Malceski, Parker, Richards
4. Sloane, Bird, White, McGlynn, Bolton, Lynch, Kennedy, N. Smith, B. Smith, Henderson, Jacobs
3. Morton, Pyke, Grundy, Laird, Thompson, Reilly
2. Mumford, Goodes, McKernan, Porplyzia, van Berlo, Otten
1. Kerridge, Petrenko, Jenkins
 
From Round 11 - GWS vs Geel:
8. J. Hunt, Selwood
7. Podsiadly, Christensen, Stokes, Kelly
6. Giles, Cameron, Treloar, Ward, Corey
5. Palmer, Bartel, Johnson, Enright, Mohr
4. Murdoch, Smith, Reid, West
3. Thurlow, Scully, Mackie, Adams, Guthrie, Brown
2. Coniglio, Tomlinson, Kennedy, Plowman, Gilham, Townsend, Stringer, Hawkins, Smedts
1. Whitfield, Vardy
 
From Round 11 - StK vs WCE:
8. Mackenzie
7. Armitage
6. Montagna, Shuey, Naitanui, Hurn, Cox, Milne, Selwood
5. Wilson, Priddis, Darling, Masten, Dal Santo, Brown
4. Maister, Steven, Kerr, Newnes, Dempster, Stanley, Ray
3. Embley, Riewoldt, Dennis-Lane, Brennan, Roberton, Butler
2. Rosa, Hill, Gaff, Gwilt, Geary, Jones
1. A. Selwood, Hams, Saad, Ross
0. Cripps
 
From Round 12 - Carl vs Haw:
9. Judd
8. Simpson, Gibbs, Mitchell
7. McLean, Kreuzer, Lake
6. Scotland, Hodge, Stratton, Gibson, Roughead
5. Gunston, Birchall, Henderson, Tuohy, Franklin, Cachia
4. Betts, Jamison, Walker, Armfield, Hill, Guerra, Puopolo
3. Lewis, Robinson, Casboult, Waite, Curnow, Bailey, Burgoyne, Sewell
2. Rowe, Breust, Smith, Simpkin, Shiels
1. Garlett, Lucas
0. Murphy
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

eaglespremiers said:
From Round 12 - Carl vs Haw:
9. Judd
8. Simpson, Gibbs
7. McLean, Kreuzer, Mitchell
6. Scotland, Hodge, Lake, Stratton
5. Roughead, Gunston, Birchall, Gibson, Henderson, Tuohy
4. Franklin, Betts, Jamison, Walker, Armfield, Cachia, Hill, Guerra, Puopolo
3. Lewis, Robinson, Casboult, Waite, Curnow, Bailey, Burgoyne, Sewell
2. Rowe, Breust, Smith, Simpkin, Shiels
1. Garlett, Lucas
0. Murphy
Click to expand...
5 of the 6 highest votes to the losing team?
 
eaglespremiers said:
From Round 12 - Carl vs Haw:
9. Judd
8. Simpson, Gibbs
7. McLean, Kreuzer, Mitchell
6. Scotland, Hodge, Lake, Stratton
5. Roughead, Gunston, Birchall, Gibson, Henderson, Tuohy
4. Franklin, Betts, Jamison, Walker, Armfield, Cachia, Hill, Guerra, Puopolo
3. Lewis, Robinson, Casboult, Waite, Curnow, Bailey, Burgoyne, Sewell
2. Rowe, Breust, Smith, Simpkin, Shiels
1. Garlett, Lucas
0. Murphy
Click to expand...


I think just about every hawk could go up a rung. Mitchell's last quarter won the game. Lake was unbeatable in the second half.
Franklin kicked 4 and was the Hawks leading SC player but only gets a 4?

Cachia deserves higher than 4, he got 22 possessions and kept Smith to just 11. And I thought Gibbs was the Blues best.
 
From Round 10 - Melb vs Haw:
8. Sewell, Breust
7. Lewis, Puopolo
6. Smith, Lake, Stratton, Birchall, Gibson, Hale, N. Jones
5. Burgoyne, Roughead, Simpkin, Hill, Dawes
4. Franklin, Duryea, Mitchell, Garland, Frawley, Trengove
3. Hodge, Davey, Howe, Terlich, McKenzie, Watts
2. Guerra, Shiels, Bail, Jamar
1. Dunn, Evans, M. Jones
0. Tapscott
 
From Round 10 - NM vs StK:
8. Mullett, Petrie
7. Goldstein, Black, Hansen, Harvey
6. Thomas, Bastinac, Cunnington, Swallow, Thompson
5. Riewoldt, Atley, Wells, Steven, Dal Santo
4. Montagna, Grima, Ray, Gibson, Adams
3. Stanley, Armitage, Gwilt, Roberton, McEvoy, MacMillan, McMahon
2. Geary, Fisher
1. Milne, Newnes, S. Wright
0. Siposs, Saad
 
From Round 11 - GCS v NM:
9. Ablett
8. McKenzie
7. Harbrow, Lynch, Harbrow, Nicholls, Cunnington
6. Prestia, O'Meara, Stanley, Wells, Russell, S. Thompson
5. D. Swallow, Murphy, Shaw, Grima, Goldstein
4. Hall, R. Thompson, Gibson, Mullett, Day
3. Petrie, Brown, Rischitelli, A. Swallow, Harvey, Wright, Thomas
2. Black, Dixon, Adams, Wilkinson, McMahon, Atley, Firrito
1. MacMillan, Bastinac
0. Patrick, Hutchins, Hansen
 
From Round 11 - Melb vs Coll:
8. Swan, Ball
7. Pendlebury, O'Brien, Shaw
6. Thomas, Macaffer, Sidebottom
5. Kennedy, Cloke, Lynch, Garland, N. Jones, Williams, Reid
4. M. Jones, Trengove, Sylvia, Didak, Martin, Maxwell
3. Seedsman, Blair, Jolly, Sinclair, Brown, Terlich, Watts, Blease, Jamar
2. Rodan, Howe, Evans, McKenzie, Toumpas, Dunn
1. McDonald, Kent
0. Tapscott, Dawes
 
From Round 12 - Rich vs Adel:
8. Deledio, Dangerfield
7. Martin, Houli, Ellis
6. Morris, Foley, Maric, Grigg, Rance, Riewoldt
5. Jackson, Chaplin, Edwards, Newman, Douglas, Sloane, Thompson
4. Cotchin, Vlastuin, Conca, Talia, Rutten, Lynch
3. King, Jacobs, Jenkins, Mackay, Porplyzia
2. Vickery, Jaensch, Wright, Otten, Vince, Callinan, B. Smith
1. A. Edwards, Astbury, van Berlo, McKernan, Brown, Laird
0. White, Henderson
 
From Round 12 - Ess vs GCS:
9. Goddard
8. Ablett
7. O'Meara, Heppell, Watson, Crameri, Hibberd
6. Hooker, Zaharakis, Ryder, Pears, Howlett, McKenzie
5. Daniher, Myers, Carlisle, Hocking, Thompson, Winderlich, Harbrow
4. Baguley, Kommer, Hall, Swallow, Prestia, Nicholls, Russell
3. Hurley, Melksham, Shaw, Day, Brown
2. Davey, Rischitelli, Sumner
1. Murphy, Gorringe, Hutchins, Wilkerson, Patrick
0. Merrett, Lynch
 

Remove this Banner Ad

From Round 12 - Frem vs Bris:
8. Mundy, Ibbotson
7. Barlow, Johnson, D. Pearce, McPharlin
6. Hill, Mzungu, Z. Clarke, C. Pearce, Golby
5. Lester, Crowley, Mayes, J. Clarke, Patfull, Mayne
4. Fyfe, Duffield, Redden, Rockliff, Leuenberger, Lisle, Hanley
3. Black, McGrath, Rich, Zorko, Yeo, Staker, Spurr, Dawson
2. Bewick, Raines, Ballantyne, de Boer, Suban, Hannath
1. McKeever
0. Docherty, Silvangi, Crozier
 
From Round 13 - Haw vs WCE:
8. Roughead, Lake, Shuey
7. Hodge, Kennedy, Gaff, Stratton
6. Kerr, Naitanui, Gunston, Masten, Guerra
5. Selwood, Mitchell, Mackenzie, Lewis, Breust, Savage
4. Bailey, Franklin, Priddis, Gibson, Shiels, Simpkin
3. Cox, Rosa, Wilson, Waters, McGinnity, Burgoyne
2. Darling, LeCras, Butler, Brown, Glass, Dalziell, Hill, Sewell
1. Embley, Hale, Birchall
0. Hurn, Ellis
 
eaglespremiers said:
From Round 13 - Haw vs WCE:
8. Roughead, Lake, Shuey
7. Hodge, Kennedy, Gaff, Stratton
6. Kerr, Naitanui, Gunston, Masten, Guerra
5. Selwood, Mitchell, Mackenzie, Lewis, Breust, Savage
4. Bailey, Franklin, Priddis, Gibson, Shiels, Simpkin
3. Cox, Rosa, Wilson, Waters, McGinnity, Burgoyne
2. Darling, LeCras, Butler, Brown, Glass, Dalziell, Hill, Sewell
1. Embley, Hale, Birchall
0. Hurn, Ellis
Click to expand...
Roughead unlucky not to get 9, clearly BOG. I'm a big wrap for Stratton but last night was one of his worst games of the year. Franklin was better than a 4 as well
 
hawkman said:
Roughead unlucky not to get 9, clearly BOG. I'm a big wrap for Stratton but last night was one of his worst games of the year. Franklin was better than a 4 as well
Click to expand...

Yeah, I'm half tempted to give Roughead a 9.
Stratton beat Darling from pillar to post last night, thought he was excellent.
Perhaps a 5 for Franklin?
 
eaglespremiers said:
Yeah, I'm half tempted to give Roughead a 9.
Stratton beat Darling from pillar to post last night, thought he was excellent.
Perhaps a 5 for Franklin?
Click to expand...
He did a solid job on Darling but he panicked with the ball a number of times which I would drop him down for. Franklin would be at least a 5, kicked 2 set up another 3 I think. Heard that he also had the most pressure acts for us last night so he was good defensively as well
Compare that to Gibson who I thought was well beaten by Kennedy
 
From Round 13 - PA vs Syd:
8. Wingard, Lobbe, Jack
7. Ebert, Broadbent, Kennedy
6. McVeigh, Malceski, O'Keefe, Cornes, Cassisi
5. Parker, Westhoff, Jonas, Logan, Gray, Moore, Schulz, Wines, Hombsch, Bird
4. Rampe, Mitchell, Pyke, Hartlett, Monfries, O'Shea,
3. Neade, Tippett, Carlile, Goodes, Smith
2. Hannebery, Heath, Armstrong, Grundy, Richards, McGlynn
1. Thomas, Bolton, White
0. Pittard, Lamb
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

From Round 13 - StK vs Melb:
9. Montagna
8. Ray
7. Steven, Geary, Dempster, Garland
6. Roberton, Gwilt, Sylvia, Dal Santo, Armitage
5. Milera, Riewoldt, Dunell, N. Jones, Spencer
4. Watts, Newnes, Terlich, McDonald, Clisby
3. Ross, Dennis-Lane, Simpkin, Stanley, Toumpas, M. Jones, Byrnes, Blease
2. C. Jones, Murdoch, Koschitzke, McEvoy, Trengove, Dunn, Pederson, Howe, Rodan, Fitzpatrick
1. Webster, Davey, Kent, Dawes
0. Nicholson
 
From Round 13 - WB vs Rich:
8. Houli
7. Grigg, Martin, Griffen, Conca
6. Smith, Rance, Morris, A. Edwards, Jackson, Riewoldt
5. Macrae, S. Edwards, Vickery, Foley, Deledio, Hunter, Liberatore, Roughead, Boyd
4. Maric, Chaplin, Newman, Ellis, Cooney, Johannisen, Minson
3. Cotchin, Talia, Morris
2. King, L. Jones, Goodes, Stringer, Markovic
1. White, Vlastuin, Astbury, Dahlhaus, Picken, Lower, Hrovat
0. Gia
 
From Round 13 - Frem vs NM:
8. Fyfe
7. Ibbotson, Barlow, Clarke, Swallow, Bastinac
6. Johnson, McPharlin, Hansen, Greenwood, Grima
5. de Boer, Spurr, Suban, Hill, C. Pearce, Crowley, MacMillan, Goldstein
4. Duffield, Ballantyne, Mayne, Walters, Dawson, Thompson
3. D. Pearce, Mzungu, Wells, Mullett, Atley, Gibson
2. Taberner, Hannath, Black, Harvey, Petrie, McKenzie, Hine, Anthony, Firrito
1. Crozier, Wright, Adams
0. Thomas
 
From Round 12 – PA vs GWS:
8. Wingard, O'Shea, Boak
7. Jonas, Ebert, Monfries
6. Lobbe, Schulz, Scully
5. Westhoff, Hartlett, Hombsch, Logan, Whitfield
4. Wines, Broadbent, Treloar, Giles, Ward
3. Stewart, Carlile, Thomas, Hampton, Greene, Tomlinson, Mohr
2. Butcher, Coniglio, Adams, Cameron, Shiel, Kennedy, Townsend
1. Neade, Reid, Smith, Hoskin-Elliott, Corr, Bruce, Williams
0. Gray, Hitchcock, Plowman
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Top 50 2013

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top