Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Top 50 2013

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

From Round 14 - Sydney vs Carlton:
8. Bird
7. Parker, O'Keefe, Gibbs, Henderson
6. Tippett, McVeigh, Judd, Kreuzer, Simpson
5. Hannebery, Kennedy, Malceski, Rampe, Pyke, Walker, Cachia, McGlynn
4. K. Jack, Mitchell, Bolton, Smith, Richards, Scotland, Curnow, Jamison
3. Everitt, Grundy, Lamb, Armfield, Robinson, Tuohy, Lucas
2. B. Jack, McLean, Bootsma, S. White, Casboult
1. J. White, Waite, Garlett, Yarran, Betts
0. X. Richards
 
From Round 14 - Gold Coast vs Adelaide:
9. Prestia
8. Dangerfield
7. Smith, Crouch, Porplyzia, O'Meara, Ablett
6. Wright, Jacobs, Laird, Stanley
5. Henderson, van Berlo, Harbrow
4. Jenkins, T. Lynch, Douglas, Riley, Talia, McKenzie, Nicholls
3. Rutten, S. Thompson, Sloane, Otten, Vince, May, Shaw, Hall, C. Brown, R. Thompson, Broughton
2. L. Brown, Day, Sumner, Murphy, Swallow, Wilkinson
1. Jaensch, Weller, Gorringe
0. Reilly, Hunt, Boston
 
eaglespremiers said:
From Round 14 - Gold Coast vs Adelaide:
9. Prestia
8. Dangerfield
7. Smith, Crouch, O'Meara, Ablett
6. Wright, Porplyzia, Jacobs, Laird, Stanley
5. Henderson, van Berlo, Harbrow
4. Jenkins, T. Lynch, Douglas, Talia, McKenzie, Nicholls
3. Rutten, S. Thompson, Sloane, Otten, Vince, May, Shaw, Hall, C. Brown, R. Thompson, Broughton
2. L. Brown, Riley, Day, Sumner, Murphy, Swallow, Wilkinson
1. Jaensch, Weller, Gorringe
0. Reilly, Hunt, Boston
Click to expand...

Pretty accurate assessment of the game. Think, although it won't affect too much, think Riley's game was around a 4 rather than a 2. Had an impact when the game was there in the balance. Also, for the same reason, I'd say Porplyzia may deserve a 7. Had a huge impact on the game with those crucial goals when things were close...
 
For Round 14 - PA vs Coll:
8. Ebert
7. Broadbent, Boak, Seedsman
6. Wines, Jonas, Westhoff, Carlile, Cornes
5. Hombsch, Moore, Wingard, Pendlebury
4. Hartlett, O'Shea, Schulz, Williams, Hudson, Dwyer, Ball, Maxwell, Macaffer
3. Monfries, Lobbe, Logan, Thomas, Shaw, Cloke, Swan, O'Brien, Sinclair, Sidebottom
2. Trengove, Pittard, Neade, Blair, Brown
1. Martin, Lynch, Elliott
0. Cassisi, Kennedy
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

From Round 14 - Geel vs Frem:
9. Christensen
8. Taylor
7. Enright, Corey, Macke, Bartel, Crowley
6. Simpson, Stokes, Kelly, Duncan, Hunt, Mzungu, D. Pearce
5. Podsiadly, Motlop, Ibbotson, Clarke, Fyfe, McPharlin, Walters
4. Z. Dawson, M. Johnson
3. Hawkins, Caddy, Stringer, J. Hunt, Lonergan, Mayne, C. Pearce, Sheridan, de Boer,
2. Selwood, Blicavs, Ballantyne, Hill, Suban, Crozier, Duffield, Michie
1. Murdoch, Hannath, Taberner
 
From Round 14 - Melb vs WB:
8. Watts, Liberatore
7. Griffen
6. Terlich, Minson
5. Nicholson, Frawley, Rodan, N. Jones, Giansiracusa, Murphy
4. Dawes, Trengove, Gawn, Garland, Cooney, Boyd, Macrae
3. Fitzpatrick, M. Jones, McDonald, Hrovat, Talia, Wallis, Lower, Roughead
2. Clisby, Dunn, Davey, Toumpas, Cordy, Dickson, Dahlhaus, Johannisen, Morris
1. Kent, Blease, Byrnes, Smith, L. Jones, Stringer
0. Hunter
 
From Round 14 - Haw vs Bris:
7. Sewell, Gibson, Roughead
6. Savage, Mitchell, Lake, Franklin, Rich
5. Breust, Hodge, Brown, Moloney, Leuenberger
4. Stratton, Lake, Hill, Simpkin, Gunston, Golby, Hanley, Redden, Black
3. Burgoyne, Duryea, Lewis, Adcock, Maguire, Rockliff
2. Ceglar, Hale, Shiels, Whitecross, Lisle, Zorko, Staker, Patfull
1. Yeo, Polkinghorne, Harwood, McGrath, Docherty, Clarke
0. Ellis
 
From Round 14 - NM vs GWS:
7. Petrie
6. Harvey, Hansen, Bastinac, Thompson
5. Grima, Gibson, Swallow, Thomas, Goldstein, Greenwood
4. McKenzie, Wells, Ziebell, Mullett, Hoskin-Elliott, O'hAilpin, Treloar
3. Hine, Firrito, Tomlinson, Greene, Adams, Gilham, Shiel, Giles
2. Tarrant, Scully, Ward, Reid, Whitfield
1. Haynes, Kennedy, Hampton, D. Smith, Sumner, Corr, Mohr
0. Black, MacMillan, Williams, Townsend
 
From Round 14 - Rich vs StK:
7. Jackson, Vickery
6. Conca, J. Riewoldt, A. Edwards, Foley, Rance, Steven
5. S. Edwards, Houli, Cotchin, Chaplin, Grigg, Dal Santo, Armitage
4. Martin, Stephenson, Deledio, McEvoy, N. Riewoldt, C. Jones, Montagna
3. Arnot, Newman, Ellis, Batchelor, Dennis-Lane, Murdoch, Ray
2. Morris, Newnes, Geary, Stanley, Gwilt, Dempster, Webster, Wright
1. White, King, Ross, Roberton, Milera
0. Koschitzke, Dunell
 
From Round 15 - Carl vs Coll:
9. Pendlebury
8. Cloke
7. Reid, Swan, Judd
6. McLean, Kreuzer
5. Thomas, Ball, Sidebottom, Lucas, Carrazzo, Walker
4. Macaffer, Williams, Brown, Sinclair, Seedsman, Simpson
3. Shaw, Witts, Hudson, Dwyer, Elliott, Henderson, Robinson
2. Blair, Krakouer, Murphy, Gibbs, Jamison, Cachia, Casboult, Armfield, Tuohy
1. Young, Maxwell, Yarran, Garlett, Betts
0. Kennedy, Waite
 
Swan a 5?? Surely taking the piss.
 
eaglespremiers said:
He was awful.
Don't know how I can give him any more than that.
Unless I completely ignore my impressions of the game.
Click to expand...

His disposal wasn't great but he still kept getting clearances after clearances for the pies and kept going all night. He would get a 9 from me if his disposals were better but he deserved an 8 or a 7 at the very least.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Hawkas1988 said:
His disposal wasn't great but he still kept getting clearances after clearances for the pies and kept going all night. He would get a 9 from me if his disposals were better but he deserved an 8 or a 7 at the very least.
Click to expand...

Sure, I'll bump him up to a 7.
But I can't think of a disposal in the last three quarters of his that actually did anything productive or had any merit.
 
From Round 15 - GWS vs WB:
8. Talia
7. Shiel
6. C. Smith, D. Smith
5. Dahlhaus, Goodes, Whitfield, Haynes, Scully
4. Giansiracusa, Griffen, Minson, Cooney, Treloar, Mohr
3. Macrae, Murphy, Liberatore, Hrovat, Morris, Giles, Gilham, Coniglio
2. Dickson, Wallis, Tutt, Stevens, Jones, Hoskin-Elliott, Ward, Hampton, Cameron
1. Stringer, Cordy, Tomlinson, Reid, Adams, O'hAilpin, Palmer, Townsend, Corr
0. Johanissen, Kennedy
 
From Round 15 - Adel vs WCE:
8. Mackenzie
7. Kennedy, Masten, Priddis, Dalziell, Dangerfield
6. Glass, Thompson
5. Naitanui, Hutchings, Crouch, Douglas, Vince, Henderson, Sloane, Otten
4. Cox, Schofield, Lynch, Porplyzia, Jacobs, Vince
3. LeCras, Embley, Rosa, van Berlo, Talia, Rutten, Laird, Smith
2. Hill, Sheppard, McGinnity, Cripps, L. Brown, McKernan
1. M. Brown, Gaff, Waters, Jenkins, Jaensch
0. Darling, Brennan, Riley
 
From Round 15 - NM vs Rich:
8. Adams, Hansen
7. Greenwood, Bastinac
6. Ziebell, Hines, Grima, Goldstein, Foley, Morris
5. Wells, Tarrant, Swallow, Grigg, White, Martin, Cotchin, Black
4. Petrie, Jackson, Vickery, Chaplin
3. Mullett, Cunnington, MacMillan, Deledio, Stephenson, Conca, S. Edwards
2. Gibson, Firrito, Atley, King, Rance, A. Edwards, Newman, Vlastuin
1. Batchelor, Riewoldt, Ellis, Dea
0. McKenzie
 
From Round 15 - Bris vs GCS:
8. Leuenberger
7. Hanley, Bennell
6. Maguire, Zorko, Mayes, Redden, Staker, Brennan
5. Patfull, Rockliff, J. Brown, Shaw, Swallow, Thompson, Stanley
4. Golby, Raines, Prestia, McKenzie, Nicholls, Broughton
3. Harwood, Clarke, O'Meara, C. Brown, Murphy
2. Rich, Merrett, Green, Lester, Russell, Wilkinson, Hall
1. Bewick, Moloney, May, Sumner, Gorringe
0. McGrath, Day, Boston
 
From Round 15 - Geel vs Haw:
9. Selwood
8. Duncan, Kelly, Mitchell
7. Mackie, Lonergan, Bartel
6. Enright, Murdoch, Stratton
5. Caddy, J. Hun, Gunston, Hill, Lake
4. Taylor, Blicavs, Roughead, Duryea, Gibson
3. Stokes, Christensen, Motlop, Corey, Breust, Simpkin, Smith, Burgoyne
2. Hunt, Franklin, Hodge, Whitecross, Puopolo
1. Hawkins, Sewell, Savage, Rioli, Bailey
0. Stringer
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

eaglespremiers said:
From Round 15 - Adel vs WCE:
8. Mackenzie
7. Kennedy, Masten, Priddis, Dalziell, Dangerfield
6. Glass, Thompson
5. Naitanui, Hutchings, Crouch, Douglas, Vince, Henderson, Sloane, Otten
4. Cox, Schofield, Lynch, Porplyzia, Jacobs, Vince
3. LeCras, Embley, Rosa, van Berlo, Talia, Rutten, Laird, Smith
2. Hill, Sheppard, McGinnity, Cripps, L. Brown, McKernan
1. M. Brown, Gaff, Waters, Jenkins, Jaensch
0. Darling, Brennan, Riley
Click to expand...
Embley a three? Did you not see his last quarter? When the game was there to be won he stepped it up!
 
From Round 15 - Melb vs Syd:
9. K. Jack
7. O'Keefe, McVeigh, Kennedy
6. Malceski, Mitchell, Fitzpatrick
5. Bird, Hannebery, B. Jack, Terlich
4. Tippett, Mumford, Parker, Garland, McDonald, Howe
3. Bolton, Richards, Everitt, Grundy, Pyke, Frawley, Sylvia, N. Jones, Nicholson, M. Jones
2. Rampe, Smith, Davey, Clisby, Toumpas, Dawes, Dunn, Rodan, Trengove
1. McGlynn, Lamb, Kent
0. Reid, Byrnes
 
From Round 15 - Frem vs St K:
8. Ballantyne
7. Johnson, Mzungu, Montagna
6. Mundy, Ibbotson, Fyfe, D. Pearce, Barlow, Steven
5. C. Pearce, Spurr, Pavlich, Suban, Mayne, Hayes, McEvoy, C. Jones
4. De boer, McPharlin, Armitage, Dal Santo, Geary, Murdoch
3. Crowley, Walters, Z. Clarke, Gwilt, Lee, Roberton, Newnes
2. Dawson, Hill, Dempster, Saad, Dennis-Lane, Saunders
1. Sandilands, Stanley, Wright, Hickey
0. Sheridan, Milera
 
From Round 15 - Ess vs PA:
8. Hooker
7. Goddard, Zaharakis, Pears, Ebert
6. Stanton, Bellchambers, Monfries, Lobbe, Gray
5. Ryder, Winderlich, Howlett, Baguley, Heppell, Boak, Hartlett, Wines
4. Fletcher, Hurley, Dempsey, Wingard, Cornes, Trengove, Carlile
3. Myers, Schulz, Moore, O'Shea, Jonas
2. Kommer, Westhoff, Broadbent, Logan
1. Carlisle, Colyer, Merrett, Hombsch
0. Watson, Pittard, Neade, Stewart
 
From Round 16 - Adel vs Coll:
9. Pendlebury
8. Ball, Swan
7. Lynch, Beams, Dwyer
6. Henderson, Douglas, Reid, Sidebottom, Williams
5. Crouch, Laird, Lyons, Porplyzia, Cloke, Hudson, Shaw
4. Vince, Smith, Sloane, Thompson, Krakouer, Macaffer, N. Brown
3. Van Belro, L. Brown, Jacobs, Rutten, Talia, Dangerfield, Witts
2. Mackay, Jenkins, Maxwell, Seedsman, Blair
1. Wright, Otten, Sinclair, Thomas
0. Jaensch, Elliott
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Top 50 2013

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top