Trade and Draft Game (with concessions)

[mojon95]

I thought it would be interesting to see, how the concession system would work.

We'll have a trade period of 1 week where players and picks can be traded, including GC17. The twist however... is that the draft picks will be done like the 2010 draft, including GC17 Concessions..... the draft will be done imediately after the trade period.

To make sure GC17 have a full squad of 44.... i will recieve 2 players from each club. The players willbe one above 25 and one player below 25, however, you must choose you 3 best players at the club you have, and i cannot take any of those 3.

First in best dressed as usual.

Adelaide -
Brisbane -
Carlton -
Collingwood -
Essendon -
Fremantle -
Geelong -
Gold Coast - Mojon95
Hawthorn -
Melbourne -
North Melbourne - Yonnie
Port Adelaide - Strath39
St.Kilda -
Sydney -
West Coast -
Western Bulldogs -


Draft Picks:

Round One
1 GC17
2 GC17
3 GC17
4 Melborune
5 GC17
6 West Coast
7 GC17
8 Fremantle
9 GC17
10 Port Adelaide
11 GC17
12 Essendon
13 GC17
14 Carlton
15 GC17
16 Brisbane
17 Richmond
18 Collingwood
19 North Melbourne
20 Sydney
21 Adelaide
22 St.Kilda
23 Western Bulldogs
24 Hawthorn
25 Geelong

Round Two
26 GC17
27 Melbourne
28 West Coast
29 Fremantle
30 Port Adelaide
31 Essendon
32 Carlton
33 Brisbane
34 Richmond
35 Collingwood
36 North Melbourne
37 Sydney
38 Adelaide
39 St.Kilda
40 Western Bulldogs
41 Hawthorn
42 Geelong

Round Three
43 GC17
44 Melbourne
45 West Coast
46 Fremantle
47 Port Adelaide
48 Essendon
49 Carlton
50 Brisbane
51 Richmond
52 Collingwood
53 North Melbourne
54 Sydney
55 Adelaide
56 St.Kilda
57 Western Bulldogs
58 Hawthorn
59 Geelong

 

[mojon95]

GC17

Picks: 1,2,3,5,7,9,11,13,15,26,43

Players:

Charlie Dixon
Birth Date: 23-9-90
Birth place: Cairns
Height: 200cm
Weight: 97Kgs
A Cairns product whose parents were both outstanding basketball players, and himself was a junior representative basketballer. Didn't take up football until 2003 and olnly began playing seriously in 2007. Moved to Brisbane this year to further his AFL aspirations.


http://gc17.com.au/typo3/#
Jesse Haberfield
Birth date: 17-1-91
Birth place: Whittington (Vic)
Height: 182cm
Weight: 76Kgs
Moved from Geelong to the Gold Coast with his family in 1998 and has been a regular state age representative. His father was a good country footballer.


http://gc17.com.au/typo3/#
Jack Stanlake
Birth date: 28-2-91
Birth place: Albury
Height: 190cm
Weight: 79kgs
Son of a former Footscray AFL player, he moved from Albury (NSW) to Harvey Bay in 2002 and later to the Gold Coast in 2003. A standout junior sportsman, he is a highly rated fast bowler and narrowly missed a 2008-2009 rookie contract with the Queensland Bulls.

http://gc17.com.au/typo3/#
Jack Stanley
Birth Date: 3-1-90
Birth place: Brisbane
Height: 192cm
Weight: 88kgs
Son of a former Victorian baseball representative, he is a born and bred Queenslander and a product of Nudgee College.


Zac Smith
Birth Date: 22-2-90
Birth Place: Biloela (Qld)
Height: 204cm
Weight: 95kgs
A Queensland junior representative in soccer and indoor soccer from Rockhampon, he is in just his second year of football. Moved to Brisbane this year

 

[strath39]

I will take port

 

[search and destroy]

surely by taking the 4th and 5th best players from other clubs (by way of teams only being able to protect their best 3 players) GC17 will end up with a ridiculously unrealistically good team.

for example, going by this method you could get:
from cats: joel corey and joel selwood
from hawks: sewell and cyril rioli
from carlton: one of murphy/gibbs/kreuzer and nick stevens

In many teams the 4th and 5th best players are still absolute guns. I think you need more limits on the players you can take from other teams.

 

[mojon95]

how about top 4 players can't be picked, but..... remember you don't hvae too choose the best 4 players, just the 4 you want to keep...

ie.... geelong keep....corey, ablett, mooney and bartel

scarlett is better than mooney,but they need mooney more


and also rememer that some teams such as melbourne have 3 players worth getting....

ie.

1: McDonald
2. Bruce
3. Bate
4. Miller
........ who is left?

 

[search and destroy]

I disagree with your Scarlett vs Mooney comment as I think Scarlett is a more required player than Mooney. Nevertheless, going by those rules, GC17 could still pick Scarlett and Selwood from the Cats - which I think is very unrealistic. I reckon there are a lot of teams where the top 10 (or more) players will be off limits to GC17. From what I understand about GC17 draft allowances (and I admit I don't know a lot about it), they will have access to uncontracted players from other clubs. Surely most clubs will have the majority of their core team on contracts when the GC17 draft rolls around.

 

[mojon95]

just a game mate... just to try it... most of it is about the picks.... the rest is just to back them up

you in to play tho?

 

[search and destroy]

in response to your melbourne comment, I would take nathan jones or wonerammi (spelling??) from the dees. They are both great upcoming players who have the potential to be guns and would be a steal if GC17 had access to either of them. So I think that even the dees have more than 4 players they would want to keep and would be furious to lose them to GC17.

 

[search and destroy]

I take your point about it just being a game. I'm usually too unreliable with bigfooty stuff so I'll pass on it. thanks.

 

[mojon95]

also remember that i can only take one player above 25, so it's impossible to take those 2

 

[Yonnie]

hey, ill play with Kangas thanks

 

[Big Bad Buddy]

I'll play tigers

 

[mojon95]

These are the GC17's preffered players, you now must tell me which four players, i can't have

Adelaide -25: Van Berlo, Porplyzia, Knights
Adelaide +25: Rutten, Thompson, McLeod

Brisbane -25: Adcock, Luenberger, Rischitelli
Brisbane +25:Charman, Brown, Black

Carlton -25: Murphy, Kreuzer, Gibbs
Carlton +25: Judd, Fevola, Stevens

Collingwood -25: Thomas, Cloke, H.Shaw
Collingwood +25: Medhurst, Lockyer, Swan

Essendon -25: Davey, Ryder, Reimers
Essendon +25: Lucas, Hille, McVeigh

Fremantle -25 Palmer, Crowley, Murphy
Fremantle +25: Pavlich, Sandilands, McPharlin

Geelong -25: Bartel, GAblett, Selwood
Geelong +25: Corey, Scarlett, Ottens

Hawthorn -25: Franklin, Rioli, Hodge
Hawthorn +25: Mitchell, Bateman, Croad

Melbourne -25: Jones, Morton, Woneamirri
Melbourne +25: McDonald, Bruce, Davey

North Melbourne -25: McIntosh, Wells, Campbell
North Melbourne +25: Harvey, Petrie, Harris

Port Adelaide -25: Pearce, Ebert, Boak
Port Adelaide +25: S.Burgoyne, K.Cornes, C.Cornes

Richmond -25: Deledio, Foley, Cotchin
Richmond +25:McMahon, Richo, Brown

St.Kilda -25: Dal Santo, Ball, Goddard
St.Kilda +25: Riewoldt, Hayes, Fisher

Sydney -25: McVeigh, Malceski, Buchanan
Sydney +25: Goodes, O'Keefe, Bolton

West Coast -25: Masten, LeCras, Priddis
West Coast +25: Kerr, Embley, Glass

Western Bulldogs -25: Griffen, Cooney, Higgns
Western Bulldogs +25: Cross, Gilbee, Lake

 

[mojon95]

GUYS NOT ENOUGH PPL ON THIS BOARD SO GAME WILL START IN the "Other footy Games" board.....

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?p=12528842#post12528842

 

[Subprime]

I'll have a go for the Pies. Not too sure on the rules though.

 

[strath39]

c.cornes,K.Cornes,S.Burgoyne and T.Boak are my players u cant touch

 

[Stereophonic]

Ill take St Kilda if stil available, cheers

 

[postmanpav]

not 100% on the rules but if the games runnin ill take freo if available

 

[RangaInTeal]

Ill be gold coast... or Melbourne!