Just thought I'd put down those who have any trade value on our list:
1. Jarrad Grant: No
2. Bob Murphy: No
3. Mitch Wallis: pick 20-35
4. Marcus Bontempelli: pick 1-5
5. Matthew Boyd: No
6. Luke Dahlhaus: pick 12-20
7. Lachy Hunter: pick 30-50
8. Stewart Crameri: pick 20-35
9. Jake Stringer: pick 5-15
10. Easton Wood: pick 30-45
11. Jack Macrae: pick 5-15
12. Zaine Cordy: unknown
13. Nathan Hrovat: pick 25-40
14. Clay Smith: No
15. Tom Campbell: pick 30-50
16. Toby McLean: unknown
17. Tom Boyd: pick 5-10
18. Fletcher Roberts: pick 40-60
19. Lukas Webb: unknown
20. Daniel Pearce: no
21. Tom Liberatore: pick 5-15
22. Mitch Honeychurch: pick 25-40
23. Jordan Roughead: pick 20-35
24. Shane Biggs: pick 40-60
25. Koby Stevens: pick 30-50
26. Declan Hamilton: unknown
27. Will Minson: pick 15-30
28. Josh Prudden: no
29. Tory Dickson: pick 30-50
30. Joel Hamling: pick 40-60
31. Bailey Dale: unknown
32. Michael Talia: pick 25-40
33. Sam Darley: no
35. Caleb Daniel: unknown
36. Matthew Fuller: no
38. Dale Morris: no
39. Jason Johanissen: pick 25-40
42. Liam Picken: pick 40-60
43. Jack Redpath: pick 40-60
46. Lin Jong: pick 30-50
49. Ayce Cordy: pick 40-60
How does Stringer, Macrae and Boyd get us picks 5 - 15. I'd ask for at least a top 3 draft pick for each of them at the very worst. They have not lost all value since draft. Seriously underrated a fair bit of our list. Have to keep in mind the nature of the draft, how all players in the draft are unproven.
My Assessment.
1. Grant - pick 45 - 55
2. Murphy - Nil (due to age)
3. Wallis - pick 15 - 25
4. Bontempelli - Pick 1 + more (I am serious in saying this but if he keeps going the way he is, we would demand Judd like compensation, which effectively included 2 top 5 picks + steak knives)
5. Boyd Nil (due to age)
6. Dahlhaus - Pick 12 - 16 (A team in finals contention without a good small forward etc Richmond would most certainly offer a first rounder.
7. Hunter - Pick 25 - 35
8. Crameri - Pick 25 - 30
9. Stringer - Pick 1 - 3 effectively I think hes most certainly in the top 5 players already of the 2012 draft and he is proven so a club would have to give up a top 3 pick or a top 10 pick + good player.
10. Wood - Pick 30 - 40
11. Macrae - Pick 1 - 2
12. Z.Cordy - Unknown
13. Hrovat - Pick 20 - 30
14. Smith - Pick 35 - 55 (due to injury history)
15. Campbell - Pick 30 - 40 (ruckman are a premium)
16. Mclean - Unknown
17. T.Boyd - Pick 1 (plus being one of the highest rated pick 1's in history from junior level I would demand steak knives as well)
18. Roberts - Pick 55 - 70
19. Webb - Unknown
20. Pearce - Nil
21. Liberatore - Pick 4 - 10
22. Honeychurch - Pick 25 - 35
23. Roughead - Pick 18 - 30
24. Biggs - Pick 45 - 55
25. Stevens - Pick 45 - 60
26. Hamiliton - Unknown
27. Minson - Pick 25 - 35
28. Prudden - Nil
29. Dickson - Pick 35 - 45
30. Hamling - Pick 55 - 70 (remember we got him as a DFA so his value isn't much until he plays regular senior footy
31. Dale - Unknown
32. Talia - From this season so far if he continues he could get us say 20 - 30
33. Darley - very late pick
35. Daniel - Unknown
36. Fuller - Ham Sandwich
38. Morris - Nil (due to age)
39. JJ - Pick 30 - 40
42. Picken - late pick
43. Redpath - Pick 55 - 70
46. Jong - Pick 25 - 35 (improvement has been remarkable)
49. Cordy - Brussel Sprout Sandwich