Redpath has it all over White as an AFL player.
Red is one dimensional, lacks in areas that should be real strengths for him and he's not a great fit next to our million dollar investment, but he's got a mean streak, he doesn't let a bad start turn into a bad day, he's a decent kick, makes second and third efforts, and he cares about and looks out for his teammates.
Maybe if White had even one AFL standard trait in his game, he'd be a more appropriate 'fit' for our side, but if I had to pick one or the other, it's Big Jack every day of the week and twice on Sundays.