Strategy Trade and List Management thread 2.(...the waiting for the hammer to fall edition)

[JTCWBFC]

Again, why trade Hamling? Keep him and just trade Adams.

Obviously this is in the scenario where he wants to go too.

 

[random260]

Reckon

eMac who at his peak is arguably the second best Kpd + 2 round pick + (next year second?) might do it?



You guys need a replacement kpd quick and eMac is perfect since your in primership mode

 

[gangsta deluxe]

Reckon

eMac who at his peak is arguably the second best Kpd + 2 round pick + (next year second?) might do it?



You guys need a replacement kpd quick and eMac is perfect

Something like that would work well I think. Worried about his capacity to fit into a zone though.

 

[Super Hans]

I'd really like to hear from the club on Hrovat, Stevens, Adams and potentially Hamling all wanting to leave.

I get they're all unique cases, but would like to hear from J-Mac none the less.

Let's not overplay this. Two are going because they couldn't get a game and one because Freo are offering a huge deal.

 

[darthbards]

In fairness to Adams we took a bit of a risk drafting him ahead of the WA clubs. His family reasons are very real and extremely sad and we were well aware of them. I always thought there was a huge chance he'd go home,just not so soon.

 

[Boristown]

Mackenzie is supposedly on decent money (reported as $500K but who really knows). Adams is on minimum draftee wages.

WC would need to pay a huge chunk of Mackenzie's wage for the Dogs to entertain it, surely?

 

[LittleG]

Reckon

eMac who at his peak is arguably the second best Kpd + 2 round pick + (next year second?) might do it?



You guys need a replacement kpd quick and eMac is perfect

You are offering EMac plus 2 second round picks for Adams. Not sure we would do that trade. Adams was tracking as the best kpd earlier this year, while emac has lost his mobility. The 2 second rounders might allow us to get some kpd from the draft.
It's not a terrible trade.

 

[compact72]

Because West Coast aren't too bad for key defenders. McGovern and Barrass are both/will be awesome, and they have depth with Mckenzie.
Freo have **** all.

Because they have McGovern and barrass, he'd be playing wafl.

You never know

 

[Del165892]

If only we werent losing the players in the one position we cant cover... Looks like Shiggsy will be playing full back next year.

 

[go you pups]

I reckon every chance Duggan is involved in a deal for Adams.

Would be nice, but that doesn't help our KPP stocks and our KPDs get younger if we have to draft more

 

[Del165892]

Mackenzie is supposedly on decent money (reported as $500K but who really knows). Adams is on minimum draftee wages.

WC would need to pay a huge chunk of Mackenzie's wage for the Dogs to entertain it, surely?

Yeah I cant see us paying 500k for a worse player

 

[Dogsman16]

Has to involve pick 7. Otherwise he stays.

 

[random260]

You are offering EMac plus 2 second round picks for Adams. Not sure we would do that trade. Adams was tracking as the best kpd earlier this year, while emac has lost his mobility. The 2 second rounders might allow us to get some kpd from the draft.
It's not a terrible trade.

How about will schoey + second rounders(s)

We would do that we know eMac in his prime is better then schoey

 

[Keys]

Because West Coast aren't too bad for key defenders. McGovern and Barrass are both/will be awesome, and they have depth with Mckenzie.
Freo have **** all.

Our depth in KPDs isn't as strong as it appears

Schofield, McGovern and barass are first choice. Brown is leaving as a FA somewhere which leaves Mckenzie who had a below par year returning from a knee injury

I'd suggest any play we might make for Adams would involve Mckenzie. Also Adams would perhaps allow us to move McGovern forward so I'm sure we'll be interested in him.

My son knows Hamling from when he was in Broome (same year at school) so I've followed his career since Geelong drafted him. Was rapt at how well he did in the back half of this year and all his Broome mates were super happy he won a premiership medal

Really hope he stays with you guys as I'd be shattered if he was playing for Freo

 

[JTCWBFC]

Adams, Hamling and 37 for Pick 7.

Pick 7 for Riewoldt.

Sign Nathan Brown as a FA for defensive cover.

Stringer Boyd Crameri
Dickson Riewoldt Smith

 

[Chops]

Reckon

eMac who at his peak is arguably the second best Kpd + 2 round pick + (next year second?) might do it?



You guys need a replacement kpd quick and eMac is perfect since your in primership mode

Keep him at that price
Can't play team defence at WC but can at our club?

 

[Chops]

In fairness to Adams we took a bit of a risk drafting him ahead of the WA clubs. His family reasons are very real and extremely sad and we were well aware of them. I always thought there was a huge chance he'd go home,just not so soon.

That's BS sorry. Players move states all the time, WA and even SA clubs draft VIC players.

 

[Cori]

Adams, Hamling and 37 for Pick 7.

Pick 7 for Riewoldt.

Sign Nathan Brown as a FA for defensive cover.

Stringer Boyd Crameri
Dickson Riewoldt Smith

That is a godmode forward line. Make it so.

 

[JTCWBFC]

That is a godmode forward line. Make it so.

Mate we'd score 200 points each week, wouldn't matter if we have no defenders and the opposition kick 100.

 

[JJHunter]

Wtf.. trade Radio: Adams worth 30 to 50

He was drafted at 35.
hasnt shown anything that suggests he wouldnt live up to that sort of pick.
how anyone can suggest anything later is beyond me

 

[GetDimmaBack]

Something big is brewing.

I can feel it in me waters.

 

[Doggy]

He was drafted at 35.
hasnt shown anything that suggests he wouldnt live up to that sort of pick.
how anyone can suggest anything later is beyond me

He's worth a first of some sort

 

[gangsta deluxe]

Something big is brewing.

I can feel it in me waters.

Yes it feels like we are being reamed and the backs are against the wall. A return fire is surely coming.

 

[BRWB]

He was drafted at 35.
hasnt shown anything that suggests he wouldnt live up to that sort of pick.
how anyone can suggest anything later is beyond me

Adams is already the player Carlton hope Marchbank will be and Carlton are being asked for P5...

Not sure it matters where Adams was drafted when he has already demonstrated elite AFL KPD traits.

 

[Chops]

Adams, Hamling and 37 for Pick 7.

Way overs from us