Strategy Trade and List Management thread 2.(...the waiting for the hammer to fall edition)

[Simon Phoenix]

Reckon the Cloke deal is the dead giveaway - agreed by both parties in principle, Collingwood need him off the books, only wants to come to us...deal still not done. Something going on behind the scenes.

This will be one of the last deals done. I think we've agreed to give Collingwood our highest available pick that we won't be using.

 

[geoffjennings79]

Joffa's dedicated his life to helping less fortunate people and comes from a terrible background himself, turned his life around.
He'd make a fine bulldog

So you're saying yes to the trade then...???!!!

 

[Dog Rising]

What would it take to get Jack Reiwoldt? Early 1st round pick and a player or more than that?

 

[jdz101]

Joffa is one of the nicest men I have ever met and a very giving man who spends hours looking after people and his community for zero money and zero recognition.

Id be proud to stand next to the man and his accomplishments outside football so perhaps before you belittle a man check his background and then not look completely ignorant

Are you suggesting we would need to throw in picks and maybe a kicker on our side in an MD for Joffa trade?

 

[Mattdougie]

What would it take to get Jack Reiwoldt? Early 1st round pick and a player or more than that?

How does Jack fit into a forwar line we
have already committed to Cloke?

I know Jack is far better but I think is commmiting to Cloke means we won't chase Jack even if he is available

 

[JTCWBFC]

Getting sick of hearing about the Hawks this week.

 

[geoffjennings79]

Finally! Some light-hearted banter! Hooray!

 

[Mattdougie]

Are you suggesting we would need to throw in picks and maybe a kicker on our side in an MD for Joffa trade?

You don't trade valuable assets you trade lemmings and followers so I'm safe.

You on the other hand ....

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Adams and Hamling for Collins, 2017 2nd round and pick 35?

Not the greatest result for us but best I could do without using Freo's first.

 

[TMoney22]

there's is too much talk of players going out and none coming in. There has to be something else going on.

Riewoldt, Nic Nat i dunno, something

 

[murphy2bedabest]

The solution isn't always in front of you, don't be surprised even if we traded Adams and or Hamling this season that we replace them of note this season.

Don't just trade in a key back for the sake of trading in a key back this season, if there isn't one good enough.

The answer may come next season and I'm thinking it maybe someone like leaver that we make home sick.

 

[DexterTan]

Are you suggesting we would need to throw in picks and maybe a kicker on our side in an MD for Joffa trade?

As long as we get dibs on MD's kids, kind of like a BF father/son rule. Keep the legacy going!

 

[Mezzoculo]

If Jack is gettable and we aren't chasing hard I'll be disappointed.

There is a sneaking suspicion over at the Carlton board that this twitter account is run by a poster who made many, many grandiose predictions... that all proved horribly wrong.

 

[jdz101]

You don't trade valuable assets you trade lemmings and followers so I'm safe.

You on the other hand ....

Oh dear

Me and my saucy gifs are surely worth a mid-late first...

 

[Northernsoul74]

S

Moot point - we take the best available first our first pick, and we desperately need a burst midfielder anyway.
Tim Taranto come on down.

Can you PM it to me mate?

if it's a rumour I really don't see why people can't just post it.

 

[Dog Rising]

How does Jack fit into a forwar line we
have already committed to Cloke?

I know Jack is far better but I think is commmiting to Cloke means we won't chase Jack even if he is available

Cordy goes back and Stinger goes to more mid. Only my opinion but I'm pretty sure we'd fit him in.
Anything can happen in these crazy weeks, but I think we are brewing something.

 

[murphy2bedabest]

I also like the idea of trading for their future 1st round pick.

This gives us a great hand, we can then trade both our 1st picks to GC for 8 22 and 26

Then see if port or north want 2 2nd rounders for 9 or 11

Would then give us picks 8, 9 or 11 plus freos 2017 1st round.

This gives us max flexibility as we keep a 1st rd pick in both 2016/17

 

[Royale]

just post the bloody rumour

 

[gangsta deluxe]

Well he never PM'd me so he should post it!

Or anyone that knows what it is for that matter. Need something positive.

 

[Borgsta]

S


if it's a rumour I really don't see why people can't just post it.

gotta sound important

 

[darthbards]

How does Jack fit into a forwar line we
have already committed to Cloke?

I know Jack is far better but I think is commmiting to Cloke means we won't chase Jack even if he is available

Lol, Reiwoldt wouldn't be worth getting because we have committed to Cloke,unbelievable.

 

[Substance]

I also like the idea of trading for their future 1st round pick.

This gives us a great hand, we can then trade both our 1st picks to GC for 8 22 and 26

Then see if port or north want 2 2nd rounders for 9 or 11

Would then give us picks 8, 9 or 11 plus freos 2017 1st round.

This gives us max flexibility as we keep a 1st rd pick in both 2016/17

Sounds great. Go Dogs.

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

Cordy goes back and Stinger goes to more mid. Only my opinion but I'm pretty sure we'd fit him in.
Anything can happen in these crazy weeks, but I think we are brewing something.

Or Cloke to CHB?? Bevo is capable of anything!

 

[Rookie]

Adams and Hamling for Collins, 2017 2nd round and pick 35?

Not the greatest result for us but best I could do without using Freo's first.

Awful outcome, but in the circumstances may be the best we can get. Maybe we hang onto Adams for a year in the knowledge we end up getting squat for him, because our premiership window is wide wide open and can't afford to go into 2017 with only Cordy, Roberts, our Collins and Morris IMO.

 

[The Inbetweener]

Adams isn't going to be as valuable as what he is now so we have to sell him now. Doesn't mean I'm furious or that I'm confident that we are going to get what he is worth.
I cannot think of a suitable player/s we could acquire in return as they have to be decent as well as a kid. Sam Collins and Alex Pearce are all that I'd want really. I want to re sign hamling but I can't agree to the price freo have offered.
This trade period was meant to compliment our list, not save or re fill it.

If jmac is any good he will have something ready to pull from his ass, and I believe that he will. Go dogs!

Disagree. Could be All Australian next year.