Strategy Trade and List Management thread 2.(...the waiting for the hammer to fall edition)

[ab_83]

Fyfe Fyfe Fyfe.

FYFE, FYFE, FYFE!!!

 

[DexterTan]

If you can't see it as a piss take then....

Again, 90% of what's posted on Bigfooty is a piss take.

 

[compact72]

Can't we just relocate his family down here, and just give them all jobs at the cafe? Problem solved

 

[Jdoggy]

Would Sam Collins even fit into our defence? I keep hearing that he's slow.

Played with Collo in my Donvale Years U16-18. Will admit not a speedster by any means. Has a Cordy feel about him but don't know if he has that mongrel like Zaine. Never the less hes a player that generally stood up and would do things all over the ground and great on him for making the grade. Id love it if he came to dogs but not sure if itd suit him and us.

 

[AnonJohn]

With Adams spending 2017 playing with us, there is also every possibility that he falls in love with the club and no longer wishes to leave. That happened with Nathan Brown and Ryan Griffen, didn't it?

Actually, disregard.

Harry Taylor.

 

[Substance]

If you can't see it as a piss take then....

I know it's a pisstake. Thought this thread was for real trade discussion though.

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

Can't we just relocate his family down here, and just give them all jobs at the cafe? Problem solved

Thats a good idea it works really well in Summer Bay!!

 

[Royale]

Played with Collo in my Donvale Years U16-18. Will admit not a speedster by any means. Has a Cordy feel about him but don't know if he has that mongrel like Zaine. Never the less hes a player that generally stood up and would do things all over the ground and great on him for making the grade. Id love it if he came to dogs but not sure if itd suit him and us.

I watched him pretty closely this year. Had him in my draft sc team. Generally a good decision maker. And he was under pressure a lot in that back line this year. That's the starting point for me. You can build from there.

 

[Doggy]

So has stevens been traded?

 

[compact72]

So has stevens been traded?

Apparentley

 

[Bemoreboyddog]

i dont get why we are going for Nankervis when we signed up Campbell. One of them wont be getting games

We've lost Minson and Goetz. We need more than two genuine ruckman on our list. We need at least one ruckman, I'd be hoping for 2. I want Boyd as a forward long term.

 

[RWnBluey]

Yep prob worst case scenario, now we lose Hamling this year and next year lose Adams with no contract meaning we get peanuts for him

Yep. Freo will play this to their advantage.

 

[Tibes]

 

[Doggy]

Yep. Freo will play this to their advantage.

Who knows maybe he decides to stay longer term.. afterall he didn't actually request a trade

 

[dergert]

Indeed for Stevens but meh

 

[VitalDread]

Pick 68 and off load for Cloke

 

[Doggy]

And saints rob yet another team today

 

[Sentinel]

Should be pick 50 from those options. Which is still unders for the Saints.

 

[Sonsofthescray]

Only worth Pick 50 IMO after we didn't play him in the finals and after we apparently took his contract off the table.

 

[Dav1d]

Who knows maybe he decides to stay longer term.. afterall he didn't actually request a trade

A premiership might change his mind

Also, so long Koby. Best of luck at St Kilda, just not against us.

 

[BRWB]

Should be pick 50 from those options. Which is still unders for the Saints.

Wouldn't rule out next years second rds swapping as Steele trade only refers to future second rd pick - not which club.

And Saints just traded for 23 and 36 from Hawks...

 

[StringyDog]

Good trade by saints, trade pick 10 for hawks first next year (could be about 10 anyway) and generate 2 second rounders out of it

 

[Simon Phoenix]

Saints have traded 68, you would think it's 50 for Stevens.

 

[grassman75]

We would've been happy for Hurley to come to us for personal matters (or money, we wouldn't really have cared). No one here cared that Boyd wanted to cry me home after 1 year while still contracted.

So much hypocrisy ITT

My thoughts exactly. No one yelled and screamed that Boyd was contracted and leaving afterv1 year

GeT used to it fellas - the players wanted freedom, this is what we will see more if I am afraid

 

[TMoney22]

We've lost Minson and Goetz. We need more than two genuine ruckman on our list. We need at least one ruckman, I'd be hoping for 2. I want Boyd as a forward long term.

No problem if its a project ruckman, but Nankervis probably deserves to be a #2 ruckman, much like Campbell. Fine as depth if we dont pay much but even from Nankervis' point of view i dont see him getting much game time. Campbell starts in front of him imo