Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 2 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Bemoreboyddog]

Hill bros
Keath
Martin
Elliott

Can this all be done?

No. Brad Hill would cost at least a first and $700k. Stephen would be around a 3rd and maybe $275k.

Keath would cost a second and steak knives and around $600k. Martin would cost around the same. Elliot would probably cost $450k -$500k.

So that’s at very least a first, 2 2nd round picks, a 3rd round pick and over $2m. Would have to give up something more than Bailey Williams and Bailey Dale to do all that I would guess.

 

[sashdog]

Get Keath. Get Martin. Get Isaac Smith. Get Butler.

FB: Morris Cordy Crozier
HB: JJ Keath Williams
C: Hunter Macrae I Smith
HF: Mclean Naughton Martin
FF: Butler Schache Lloyd
R: English Dunkley Bontempelli
IC: Libba, Daniel, Richards, B Smith

Bonti skipper.

Have a swing dogs.

Completely agree.

This is a serious team.

 

[dergert]

No. Brad Hill would cost at least a first and $700k. Stephen would be around a 3rd and maybe $275k.

Keath would cost a second and steak knives and around $600k. Martin would cost around the same. Elliot would probably cost $450k -$500k.

So that’s at very least a first, 2 2nd round picks, a 3rd round pick and over $2m. Would have to give up something more than Bailey Williams and Bailey Dale to do all that I would guess.

It was a tongue in cheek post as we have been linked to all.

 

[Virgin Dog]

No. Brad Hill would cost at least a first and $700k. Stephen would be around a 3rd and maybe $275k.

Keath would cost a second and steak knives and around $600k. Martin would cost around the same. Elliot would probably cost $450k -$500k.

So that’s at very least a first, 2 2nd round picks, a 3rd round pick and over $2m. Would have to give up something more than Bailey Williams and Bailey Dale to do all that I would guess.

Not that it'd happen, but Stephen is a free agent, so no cost. It's Brad that brings the big cost

 

[Del165892]

Any chance we could convince Tom McDonald to leave the Demons? Would be the ideal recruit for us imo and the Demons are a trainwreck and going nowhere. If I'm Sam Power I'm definitely asking the question.

 

[Bemoreboyddog]

Not that it'd happen, but Stephen is a free agent, so no cost. It's Brad that brings the big cost

Oh didn’t realise. Apologies

 

[Bemoreboyddog]

It was a tongue in cheek post as we have been linked to all.

Sorry mate, didn’t realise.

 

[Bemoreboyddog]

Any chance we could convince Tom McDonald to leave the Demons? Would be the ideal recruit for us imo and the Demons are a trainwreck and going nowhere. If I'm Sam Power I'm definitely asking the question.

He can ask and should ask but didn’t McDonald re-sign a long deal just last year? Especially with his brother at the club, I doubt he leaves. Demons can turn it around really quickly. Still have most of the talent that made top 4 last year. Just too many players having a down year.

 

[Virgin Dog]

Any chance we could convince Tom McDonald to leave the Demons? Would be the ideal recruit for us imo and the Demons are a trainwreck and going nowhere. If I'm Sam Power I'm definitely asking the question.

I'd be keen. More likely we get Oscar thanks to the dud brother curse, but Tom would be a great pickup for us. Melbourne would be in shambles if he left after Hogan did last year. Sucked in to May if that happened though

 

[ossie_21]

2 firsts for Gawn, he looked fed up after tonight’s game

 

[Northernsoul74]

2 firsts for Gawn, he looked fed up after tonight’s game

He was on the bench when the game was lost. Shocking coaching.

 

[maddog37]

Goodwin has the deer in the headlights look.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

We have another gun NGA kid in nick stevens to factor in for next years draft

What's he like. dont know of him apart from a few mentions here.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Must keep Bailey Williams to take Woods spot soon, playing his roll whilst been able to play mid is a plus

 

[Smiley Boy]

Must keep Bailey Williams to take Woods spot soon, playing his roll whilst been able to play mid is a plus

I’m not sure Easton stays in the side when he doesn’t have the captaincy. Let’s be honest he’s been very ordinary this year and others like Bailey Williams have gone ahead of him in my eyes

 

[LittleG]

He was on the bench when the game was lost. Shocking coaching.

Nah mate.

Typical high quality Dees coaching.... like playing players out of position....

I wonder if they are doing it again?

 

[maddog37]

I’m not sure Easton stays in the side when he doesn’t have the captaincy. Let’s be honest he’s been very ordinary this year and others like Bailey Williams have gone ahead of him in my eyes

I wouldn’t be surprise to see Easton Wood have something of an Indian Sumer in his career if he is relieved of the burden of captaincy.

 

[Dogsman16]

Eagles and main board thinking Petruccelle is going to request a trade. Possibly to us. And most certainly to a vic club.

 

[Munnez]

Eagles and main board thinking Petruccelle is going to request a trade. Possibly to us. And most certainly to a vic club.

I believe Petruchelle has an association with Rohan Smith from his junior days

 

[LittleG]

Eagles and main board thinking Petruccelle is going to request a trade. Possibly to us. And most certainly to a vic club.

This is good news. Hope our list manager has at least asked the question.

Much better than Tippa and been a solid player in a team with multiple small forward options.

 

[BRWB]

This is good news. Hope our list manager has at least asked the question.

If even a footy nuffy like me could ID Petrucelle as a target months ago so you'd hope so.

Offer next yr first to help them get T Kelly would want something else plus Petrucelle though maybe one or two second rds. Might be overpaying but really quick fwds don't grow on trees.

 

[Mojorisin]

If even a footy nuffy like me could ID Petrucelle as a target months ago so you'd hope so.

Offer next yr first to help them get T Kelly would want something else plus Petrucelle though maybe one or two second rds. Might be overpaying but really quick fwds don't grow on trees.

Loved him in his draft year, can't see eagles letting him go and if they do it certainly won't be cheap

 

[Munnez]

Given our distinct lack of KPP players I would hope we pick up 1-2 of McAsey, L Jackson, S De Koning and latish Ben Kelly
Of course will be dependent on what picks we have left after the trade period

 

[Dogsman16]

West coast have huge depth in that small forward area. Ryan, Cameron and Rioli.

Right deal presents itself I’d imagine they would trade him.

 

[BRWB]

Loved him in his draft year, can't see eagles letting him go and if they do it certainly won't be cheap

If he is out of contract it doesn't really matter what the Eagles want - they have no hand.

Still would do next yrs first if enough came back our way. Surely Eagles priority will be to get Kelly currency.