Strategy Trade and List management Thread Part 4 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[GetDimmaBack]

P

I am waiting for Tom Browne and co to make a link.

The sad thing is they probably will.

 

[CarnTheScray]

So what is the deal with Lloyd? Do we expect him to come good again next year or is he just full on cooked?

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

I think North would keep pick 2 though.

Yeah think so too, but they need as many early draft pics as they can. Might take it,
Bringing in one at a time will take years to do, if in fact they can bring two top tens each year it will fast track them more, say we have two early ones next year and they have 1 or 2 we can do the Same thing.

 

[ard79]

So what is the deal with Lloyd? Do we expect him to come good again next year or is he just full on cooked?

Fully cooked. We should pay out his contract and move him on.



Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

What....? How would he “absolutely kill it” haha....Doubt it!! If we trade well this year he’s got not excuses for us to not finish 5-3 on the ladder.. win 2 finals is a pass mark

You must have enjoyed the 62 years

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

O

Would take Parker over Hannan

Ahhh no way

 

[Bro_Pro]

You must have enjoyed the 62 years

What’s that got to do with anything we were both talking about....??

 

[TommyD13]

Hypothetically, what would JJ be worth? Thinking pick in the teens, and a favorable second round swap?

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

I don't actually believe there was an offer of pick 30 and Tippa. Not calling Mojo a liar, I just think he had bad info there. The Bombers are going to end up with a glut of draft picks this trade period, I really don't think they will want to trade out required players as a first preference.

Power on trade radio im pretty sure said they hadn’t got to the stage of an offer just the discussion had been around him wanting to go

 

[King Harold]

Lol devastated it looks like he is gone

Trumpet gave much entertainment on how much he annoyed lefty flogs especially “celebrities”

Take heart he won’t be going away anytime soon.( sadly )
I.m going to get great entertainment watching him whine like an EH diff until they march him out kicking and screaming.

 

[Struggle]

**** it, we should just make a play for Caldwell and keep Dunkley

 

[Bro_Pro]

Hypothetically, what would JJ be worth? Thinking pick in the teens, and a favorable second round swap?

Would fit in well at the bombers

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

I have read several posts stating the view that Treloar's disposal is ordinary and I had to really test my memory to see how valid this opinion was. I admit that his kicking style is not classical (but it is certainly more so than Dunkley's), however, from what I have seen, he is at least a long kick and a good snap at goal. Further, whatever technical detail may be missing he easily makes up for it in other skills: speed, hand-balling etc. I reiterate that I think he would be a great addition to the team.
There are several highlights clips of Treloar on Youtube to help people make their own assessment.

I also think that kicking at full pace is more difficult than just normal kicking so he probably gets judged harshly

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Changes 2021

Off
1.Gowers Ugle-Hagan
2.Dickson Stevenson
3Green McPherson
4Lynch. Fast running wingman
5Dunkley Treloar
6Trengrove Rakk
7.Young


Trade
Dale
Schache
Young
Young

Suckling
Durea
Porter

Dunkley 8,9 Essendon
Pick 14 Adelaide
Picks 23,33
Pick 8 to North Melbourne
Picks 11,28
Treloar pick 11 Dogs
Stevenson pick 28
Pick
23,28,33,41,54 =2612 points
Ugle-Hagen will get bid on at 3 after deals with Adelaide and North.
2234 points then minus 30%
=1563 points [emoji108]
Then cherry [emoji523] on top
Trade pick 9 and a second next year to Swans for there pick 58 2020 and 1 in 2021

So in simple terms We deal with bottom 3 teams this year not to bid on UH
1563 points turns into
1423 that’s picks 28,33,54

So ends up like this .....

In
Treloar
UH
Stevenson
Pick 23
Pick 41
Pick 58

Out
Dunkley
Pick 14

The Dunkley deal could and will set us up for 10 years




On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

So our three first round picks, two from the Bombers pays for Trelore and Stephenson and a few late pics?

 

[ard79]

Hypothetically, what would JJ be worth? Thinking pick in the teens, and a favorable second round swap?

Is his value any different to Saad? Late first round I reckon.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Mattdougie]

Take heart he won’t be going away anytime soon.( sadly )
I.m going to get great entertainment watching him whine like an EH diff until they march him out kicking and screaming.

Yeah it’s going to get very messy but that’s the fun of laughing at the USA.

Their election is a farce regardless result

 

[Mojorisin]

Is his value any different to Saad? Late first round I reckon.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Saad is worth more then JJ. Saad worth a pick 10-15, JJ worth 25-30. Irrelevant anyway, his not going anywhere

 

[Freshwater]

Is there any ‘meat on the bones’ with Saad for Dunkley direct swap? We’d have to think about it? Saad would definitely put JJ on notice to smarten up. Apparently he is a very good trainer and dedicated but doesn’t like feedback or criticism. As an fan it looks like a reasonable trade and could work for our club.

 

[Mattdougie]

The last thing we need is another HBF

Trading for Saad would be a joke

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

I’m coming around to getting Trealor BUT keeping that deal seperate to Bumbers Dunkley. I’m sure Pies Dogs can work something out. Bumbers getting involved in a Treloar deal is the easy option for them.

As for Dunkley if we don’t get a WOW deal he stays. Unless we get a deal that gets us Pick 2 somehow and a player he stays. Simple as that.

I would be telling the Dunkleys yes plural as I think whole family is on this that your entitlements are set out in a contract for the next 2 years.

Dunkley wants midfield time as expressed by his manager, well he gets first crack at it and you Dunkley make it so hard that we can’t get to you out of there. If you achieve that the $ will be there come next contract.

Once you get this type of competition and depth in the side with addition of Treloar and you sort the forward line that’s when you become top 4.

Our best midfielder is ageing and knees maybe an issue going forward a combination of Dunkley/McLean is needed.

I agree we don’t need those flogs involved

 

[Mojorisin]

Is there any ‘meat on the bones’ with Saad for Dunkley direct swap? We’d have to think about it? Saad would definitely put JJ on notice to smarten up. Apparently he is a very good trainer and dedicated but doesn’t like feedback or criticism. As an fan it looks like a reasonable trade and could work for our club.

Doesn't like feedback or criticism
Wouldn't be keen as we have as many hbf's as we do inside mids

 

[ummmbont]

So our three first round picks, two from the Bombers pays for Trelore and Stephenson and a few late pics?

And a first next year Sydney’s

And we get a pick 23


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Sharkey66]

The last thing we need is another HBF

Trading for Saad would be a joke

Blokes already jumped ship from 2 clubs, no loyalty whatsoever. Would be wary of picking him up.

 

[Bulldogs Legend]

I’ll be disappointed if we only turn Dunkley into trealor , if we don’t walk away with Essendons future first + change (tippa) at the very least it’s a fail imo

I am confident of that Power was clear on Trade Radio at least two first rounders

 

[Mattdougie]

And a first next year Sydney’s

And we get a pick 23


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

And add one million to our cap when we need to resign Bont