Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Claythesmiths]

Is the poster suggesting trading Freijah a known troll? Because if not that is a Sam McClure level take. Joel is our second most important youngster behind Darcy and I can’t imagine anyone internal at the club disagrees with that assessment.

 

[Dogs Rule]

St Kilda fans are making out like it’s against the Geneva Convention to target one of their players. Meanwhile they treat other clubs fringe players as the Sudetenland, taking it as they please.

They're target contracted players at other clubs, but we go after a contracted player of theirs and they go clutching those pearls harder than ever.

 

[go_sports_team]

Throw the bank, the farm and the corner store at them for Wilkie, chuck in Bevo for good measure. Make it happen Sammy!

 

[Dogs Rule]

Wilkie is one of the best FBs in the competition, can play tall, medium or short.
I think our chances are slim but I like the big thinking

Even if it fails, I hope they have to fork out another 300k a year for Wilkie and their cap gets to bursting point.

Grab the popcorn.

 

[House_of_Dahl]

If St Kilda had half a brain they'd realise that a 30 y/o Wilkie won't be part of their flag push. They'd be better with pick 10 to draft a gun that will be around for that push.

Unfortunately they don't seem to have half a brain and are after Treloar who will be 33...

 

[grassman75]

Good that dogs aren't sitting on their arse but no way in hell they trade him

They do if he wants out

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Is the poster suggesting trading Freijah a known troll? Because if not that is a Sam McClure level take. Joel is our second most important youngster behind Darcy and I can’t imagine anyone internal at the club disagrees with that assessment.

He’s a solid poster. People are allowed different opinions on players

I disagree with them on the Freijah topic

 

[grassman75]

And people were panicking yesterday that we weren't doing anything...

Imagine a Butters and Wilkie off season….**** the Dan Andrew’s statue, there will be a Sam Power one too

 

[grassman75]

Don’t be surprised if Treloar is apart of any deal with Saints should we manage to pry Wilkie out

I hope not Adz is such a great guy, stk don’t deserve him and he doesn’t deserve to be ****ed around again

 

[Dogs Rule]

They do if he wants out

That's the important part. He nominates us, deal there and suddenly the Saints realise that s*** is real.

 

[grassman75]

As good as Wilkie is, Ed Richards is worth considerably more than Wilkie, and is entirely untouchable.

Freijah would be a reasonable ask. Though we don’t really see NBA-style player for player trades in the AFL

I’d hope a Freijah ask would be smacked down pretty quickly

 

[Sentinel]

Saints fans right now:




(Not that I expect Wilkie is actually leaving them)

 

[grassman75]

So you can see why saints supporters aren’t concerned then can’t you?

It’s a cash grab from an agent and you are being used to help. Like we got used for Merrett last year.

And you got used by JSOS this week

 

[grassman75]

I can’t breathe.

So if Wilkie has 2yrs to run and is turning 30 and Richard’s is younger and just extended his deal….what else are you sending over with Wilkie?

And Zac isn’t the answer

 

[JohnnySteel]

Our pursuit of Erasmus as that young inside mid, makes me think the club knows Sanders is off to Tassie. He’d be taking the midfield minutes that Sanders would be getting when Libba / Treloar finish up.

We SHOULD be well compensated if Tassie get their marque signing. He is their number one target as reported.

 

[grassman75]

So what do you think we would ask for?

We have one of the best key backs in the league. Never missed a game with injury. All Australian. Plays on talls and smalls. Good with ball in hand. Can intercept mark. Does it all.

You think we wouldn’t be asking for Richards if this was legitimate?

You can have McNeill and we will throw in VDM

 

[grassman75]

You can take Freijah in the trade. Richard’s - You’d need to package Wilkie with something else.

Trade Freijah….blocked

 

[grassman75]

Reads like a Trump Tweet.

“Greg Size, or as I like to call him, Greg Small In Size. Major loser with almost no players on his books”

Greg Size knows nothing about contracts or managing players…in fact I know everything about managing players, I know more about managing players than anyone…..

 

[54Bulldog16]

Let’s say Cal is currently on $750k for next 2 years. Just to match the dogs offer of $4.5m over the next 4, they would have to extend by 2 years with the last two being at $1.5m.
I know there is a loyalty discount, but that’s a big ask given there current signing commitments.
Prob won’t happen, but that’s a good offer from Sammy.

 

[BrisDog]

Our pursuit of Erasmus as that young inside mid, makes me think the club knows Sanders is off to Tassie. He’d be taking the midfield minutes that Sanders would be getting when Libba / Treloar finish up.

We SHOULD be well compensated if Tassie get their marque signing. He is their number one target as reported.

If Sanders is Tassie’s #1 target, they will be awfully boring

 

[adogsfan5]

It’s not even the player, it’s the leadership back there that I want from Wilkie.

 

[Pencil case]

Even if it fails, I hope they have to fork out another 300k a year for Wilkie and their cap gets to bursting point.

Grab the popcorn.

Exactly. They’ve dug themselves into a hole and we’re just pouring in dirt from the top.

 

[Da Zuumas]

Our pursuit of Erasmus as that young inside mid, makes me think the club knows Sanders is off to Tassie. He’d be taking the midfield minutes that Sanders would be getting when Libba / Treloar finish up.

We SHOULD be well compensated if Tassie get their marque signing. He is their number one target as reported.

Our pursuit of Erasmus as that young inside mid, makes me think the club knows Sanders is off to Tassie. He’d be taking the midfield minutes that Sanders would be getting when Libba / Treloar finish up.

We SHOULD be well compensated if Tassie get their marque signing. He is their number one target as reported.

I’m not sure why Sammy power gave up extra draft picks to go after sanders. Blind Freddy could have told you that sanders was a flight risk with Tassie coming in. Hopefully we’ll be compensated well when he does leave

 

[Snarls Barkley]

Even if it fails, I hope they have to fork out another 300k a year for Wilkie and their cap gets to bursting point.

Grab the popcorn.

Only team it will benefit will be Geelong who will end up picking Marshall for nothing. Can just see it happening

 

[King Harold]

Hope all you guys are enjoying the trip you are on.
I will meet you all on the corner of Haight and Ashbury for some cool aid when he signs