Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[RWnBluey]

Nuffies on Footy Classified say butters is keen to come back home. 4 clubs known to be keen..... Of course we don't make their list haha

According to Sam McClure. So you can basically rule out those 4 clubs.

 

[cherrypie]

Cya Marra

Any context for that? Other than what was already known before tonight

 

[dogsuperfan]

But Harmes is a good guy….not sure how many here know he faked an injury in the 2021 GF in the dying minutes while flogs like Fritsch were rubbing our nose in it so the sub could get some game time. Epitome of a team player

Surely Harmes could’ve just asked the coach to sub him out as a tactical sub. Or was it only medical sub back then?

 

[dogsuperfan]

So what about a three team trade between us, eagles and sydney. We get Harley Reid, Sydney get Jammara and Eagles get Chad Warner.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Another ruck option I like is 20 year old Alex Van Wyk. He is 203cm and more physically developed then Ajang although doesn't have the same upside I'd guess.

Any relation to Dick?

 

[Philthy1]

So what about a three team trade between us, eagles and sydney. We get Harley Reid, Sydney get Jammara and Eagles get Chad Warner.

Sam Power would never do a multi club deal. The Treloar trade period saga proves that.

 

[Mojorisin]

Charlie McCartin (brother of Paddy and Tom) could be an option mid season as key defensive depth. Playing well for the cats at 26 years old he'd be ready to go.

 

[CDBulldog]

bayley fritsch would be my number 1 target this off season

Extra marking and elite scoring

Our ball movement style suits his forward craft

Has been atrocious this year.

 

[DiamondDogs8]

We get Butters, Sydney get Marra and Port get a singular late first round pick. No complaints. Am I doing this right?

 

[Dogsman16]

We get Butters, Sydney get Marra and Port get a singular late first round pick. No complaints. Am I doing this right?

No

 

[W W Biscuit]

I'd do anything for Butters, would work so well in our midfielder.

I'd sell the farm for Butters. Unfortunately. all of them are already owned by Geelong players.

 

[adogsfan5]

Would you ask the question of Sam Walsh?

 

[stefoid]

I woouldnt mind a good upgrade on bramble

 

[weltschmerz]

Would you ask the question of Sam Walsh?

Chronic back injuries are a worry.

 

[CDBulldog]

Cya Marra

????

 

[dogwatch]

Sam Power would never do a multi club deal. The Treloar trade period saga proves that.

Funny, I was just looking at one!

From Draftguru:

886: 2023 Trade for Nick Coffield and Paddy Dow
Carlton	#2024R4 (Fremantle) (-) + #2024R4 (Western Bulldogs) (-) + #2024R3 (Essendon) (#46 - Gross - 0 games)	expected 46	actual 0
Essendon	#35 (#39 - Lual - 0 games) + #2024R4 (Carlton) (#64 - Anderson - 0 games)	expected 46	actual 0
St Kilda	Dow (10 games) + #40 (-) + #2024R3 (Carlton) (#48 - Grego - 0 games)	expected 151	actual 10
Western Bulldogs	Coffield (8 games) + #52 (-) + #56 (#47 - Smith - 0 games)	expected 133	actual 8

 

[dogwatch]

Would you ask the question of Sam Walsh?

Let's just keep this discussion to football.

 

[ossie_21]

Any context for that? Other than what was already known before tonight

????

I believe they mean it as trading him for the capital, to trade for Butters.

 

[bobs head soup]

Sam Power would never do a multi club deal. The Treloar trade period saga proves that.

'Relaxed' Smith gets wish as three-player trade lands on the buzzer

Bailey Smith, Jack Macrae and Matt Kennedy get their trade wishes

www.afl.com.au

On the other hand ..

 

[iambrilliant]

Any context for that? Other than what was already known before tonight

Just saying I’d trade him if it meant landing butters

 

[grassman75]

Surely Harmes could’ve just asked the coach to sub him out as a tactical sub. Or was it only medical sub back then?

Think it was only medical.

 

[grassman75]

Funny, I was just looking at one!

From Draftguru:

886: 2023 Trade for Nick Coffield and Paddy Dow
Carlton	#2024R4 (Fremantle) (-) + #2024R4 (Western Bulldogs) (-) + #2024R3 (Essendon) (#46 - Gross - 0 games)	expected 46	actual 0
Essendon	#35 (#39 - Lual - 0 games) + #2024R4 (Carlton) (#64 - Anderson - 0 games)	expected 46	actual 0
St Kilda	Dow (10 games) + #40 (-) + #2024R3 (Carlton) (#48 - Grego - 0 games)	expected 151	actual 10
Western Bulldogs	Coffield (8 games) + #52 (-) + #56 (#47 - Smith - 0 games)	expected 133	actual 8

That is an awful trade for all involved

 

[Dogs_r_barking]

Quote from the Dee’s board:

Had to look it up to refresh, so Carlton traded this year's first for pick 14 which they used with their pick 12 in that three way trade with West coast and Richmond so they could land pick 3 which was Jagga Smith.
So let's say they traded 8, 12, 14 and 28 for pick 3. I hope that's right it's early in the morning and I just woke up.

Still think getting Croft, Sanders and Freijh was a bad draft.

 

[doggie dog]

Nope….most punchable head in footy. Some blokes I just can’t support and he is one of them

I have Toby Greene as my number 1, and Fritch as 2.

 

[BallaratBulldog]

That is an awful trade for all involved

I think we were right to take on Coffield. He is not a bad player but just a bit injury prone.