Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Ash1337]

Ah the afl just making shit up as it goes along.

Well it would **** over Lions because the get nothing out of it if the AFL approved otherwise Eagles would trade them a pick. In this instance I hope it gets approved.

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

I'm not convinced our forward line can hold the level of shithousery that West + Papley + Cody + VDM would bring.

Four campaigners, what could possibly go wrong?

 

[Mojorisin]

Four campaigners, what could possibly go wrong?

Darcy, Croft and Naughty certainly add to it aswell.

 

[Libbaaaa]

Saints offer to Silvagni in the $800k-$850k range 4-5 years. Madness.

 

[glenashley]

The AFL would be stoked if the Lions, Suns and Giants won the next 10 flags.

True.

The AFL own the southern states.

They know they're not going anywhere so couldn't care less if the next 10 premiers came from expansion teams... Correction, would love if they did.

 

[adogsfan5]

Saints offer to Silvagni in the $800k-$850k range 4-5 years. Madness.

Crazy. Hope he still takes the 4 from us.

 

[TheScriptorWL]

Saints offer to Silvagni in the $800k-$850k range 4-5 years. Madness.

Have at It Saints.

 

[Fossie 32]

Crazy. Hope he still takes the 4 from us.

Wow what have we offered?

 

[RWnBluey]

Crazy. Hope he still takes the 4 from us.

Is nuts. Someone needs to save the saints from themselves. They’re going to have $87 left to pay the remaining 20 players

 

[grassman75]

He wants to be as close to family as possible. Dingley is 80 odd km away and 1.5 hours with no traffic.

Footscray is 50km.

Geelong 60km

Doubt he wants the Dawks. He also doesn't like them.

But he loves Bont

 

[grassman75]

Is nuts. Someone needs to save the saints from themselves. They’re going to have $87 left to pay the remaining 20 players

Nah….love watching them implode themselves….again

 

[Dogs Rule]

Saints offer to Silvagni in the $800k-$850k range 4-5 years. Madness.

Have I missed something? Saints finished Top 4 and are topping up because they're so close to a flag, right? Right?

If you're Callum Wilkie now you just about walk don't you?

 

[Charlie Bucket]

Papley is on the trade block. Probably looks a little cooked considering but maybe dogs should look at him.

I’d be all over Papley for a few years. Whilst our window is still open.

Flea, Papley, Westy… That’d be some small forward line. Essentially replacing McNeil and Vanders with Flea and Papley.

 

[Charlie Bucket]

Whatever else we do in the trade period, we need to go hard at a genuine A Grade KPD.

Has there been a team in the last 11 years that has put less effort in to this area of the field than us?

Robert’s
Hamling
Cordy
Young
Trengove
Adam
Gardiner
Keath
Jones
Lobb
JOD
Buss

Every KPD during the Bevo era (excluding Morris as he was established long before). Not one long term A Grade defender in that bunch.

 

[Bald]

Whatever else we do in the trade period, we need to go hard at a genuine A Grade KPD.

Has there been a team in the last 11 years that has put less effort in to this area of the field than us?

Robert’s
Hamling
Cordy
Young
Trengove
Adam
Gardiner
Keath
Jones
Lobb
JOD
Buss

Every KPD during the Bevo era (excluding Morris as he was established long before). Not one long term A Grade defender in that bunch.

How many long term and A Grade key defenders are there actually in the league?

Jacob Weitering, Harris Andrews, Callum Wilke, Darcy Moore (who I don't even think is a key defender) and Sam Taylor, Sam Collins/Tom Barrass at a stretch?

 

[Optimistic Dog]

Pretty sure Buku is going to the Blues. What will we get late 2nd at best.

 

[Mofra]

Saints offer to Silvagni in the $800k-$850k range 4-5 years. Madness.

That's about average for a thin KPD market. It's less than Battle & Barrass went for.

The cap went up almost 50% in two years.

 

[iambrilliant]

Pretty sure Buku is going to the Blues. What will get late 2nd at best.

We should be going hard for the pick they get for jsos, if it’s a second rounder ofcourse

If they want him we have them over a barrel this year . There’s a low stock of tall backs getting around

 

[The Inbetweener]

Have I missed something? Saints finished Top 4 and are topping up because they're so close to a flag, right? Right?

If you're Callum Wilkie now you just about walk don't you?

Was thinking the same re Wilkie. Surely he’s got his hand out for a big pay bump.

 

[MaxiBont]

If Saints get TDK, Ryan and Silvagni they’re going to be right in the mix (for 10th place).

 

[Doggy]

Why do we have a Saints nuffie laugh reacting in here

 

[Bulldogs85]

Why do we have a Saints nuffie laugh reacting in here

That saints poster has a history of doing it

 

[Testekill]

Why do we have a Saints nuffie laugh reacting in here

Can't say that I have seen one. Of course they probably think that they're poaching Silvagni who we're chasing when in reality they're throwing 5 years at an injury prone player.

 

[BulldogMuscle]

That saints poster has a history of doing it

Just gotta remind Saints fans that Cooper Gretch is the face of the online Saints fandom and that should be enough to embarrass them into retreating.

 

[VitalDread]

Just gotta remind Saints fans that Cooper Gretch is the face of the online Saints fandom and that should be enough to embarrass them into retreating.

You mean
The proud player sponsor of Jasmyn Smith