Strategy Trade and List Management Thread Part 7 (opposition supporters - READ posting rules before posting)

[Mofra]

Contracted until 2027. New deal after that when most of our Hughes to aid players are OOC in 2027 would sort it.

It’s the Curnow example.

A Club wants another clubs gun player.

If they won’t trade him for a great return.

Why do you think we are trading one of the best key backs in the league for magic beans picks and Buku Khamis?

It’s not me being an arrogant opposition supporter either. It’s a very fair and valid point.

Where has anyone said Wilkie would come cheap?

 

[Doggy]

Where has anyone said Wilkie would come cheap?

He's a clown. Thinks saints will get huge overs for everyone

 

[stavro#4]

Where has anyone said Wilkie would come cheap?

One person said: “he will cost a first rounder”

Another said: don’t be surprised if Treloar is used in a trade.


Cmon man

 

[manutd/dogs]

With respect mate. I’m sure he does and I’m sure he will.

But you didn’t make finals either and we both will aspire to next year.

Let’s just agree on what this actually is, his agent wanting a new deal for Wilkie.

Even if you want to chat hypothetical trades, it’s going to be players and it’s probably going to be starting with Freijah +, or Ed Richards +?

I think this will take some topping as the most hilariously delusional trade-related post I see in 2025.

 

[stavro#4]

I think this will take some topping as the most hilariously delusional trade-related post I see in 2025.

So what do you think we would ask for?

We have one of the best key backs in the league. Never missed a game with injury. All Australian. Plays on talls and smalls. Good with ball in hand. Can intercept mark. Does it all.

You think we wouldn’t be asking for Richards if this was legitimate?

 

[Mofra]

One person said: “he will cost a first rounder”

Another said: don’t be surprised if Treloar is used in a trade.


Cmon man

You said "magic beans and Buku Khamis".
If you want to argue against something that hasn't been said, they're are better places to do so.

 

[Benaly28]

Well played.

Make em pay through the nose.

Go dogs go!

 

[stavro#4]

You said "magic beans and Buku Khamis".
If you want to argue against something that hasn't been said, they're are better places to do so.

No issues mate.

 

[Bulldogs85]

Contracted until 2027. New deal after that when most of our Hughes to aid players are OOC in 2027 would sort it.

It’s the Curnow example.

A Club wants another clubs gun player.

If they won’t trade him for a great return.

Why do you think we are trading one of the best key backs in the league for magic beans picks and Buku Khamis?

It’s not me being an arrogant opposition supporter either. It’s a very fair and valid point.

You won’t be getting
Richards who has Re - Signed until 2030 or Freijah anyway Wilkie hasn’t even ask for a trade

 

[MaxiBont]

Why is this nuffie still here

 

[Cudi]

So what do you think we would ask for?

We have one of the best key backs in the league. Never missed a game with injury. All Australian. Plays on talls and smalls. Good with ball in hand. Can intercept mark. Does it all.

You think we wouldn’t be asking for Richards if this was legitimate?

Tom Barrass is similar age and an All Australian, B and Fairest, premiership player and don't think the Hawks gave up Newcombe or Will Day.

 

[Train12]

Oh so Richard’s is under contract… interesting, swear the guy you are offering $$ is as well ?

 

[geoffjennings79]

Regardless of what happens, everyone picking a few picks after the Saints first knows they're a good chance to pick a future gun that the Saints miss... again.

 

[Bulldogs85]

Oh so Richard’s is under contract… interesting, swear the guy you are offering $$ is as well ?

Why are you on our board

 

[Chadley]

Well the response right now is this and some laughing with a few crazy hypotheticals like - Darcy for Wilkie.

But there is next to no concern that anyone thinks this is genuine.

And even if it was, picks would be useless in this situation.

So the ask would be a gun player in return. View attachment 2416268

 

[manutd/dogs]

So what do you think we would ask for?

We have one of the best key backs in the league. Never missed a game with injury. All Australian. Plays on talls and smalls. Good with ball in hand. Can intercept mark. Does it all.

You think we wouldn’t be asking for Richards if this was legitimate?

I wouldn't waste my time with someone who has clearly lost their already tenuous grip on reality. Best of luck with Crazy Sossy.

 

[Sentinel]

Oh so Richard’s is under contract… interesting, swear the guy you are offering $$ is as well ?

The club is obviously just salty because we missed out on paying Jack Silvagni north of $850k, that's how these things work right?

 

[Cudi]

Oh so Richard’s is under contract… interesting, swear the guy you are offering $$ is as well ?

The same Ed Richards we just extended for five years?

The reason Wilkie would be gettable is because you refuse to extend him beyond is current contract.

If you offer him a deal past his current one this story would die straight away.

 

[cleveland]

Saints are after treloar, offering 2 years

 

[Bulldogs85]

Why is this nuffie still here

One reason I try and stay off the Trade and Free agency board because it can become toxic

 

[Unorth]

I will be sick if we do not keep Treloar on our list. He has bled red white and blue since coming over and loves our club to death, it would be an incredibly huge dishonour and disrespect towards him if we toss him out like Collingwood did.

I am so against it I cannot even put it into words.

We selected McNeil/Baker/Arty/Garcia over him for an elimination game after he put up 40 and a goal in the vfl.

The disrespect already happened.

We probably want more midfield minutes for Freijah going forward also.

i would be keeping him but making him watch that game from the stands was wrong and would have been a hard pill to swallow.

 

[adogsfan5]

Oh the turn of events.. happy for a couple days, now on our board and rattled.

 

[Westerndog11]

NOW WE'RE GOING HARD BOYS

Shark eyes Sammy Power smells blood in the water.

 

[Bald]

Saints are after treloar, offering 2 years

Could hardly begrudge him leaving if that's true - there's no way he's getting 2 years with us.

 

[Westerndog11]

No issues mate.

Here’s a door perhaps you’d like to use it.