List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2018/2019 - Part 3

[ChubbyGallon]

 

[ChubbyGallon]

 

[mwhop]

Got to be wary of paying so much just for a cherry on top of the cake when our cake still missing ingredients. Just cos we almost won a flag doesn't mean our list is that great.

 

[JOELY]

here comes the amateur body language expert, but ned guy certainly didn't look as happy getting that deal done as his brisbane counterpart. well done to brisbane, they held firm and got a good deal. for us we got or man, look forward to seeing beams back with us, but i miss the days when we look at a deal on face value and think s**t, we did well there.

 

[neilk]

Just needs checkers to re-sign now !

Fixed

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

"little draft return" great.

Older, granted. But Beams is the better player.

 

[TradeDraft]

41 and 44. Someone do the points!

Still 2 1st Rounder we gave up

 

[unplugged]

We paid more for Beams than Essendon did for Shiel.

Settle down mate. Pick 18 isn't even half of the first round that Essendon gave up.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

We paid more for Beams than Essendon did for Shiel.

Yep. Ridiculous. We’re horrible traders.

 

[Horaceg]

Now the sad part, who gets delisted.

 

[Jafo]

You won’t be crying in your beer when Beams racks up 35 and slots the sealer on grand final day.

GIVE ME DANCING GIRL GIF!!

I think we can think about the cost (picks for Beams) vs possibly Beams getting 20-30 possessions and a few goals. Tag goes to him and Sidey. But then who minds Treloar, Adams, Wells, Sier etc?

If we stay in the window, we take our chances. Might be overs now (maybe), but we get a flag on the back of this, i’ll Wear it every day of the trade.

 

[Frankie23]

Absolute bargain, pick 18 and pick 16-18 for Beams and essentially 32

 

[frizzle]

Two 1st rounds for a 29 year old? um... what else did we get back?????????

Pick 18 this year. 1st rounder next year which hopefully will be in the teens. We get 2 picks in early 40's & give pick 57.
Good deal for everyone.

 

[Matt_352]

41 and 44. Someone do the points!

It's more than pick 32. 791 in total

 

[PiesUserName]

We paid more for Beams than Essendon did for Shiel.

But Essendon's 1st this year is 9 and ours is 18, which we may have had to use on our academy pick anyways.
Big difference between pick 9 and 18.

 

[MagpieJoel]

Expensive, but I think it will be worth it. And if we get our targets in the draft I will be happy.

 

[Jafo]

Brisbane Lions trade Dayne Beams, Rd 3 (41) (on traded from Gold Coast Suns), Rd 3 (44) (on traded from Gold Coast Suns) to Collingwood for Rd 1 (18), Rd 3 (56) and Future Rd 1 Selection.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Yep. Ridiculous. We’re horrible traders.

Said this earlier.

We're embarrassing at the trade table.

 

[dirts]

It’s a fair deal IMO. Would have liked to get him cheap, but wasn’t to be.

 

[Mongo Ming]

You won’t be crying in your beer when Beams racks up 35 and slots the sealer on grand final day.

GIVE ME DANCING GIRL GIF!!

 

[Dammit]

Good deal for both parties. 18 would have gone to Quaynor, Brisbane can use it better as we'll get him anyway with our lower picks. Pick 41 and 44 with 57 going out equates to pick 32. Solid.

This!

Realistically we traded a future first for Beams. Given where and how we finished this year - that's anywhere from pick 10 to 18, which is absolutely fair in my eyes.

If we finish next year poorly and for some reason our pick us in the top 10, then we have much bigger problems to solve than any damage done here.

So, yes on paper it looks like a lot. But when you understand the context on that 18 was essentially a dead pick for us anyway (Quaynor), then one future first (say pick 10-18) for Beams is all good family.

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

If Quaynor and Will Kelly both go in the top 30, we will likely be in deficit for next years draft (assuming we match bids)

 

[Visions]

Pretty sure I could have gone in Monday morning and got this same deal done.

But it took our professional brains trust until the final hour to get reamed instead.

 

[Mkcaptain]

On points the Dayne Beams trade is the equivalent of pick 7-10

 

[Matt_352]

41 and 44 are 774 points