Wills needs to go. Doesnt do enough
Sier needs to be told its his last year and has to put in
We need to get some young mids on our list, i cant name any
List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2020
- Thread starter unplugged
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Wills needs to go. Doesnt do enough
Sier needs to be told its his last year and has to put in
We need to get some young mids on our list, i cant name any
TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
KPP more Important then more Mids
Sorry mate, but if we go into next year with the players you mentioned, especially Mayne, then we aren't winning anything. Players like Mayne, Thomas, WHE and Brown should be depth players next year and nothing more, mayne sounds like a beautiful man but he just can't play footy antmore
johncitizen
Cancelled
we
I will take Buckleys opinion over anyone else's. Including my own
I will take Buckleys opinion over anyone else's. Including my own
Buckleys opinion isnt everything. Im sure you agreed when he publically lashed Maynes contract in the press?
Wills isnt what we need for our midfield. We lack pace and skill. He offers netheir of those
His court case seems to me
That’s one approach. Not opposed to it, along with fast tracking Kelly Rantall and Bianco. Depends how much faith we have in Cox.
- Oct 22, 2020
- 969
- 1,604
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Alright well i definitely think we need someone like brayshaw to firm up the midfield but I agree Hunt doesn't really do much for me. Think he showed a bit off half back circa 2017 maybe but they've tried to move him around since and hasn't really found a role that suits. Tbf you could take him out of that deal and it doesn't change much.
I think Flip is very solid, good sort of citizen and kind of guy to have at the club, and solid player in the best 22 when in form. But he's also the kind of player that has some value and limited growth-he'll never be all aus for instance-which makes him the ideal trade candidate. The degree to which he has been earmarked as trade bait may have hindered his perceived worth in these circles a little.
As for Wills, he’s good depth. But with smaller lists looming clubs will be able to afford fewer depth players. So he might have to be delisted unfortunately
Not saying I'd pay the price...all im saying is that I think in terms of trade worth he is around a pick 14. Remember he is contracted too. Not sure phillips plus 2md or 3rd cuts it.
My perception is the Brayshaw is very slow in terms of foot speed. Am I mistaken about That? If not, wouldn’t recruiting him add to one of our existing problems which is a lack of break-away speed from clearances? Also, isn’t he another whose kicking lacks penetration? We already have plenty in that category.
Personally, I’d like us to train up both Crisp and Maynard as permanent mids. They are both relentless in moving the ball forward (two of our highest in metres gained averages) and both have long penetrating kicks. And they’re both big-bodied and pretty quick.
I think it will be easier to replace Crisp and Maynard in defence (Murphy, Bianco, Mayne, even WHE) than to recruit ready-made mids.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
- Aug 4, 2018
- 321
- 691
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
This, this, this and then some more of this.
We are seriously ******* delusional sometimes...........
Just go and get him, he may not be perfect ATM but fingers crossed he can build with us.
Seriously, what other options do we have? The only other realistic one is Hogan and he scares me after Beams.......
I don't post often but guys this thread is a shitshow of people getting angry with each other and delusional trades... At least it's amusing I guess.
- Thread starter
- #26,363
If we are truly chasing Brayshaw...
Keep our first round this year because we need to snag a first round selection before a bid comes for Reef.
Our future first for Brayshaw with something back. Probably Melbourne's future third or a young player (to the value of someone like Sparrow).
Keep our first round this year because we need to snag a first round selection before a bid comes for Reef.
Our future first for Brayshaw with something back. Probably Melbourne's future third or a young player (to the value of someone like Sparrow).
Darkyprotector
Premiership Player
- Apr 10, 2017
- 4,871
- 2,379
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Investigate value and return
Trade de goey
Trade Treloar
Trade Lynch
Trade whe
Trade Thomas
Trade sidebottom
Move pendels to coaching list management by 2023
A forward line of Keene, Cox Kelly with good crumbers
Apart from the skill deficiencies and bad decision making, Wills can't run and spread to an AFL level.
johncitizen
Cancelled
Nathan Buckley is a legend and his coaching thus far has been exemplary.. most here do not agree. Like I give a *. We are lucky to have him. He has had bad luck from the beginning, injuries , losing a GF by a kick.
Wills will be a more then handy player IMO
Phillips and 2021 first for Bray and their 2020 2nd?
The Royal Sampler
Floreat Pica, Bitch!
Treloar to a wing for centre bounces?
Lost me at trading Sidey and Keane and Cox in our fwdline
TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
Darkyprotector
Premiership Player
- Apr 10, 2017
- 4,871
- 2,379
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Tom McDonald
Tom
McDonald
Tom McDonald on less than Wright
Mitch McGovern on 250 per year for a fourth but not a cent more
Mark Keene
Tohill
Wright has zero defensive side
- Oct 22, 2020
- 969
- 1,604
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Really like this shout. Teams are really good at forcing him onto his left when he wins the centre clearance, and his left is fair dinkum awful. Maybe a slight defensive liability if we have both him and daicos on either wing? We've tended to use our wingers more defensively over recent years (hard to say this year when you can't see at the game). I'd love to see it tried though.
- Nov 26, 2013
- 7,250
- 8,812
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls, Green Bay Packers
Unfortunately I've watched a fair bit of Brayshaw over the past couple of seasons. The shift to a wing was one issue yes, but a significant contributor was a noticeable lack of intensity paired with poor positioning and substandard off the ball movement.
There were times that he just looked flat out disinterested and second or third efforts were very much an exception rather than the norm.
He also has his break out season in 2018 when he came third in the Brownlow following a solid back half of 2017 when he did return from his concussion issues and I don't recall him having significant head knocks since then, so perhaps those concussion issues are behind him now?
Last edited:
Darkyprotector
Premiership Player
- Apr 10, 2017
- 4,871
- 2,379
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I'd take 2 firsts all day for sidebottom
I'd take Merrett
Keenes a better option than brown and wright
More mobile
Stronger
Quicker
More agressive
And suits our crappy entries
Perfect foil
Cox well put a fork in the club if he's traded
Get him a Robin to his batman
Get him a crumber
s**t even 2
We might kick more than 10 goals a game
Or we can waste another golden opportunity
Two top kids for nothing
I really like the idea of Treloar on one wing and Daicos on the other. That adjustment, with Brayshaw in the square, could really work.
It would also mean trading Phillips, coz he really can’t play any other position.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
- Status
