Trade hypotheticals

[Monsterdarlz]

Your most likely going to need pick 1 to get petracca so what are you prepared to give us for him?

Assuming he is a high level talent and tests well at the combine. I would give up Mackenzie strsight swap for pick one

 

[SterlingArcher]

Crows fans what would mckernan be worth? Seems out of favour. Third or fourth rounder?

Put it this way, if the pick you're offering wasn't going to a rookie upgrade, you've paid too much.

Pick 65+

 

[RossFC]

will we start to hear a few delistings this week coming after mad monday? or will clubs likely wait off?

The bottom 10 clubs should be doing it within the next few days.

 

[Tragic sainter]

Assuming he is a high level talent and tests well at the combine. I would give up Mackenzie strsight swap for pick one

Not enough.

 

[Rusty Beam]

Not enough.

I reckon it is.

Mckenzie is a gun.

Not sure why you would do it though. Robbing peter to pay paul.

 

[juss]

Assuming he is a high level talent and tests well at the combine. I would give up Mackenzie strsight swap for pick one

You would need to throw in more.

26 year old defender with no AAs, no B&Fs, no other notable achievements who isn't even the best defender in the comp would not get you pick 1 in a straight swap.

 

[ArdentEagle]

Not enough.

Mackenzie is one of only a few I consider untradeable.
The others are Shuey, Gaff and Naitanui and Lycett.

I'd be happy to entertain packaging Darling as part of a deal.

Darling and 11 for 1 perhaps?
(pure hypothetical as Darling just re-signed)

 

[joop]

Assuming he is a high level talent and tests well at the combine. I would give up Mackenzie strsight swap for pick one

LOL!!!

 

[dajesmac]

Would WB or Brisbane fans entertain the following?

Pick 10 & Fraser McInnes

for

Pick 4 or 5

McInnes is a relatively good KPP prospect. Drafted at pick 28 in 2011, he's yet to crack a debut, although he is behind a pretty extensive list of KPP at West Coast. He's shown an ability to play both forward and back, stands at 197cm and has very good footskills for a tall.

For clubs like these two who may be seeking young KPP talent, McInnes may be a good value option in terms of downgrading a first rounder in a draft that is pretty even from 4-10.

For us the motivation is a crack at Angus Brayshaw. Brayshaw & Petracca are a level above the other mids in this draft whilst other clubs could still take some quality talls a bit further down the list (which we are not interested in per se).

 

[eth-dog]

Brisbane have bucketloads of KPP talent in Bourke, Clarke, Close, Cutler, Freeman, Gardiner, Leuenberger, Martin, McStay, Michael and Smith. Not to mention Hammelman via the academy as a possible selection.

 

[blueiris]

Would WB or Brisbane fans entertain the following?

Pick 10 & Fraser McInnes

for

Pick 4 or 5

McInnes is a relatively good KPP prospect. Drafted at pick 28 in 2011, he's yet to crack a debut, although he is behind a pretty extensive list of KPP at West Coast. He's shown an ability to play both forward and back, stands at 197cm and has very good footskills for a tall.

For clubs like these two who may be seeking young KPP talent, McInnes may be a good value option in terms of downgrading a first rounder in a draft that is pretty even from 4-10.

For us the motivation is a crack at Angus Brayshaw. Brayshaw & Petracca are a level above the other mids in this draft whilst other clubs could still take some quality talls a bit further down the list (which we are not interested in per se).

I think we're chasing a midfielder in either Brayshaw or Dayne Beams with pick 4

 

[dajesmac]

I think we're chasing a midfielder in either Brayshaw or Danye Beams with pick 4

Is he related to Danye West?

Fair enough.

 

[blueiris]

Is he related to Danye West?

Fair enough.

Lol fixed it meant dayne beams

 

[ManOfClay]

Would WB or Brisbane fans entertain the following?

Pick 10 & Fraser McInnes

for

Pick 4 or 5

McInnes is a relatively good KPP prospect. Drafted at pick 28 in 2011, he's yet to crack a debut, although he is behind a pretty extensive list of KPP at West Coast. He's shown an ability to play both forward and back, stands at 197cm and has very good footskills for a tall.

No. Absolutely not. Uh-uh. No can do. No comprehende. Nada. Nein.

You've sold McInnes well there but in the end he's a second round pick originally and hasn't got a game at another non-finals side in three seasons. He is nowhere near worth us downgrading a top five selection.

It would be akin to us offering Alex Greenwood. He's an inside midfielder drafted a couple of years ago but hasn't got a game because we're set in that area.

 

[iBeng]

Would WB or Brisbane fans entertain the following?

Pick 10 & Fraser McInnes

for

Pick 4 or 5

We have an influx of talls coming via our academy boys this draft, as well as Close, Freeman, Paine and maybe Lisle if he doesnt get cut. Dont think you'll see us give away pick 4 when we need it for another midfielder to help out Rock/Rich/Redden. Either by trade or draft.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Casboult at Carlton still hasn't come to terms with the blues and maybe up for trade. Any interest?

 

[cotter101]

Would WB or Brisbane fans entertain the following?

Pick 10 & Fraser McInnes

for

Pick 4 or 5

McInnes is a relatively good KPP prospect. Drafted at pick 28 in 2011, he's yet to crack a debut, although he is behind a pretty extensive list of KPP at West Coast. He's shown an ability to play both forward and back, stands at 197cm and has very good footskills for a tall.

For clubs like these two who may be seeking young KPP talent, McInnes may be a good value option in terms of downgrading a first rounder in a draft that is pretty even from 4-10.

For us the motivation is a crack at Angus Brayshaw. Brayshaw & Petracca are a level above the other mids in this draft whilst other clubs could still take some quality talls a bit further down the list (which we are not interested in per se).

Not a chance. We've already got Gardiner, Close, Freeman, Clarke, Bourke and McStay who have all shown more than McInnes. Not to mention we'll likely add another two KPP's via the academy.

 

[eth-dog]

Casboult at Carlton still hasn't come to terms with the blues and maybe up for trade. Any interest?

Richmond will offer their 2nd round pick no doubt

 

[Masto]

I'm interested in a player for player trade for Kane Lucas, who seems to be on the move. Which fringe player from the Eagles would Blues fans be interested in?

 

[Lemma]

Worth of Brad McKenzie? 2nd round?

 

[Cleric]

Pick 9 and Kerridge for Aish?

 

[dlanod]

Pick 9 and Kerridge for Aish?

Call me insane but I'd at least consider that. Kerridge is solid and pick 9 isn't that far off Aish's pick 7.

 

[Theo X]

You'd only do it if Aish wanted out though.

 

[Jeremias]

I'm interested in a player for player trade for Kane Lucas, who seems to be on the move. Which fringe player from the Eagles would Blues fans be interested in?

It's a good question and to be honest there aren't too many players on your list I'd be looking at as a realistic trade for Lucas. McInness is perhaps the only player I'd have any genuine interest in.

If we are to trade him to West Coast I'd probably rather a draft pick come the other way.

 

[Andre the Giant]

Pick 9 and Kerridge for Aish?

Would of thought Brisbane Lions are intent on creating a culture where young players stick around.

Trading one of the young stars would take them back to square one.

No way they would even entertain that.