Trade hypotheticals

[bloke_]

Doubt Collingwood would unless he requested it

Which he has

 

[Kramer1]

If all the salaries of players were open and transparent it would be a much better efficient and honest way for the Clubs to display that they are under the salary cap.

They are on display to those who need to see them.

 

[GROTTO]

Pies lose Beams IN - Pick 9
Lions lose Aish IN - Beams
Adelaide lose pick 9 IN - Aish

 

[timtamWB]

Pies lose Beams IN - Pick 9
Lions lose Aish IN - Beams
Adelaide lose pick 9 IN - Aish

Nope.

 

[The GOAT]

Pies lose Beams IN - Pick 9
Lions lose Aish IN - Beams
Adelaide lose pick 9 IN - Aish

Pies getting screwed

 

[NinjaSwan]

Pies lose Beams IN - Pick 9
Lions lose Aish IN - Beams
Adelaide lose pick 9 IN - Aish

Pies lose here, don't see why they wouldn't just trade Beams for Pick 4 + extra

 

[dlanod]

Pies lose here, don't see why they wouldn't just trade Beams for Pick 4 + extra

Agreed. Brisbane has to be willing to give up pick 4, so why would the Pies just want pick 9 instead?

 

[Oddhawk]

Agreed. Brisbane has to be willing to give up pick 4, so why would the Pies just want pick 9 instead?

Pretty sure this has nothing to do with Collingwood or Brisbane...

 

[Dom PC]

Pick 4 & R.Lester >> Collingwood
D.Beams >> Brisbane

Collingwood get a 22 year old big bodied inside mid who's played 50 games and pick 4, while the Lions get Beams? Issue is I think Ryan is dating Zorko's sister, so he might be rather reluctant to move.

 

[joop]

Pick 1 is heading to GWS according to Gerard Wheatley, they desperately want Petracca. This will be a huge win for St.kilda.

 

[GROTTO]

Pick 4 and 9 to Collingwood.
Pick 22 to Essendon.
Aish to Adelaide
Beams and Ryder to Brisbane

 

[Two Planks]

[QUOTE"joop, post: 35300944, member: 125017"]Pick 1 is heading to GWS according to Gerard Wheatley, they desperately want Petracca. This will be a huge win for St.kilda.[/QUOTE]

Will it be pick 4 and a player

 

[GROTTO]

Pick 1 is heading to GWS according to Gerard Wheatley, they desperately want Petracca. This will be a huge win for St.kilda.

Why the hell would your Club do that? You are rebuilding.

 

[Dom PC]

Pick 4 and 9 to Collingwood.
Pick 22 to Essendon.
Aish to Adelaide
Beams and Ryder to Brisbane

We have Berger and Martin - why would we give up Aish for Ryder?

 

[Lionmoe21]

why include essendon in this deal

Pick 4 and 9 to Collingwood.
Pick 22 to Essendon.
Aish to Adelaide
Beams and Ryder to Brisbane

 

[GROTTO]

why include essendon in this deal

Because you get Ryder.

 

[joop]

Why the hell would your Club do that? You are rebuilding.

Because GWS are desperate for pick 1 so it looks like it's going to be something like Shiel & 4 for 1

 

[Joshen]

Because GWS are desperate for pick 1 so it looks like it's going to be something like Shiel & 4 for 1

There is no way you are getting Shiel for a pick swap.

 

[Lionmoe21]

Because you get Ryder.

but it could be a deal on its own, pick 22 for ryder

 

[Shade]

Pick 4 & R.Lester >> Collingwood
D.Beams >> Brisbane

Collingwood get a 22 year old big bodied inside mid who's played 50 games and pick 4, while the Lions get Beams? Issue is I think Ryan is dating Zorko's sister, so he might be rather reluctant to move.

I honestly know didly squat about Lester how is his disposal etc?

 

[joop]

There is no way you are getting Shiel for a pick swap.

We'll see.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Sam Reid and Tom Mitchell for Saints Pick 1

 

[Stylo]

Because GWS are desperate for pick 1 so it looks like it's going to be something like Shiel & 4 for 1

GWS absolutely screwed there.

4 & Jaksch for 1 makes more sense.

 

[joop]

GWS absolutely screwed there.

4 & Jaksch for 1 makes more sense.

No it doesn't. GWS are desperate for Petracca, they will be paying overs to get it. A border line 22 player (played 5 games this year) and pick 4 won't get it done. Chuck in their pick 19 and it could

 

[Dom PC]

I honestly know didly squat about Lester how is his disposal etc?

A lot of Lions fans rate it higher than I do, but he isn't worse than a Mitch Robinson kicking wise if you know what I mean. I'd say average for AFL standard - so not bad, but not above average. Pretty much, the more he has plays, the better/more composed he gets.