Trade hypotheticals

[Man of Steele]

This was suggested on our board.

Fremantle trade pick 12 to Port for Shaw+16.Port can then give 12 to the bombers for Ryder. Could this eventuate?

What about this one
Beams to Lions
Lions send pick 4 to Freo
Freo send Fyffe to Pies

Fair deal

 

[Punchy Demons]

What about this one
Beams to Lions
Lions send pick 4 to Freo
Freo send Fyffe to Pies

Fair deal

Never going to happen. Freo absolutely screwed
Fyfe >>>>Beams>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>who knows about #4

 

[timtamWB]

Never going to happen. Freo absolutely screwed
Fyfe >>>>Beams>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>who knows about #4

 

[Wargreymon90]

We rate Taberner and have put 2 years into him. We wouldn't ask for pick 12 for him (if someone else to wanted him or we wanted to trade him)

We want to keep Shaw. And he loves the club and wants to stay. So the only way you will get him is if the deal is to good to refuse (ie overs)

 

[Man of Steele]

Thought it would ruffle some feathers ha ha

 

[timtamWB]

Thought it would ruffle some feathers ha ha

It was too obvious, unless you're just that stupid. And you don't seem to be

 

[bloke_]

What about this one
Beams to Lions
Lions send pick 4 to Freo
Freo send Fyffe to Pies

Fair deal

Reading first line > ok seen this before
Reading second line > sounds like a good deal
Reads last line > yep he's taking the piss

 

[Oddhawk]

What about this one
Beams to Lions
Lions send pick 4 to Freo
Freo send Fyffe to Pies

Fair deal

Deal that actuall makes sense..

Pick 4 &Beams to Freo

Fyfe to Hawthorn

Collingwood and Brisbane suck it...

Seriously tho. Fyfe?

 

[bloke_]

Deal that actuall makes sense..

Pick 4 &Beams to Freo

Fyfe to Hawthorn

Collingwood and Brisbane suck it...

Seriously tho. Fyfe?

New deal.

Freo gets Beams, pick 4, Gunstan

Brisbane, Collingwood and Hawthorn can share Fyfe

 

[Oddhawk]

New deal.

Freo gets Beams, pick 4, Gunstan

Brisbane, Collingwood and Hawthorn can share Fyfe

Deal. So long as we have Fyfe Rounds 19 to the GF!!

 

[Bardo State]

New deal.

Freo gets Beams, pick 4, Gunstan

Brisbane, Collingwood and Hawthorn can share Fyfe

Deal, seeing as we'll have him in September

 

[bloke_]

Deal. So long as we have Fyfe Rounds 19 to the GF!!

Actually maybe we could keep him alternating Saturday night games?

 

[Oddhawk]

Actually maybe we could keep him alternating Saturday night games?

Greedy much...

But seriously... Fyfe??

 

[bloke_]

Greedy much...

But seriously... Fyfe??

It's like putting Ablett in as part of the Beams trade

 

[Oddhawk]

I know he was taking the pi$$ but one step to far!!

 

[Taylor]

If Collingwood want Greenwood then why doesn't Brisbane buy him for them?

Brisbane 1st pick to Collingwood
Brisbane 2nd pick to North
Beams to Brisbane
Greenwood to Collingwood

I would like North to 'demand' Collingwood's first pick and a very good player in trade for Levi though.

 

[c4v3m4n99]

Collingwood have supposedly put in an offer for Levi Greenwood from North, which might be the catalyst for a three-way trade to get Beams to Brisbane.

Collingwood give: Dayne Beams and picks 45 and 64.
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood and pick 4

North give: Levi Greenwood and picks 34 and 71.
North receive: picks 24, 45 and 64

Brisbane give: picks 4 and 24
Brisbane receive: Dayne Beams and picks 34 and 71

Thoughts?

 

[SnowRoo]

Collingwood have supposedly put in an offer for Levi Greenwood from North, which might be the catalyst for a three-way trade to get Beams to Brisbane.

Collingwood give: Dayne Beams and picks 45 and 64.
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood and pick 4

North give: Levi Greenwood and picks 34 and 71.
North receive: picks 24, 45 and 64

Brisbane give: picks 4 and 24
Brisbane receive: Dayne Beams and picks 34 and 71

Thoughts?

Ummm no thanks

 

[c4v3m4n99]

Ummm no thanks

As much as I don't want to lose Greenwood either, I still think its a fair deal for all parties.

Greenwood is worth around 20-25, Collingwood and Brisbane (with a shuffle of picks) get Beams for pick 4.

Win-win.

 

[SnowRoo]

As much as I don't want to lose Greenwood either, I still think its a fair deal for all parties.

Greenwood is worth around 20-25, Collingwood and Brisbane (with a shuffle of picks) get Beams for pick 4.

Win-win.

An upgrade for 34 to 24 and a 3rd is not win/win

thats North being r*ped.

 

[c4v3m4n99]

An upgrade for 34 to 24 and a 3rd is not win/win

thats North being r*ped.

Huh? It's Greenwood for 24, then picks 34 and 71 for picks 45 and 64.

 

[Taylor]

North would need a senior body to fill the list hole losing Greenwood creates.

There is no win there for them.

 

[SnowRoo]

Huh? It's Greenwood for 24, then picks 34 and 71 for picks 45 and 64.

Look at it

34 becomes 24 as our 2nd

we gain a 3rd in 45.

then upgrade a 4th

Terrible terrible idea.

 

[c4v3m4n99]

North would need a senior body to fill the list hole losing Greenwood creates.

There is no win there for them.

Suggestion?

I've heard Merrett from Brisbane, but I dont think North needs another 30 year old.

 

[SnowRoo]

Suggestion?

I've heard Merrett from Brisbane, but I dont think North needs another 30 year old.

Ok excluding Merrett

Bris
gain Beams,45
lose 4,24,53
Pies
gain 4, Greenwood, 53
lose Beams, 28
North
gain 24, 28
lose Greenwood, 45

TBH even getting 24 and an upgrade is bottom barrel for Levi.