Trade hypotheticals

[LukeParkerno1]

How bout Hannath and 3rd rounder for Ben Howlett?

Howlett + Our 3rd for your 2nd rounder +Hannath? Not much difference, just would like a pick in the 2nd round.

 

[bone2468]

Howlett + Our 3rd for your 2nd rounder +Hannath? Not much difference, just would like a pick in the 2nd round.

I would take that. just trying to get my head around were would Howlett fit in at Freo?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I would take that. just trying to get my head around were would Howlett fit in at Freo?

Would suit Lyon's gameplan, real hard at it inside player, can hurt the scoreboard too, good kick for goal. Not expecting the world for Howlett, just an upgrade would be good.

 

[bone2468]

Would suit Lyon's gameplan, real hard at it inside player, can hurt the scoreboard too, good kick for goal. Not expecting the world for Howlett, just an upgrade would be good.

Who would lose their spot for him? Neale/Fyfe/Barlow/Mundy/Morabito/Sylvia/Deboer/Sutcliffe?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Who would lose their spot for him? Neale/Fyfe/Barlow/Mundy/Morabito/Sylvia/Deboer/Sutcliffe?

The latter 3 might, definately more skilled than De Boer and could do his job easily. Sylvia who knows, and I won't comment on Mora as we all hope he stays injury free.

 

[bone2468]

The latter 3 might, definately more skilled than De Boer and could do his job easily. Sylvia who knows, and I won't comment on Mora as we all hope he stays injury free.

Morabito who ever wishes injury Upon him will cop a rath i tell ya.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Morabito who ever wishes injury Upon him will cop a rath i tell ya.

Could easily see Howlett taking De Boer's spot though

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Beams and Lumumba for Kennedy and Pick 7

come on

Please don't try putting Harry o'mumba up for a trade make me cringe thinking about him in our colours
Beams for Kennedy maybe don't like beams off field issues , some ugly things hanging over that boy's head

BTW do you want wellingham back we have buyers remorse ! Paid top dollar for a bag of spuds

 

[bone2468]

Could easily see Howlett taking De Boer's spot though

Mmm DeBoer is quite a hard nutt though

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Mmm DeBoer is quite a hard nutt though

So is Howlett, who is better at kicking goals. Howlett is a pretty hard nut.

 

[bloke_]

Mmm DeBoer is quite a hard nutt though

I would see someone with goal kicking in there game being a better fit. I think that's what we expected with Sylvia but he hasn't really done a lot of scoring. It isn't really required though

 

[bone2468]

I would see someone with goal kicking in there game being a better fit. I think that's what we expected with Sylvia but he hasn't really done a lot of scoring. It isn't really required though

Sylvia seems lost tbh

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Sylvia seems lost tbh

aven't caught your last few matches, and only caught bits and pieces of the GWS one as the X Factor was starting...but how has he been going? Surely he would want to be part of a finals team?

 

[bone2468]

aven't caught your last few matches, and only caught bits and pieces of the GWS one as the X Factor was starting...but how has he been going? Surely he would want to be part of a finals team?

Hes been playing terrible. i dont know his Avg possys, but in 5 games hes kicked 1 goal had 2 goal assists and averaging 2.2 tackles a game and 34 fantasy points...

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Hes been playing terrible. i dont know his Avg possys, but in 5 games hes kicked 1 goal had 2 goal assists and averaging 2.2 tackles a game and 34 fantasy points...

So looks like he flat out doesn't give a toss...I guess that is the risk you took with Sylvia. Jeez I hate players that look like they flat out don't care and don't work. Honestly Sylvia has more talent in his little pinky toe than Matt DeBoer and yet I know which bloke I'm picking in my side...

 

[bone2468]

So looks like he flat out doesn't give a toss...I guess that is the risk you took with Sylvia. Jeez I hate players that look like they flat out don't care and don't work. Honestly Sylvia has more talent in his little pinky toe than Matt DeBoer and yet I know which bloke I'm picking in my side...

The best thing ive seen him do is tackle some bloke like full on destroy the poor fella, get back up recieve the handball and snap it over his shoulders for a goal..... then he dissapeared. like against GWS he played a full game for 9 possys 2 marks 2 free's against and 1 tackle... in a whole game of footy.... then Mora comes on has 15 possys 1 mark and 2 goal assists, 1 coming from his kick from full back and he ran all the way to Half forward to kick it to D.Pearce and he kicked his 100th goal. so i know who i would prefer.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

The best thing ive seen him do is tackle some bloke like full on destroy the poor fella, get back up recieve the handball and snap it over his shoulders for a goal..... then he dissapeared. like against GWS he played a full game for 9 possys 2 marks 2 free's against and 1 tackle... in a whole game of footy.... then Mora comes on has 15 possys 1 mark and 2 goal assists, 1 coming from his kick from full back and he ran all the way to Half forward to kick it to D.Pearce and he kicked his 100th goal. so i know who i would prefer.

The only thing that might save Sylvia is you sort of need those big bodied blokes in the finals but sooner or later the performances must match the faith. This is a bloke that would kick multiple goals and get 20+ disposals, even upwards of 30 disposals at his best. Not good enough.

 

[bone2468]

The only thing that might save Sylvia is you sort of need those big bodied blokes in the finals but sooner or later the performances must match the faith. This is a bloke that would kick multiple goals and get 20+ disposals, even upwards of 30 disposals at his best. Not good enough.

only good thing to come out of it is. Every game he has played in we have won.... soooo if we play him every game even as sub until GF day BAM! we have our first flag

 

[LukeParkerno1]

only good thing to come out of it is. Every game he has played in we have won.... soooo if we play him every game even as sub until GF day BAM! we have our first flag

Also known as the 'your kidding' rule lol! The thing with Sylvia is you sort of know he will turn it on against a side....but when?

 

[bone2468]

Also known as the 'your kidding' rule lol! The thing with Sylvia is you sort of know he will turn it on against a side....but when?

Yup hes playing shockers against terrible sides. I think this week is his Last chance to prove himself to the Boss if he doesnt back to the 2nds

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Yup hes playing shockers against terrible sides. I think this week is his Last chance to prove himself to the Boss if he doesnt back to the 2nds

Yet you know Sylvia will do nothing in the seconds! He is sort of a player that will play better in the top side but there is a line...and he has to perform!

 

[bone2468]

Yet you know Sylvia will do nothing in the seconds! He is sort of a player that will play better in the top side but there is a line...and he has to perform!

He has to perform but i have a feeling hes a bit like Dawson no matter how bad he plays he will always stay in the team :/

 

[LukeParkerno1]

He has to perform but i have a feeling hes a bit like Dawson no matter how bad he plays he will always stay in the team :/

Zac is pretty harshly treated, he isn't pretty but he isn't the only full back that is prone to a brain fade...and he doesn't concede big bags against him anyway.

 

[CasuallyDressed]

I'd be keen to throw Blair, Lumumba, Goldsack, Young and Josh Thomas on the block and see if we can get a decent player back or draft picks.

I would hardly be expecting the world for any of them though.

 

[bone2468]

Zac is pretty harshly treated, he isn't pretty but he isn't the only full back that is prone to a brain fade...and he doesn't concede big bags against him anyway.

on the weekend he had a good 5m of clearnace running down the wing and he decides to run into the opposition player and handball is out of play turning it over..