Trade hypotheticals

[eth-dog]

Lyons + 30 for Pears + pick 50. Get it done Disco.

 

[WWSD]

Jarryd Lyons is the man on the table from the AFC.
Luke Lowden + a 3rd rounder would be good.

Would love Sam Kerridge at the Hawks. I rate him highly. Not sure if Adelaide will trade him though.

Also Lowden is very overrated in my opinion. I'm not sure why many clubs are after him. He's been on our list for six years and during that time we've recruited David Hale, Jonathon Ceglar, Ben McEvoy, Paul Johnson, Wayde Skipper, Broc Macauley and Adam Pattison. If I was Adelaide I wouldn't go after Lowden.

 

[WWSD]

We've got plenty of inside mids but seem to want to keep them all.
Clay Smith might fit the Hawks best if you want a bit of speed, he probably doesn't meet your kicking standards though.

Clay Smith would be a perfect fit for our team, but the Bulldogs won't trade him. I'd imagine he would be part of the Dogs future midfield.

 

[thetradesman]

Lyons + 30 for Pears + pick 50. Get it done Disco.

Would never happen, injuries have finished Pears unfortunately.

 

[Prochard123]

2nd Round pick for Jeff Gartlett and third round pick upgrade

 

[Punchy Demons]

Jarryd Lyons and Pick 10
For Toumpas and their 2nd.

Not even close to a realistic trade.

I'll keep Toumpas thanks

 

[Simba Moyo]

Is Toumpas out of contract at the end of the year? I thought he signed an extension before he even played a game..

 

[Punchy Demons]

Is Toumpas out of contract at the end of the year? I thought he signed an extension before he even played a game..

Pretty sure Toumpas signed a 3yr deal shortly after being drafted.

I'm still confident he'll make it as a player

 

[Lethal44]

Interested to what both Hawk and Saint supporters think of-

Mitch Hallahan, Sam Grimley and the Hawks 3rd draft pick to the Saints for Nathan Wright and the Saints 2nd draft pick.

 

[Suma Magic]

2nd Round pick for Jeff Gartlett and third round pick upgrade

His recent incident will likely reduce his value even further IMO. I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't on an AFL list next year.

 

[Footy Smarts]

Would the Dees be interested in a couple of Paul Roos specials in Taylor Hunt and Jesse Stringer? Both shown a bit at Afl level but now out of favour. Maybe an upgrade of our second rounder?

 

[etsal1]

His recent incident will likely reduce his value even further IMO. I wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't on an AFL list next year.

Because he got assaulted? How dare he get set upon and bashed whilst out for his birthday (which he had club permission to do).

 

[spenze]

I dunno if this has been asked before but Andy Ottens, what is his trade value in your eyes?

 

[spenze]

Pretty sure Toumpas signed a 3yr deal shortly after being drafted.

I'm still confident he'll make it as a player

He did sign an extra year during his first season

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Interested to what both Hawk and Saint supporters think of-

Mitch Hallahan, Sam Grimley and the Hawks 3rd draft pick to the Saints for Nathan Wright and the Saints 2nd draft pick.

We won't be trading Nathan Wright and i think we'll probably keep our second rounder also considering it'll be pretty early.

 

[Suma Magic]

Because he got assaulted? How dare he get set upon and bashed whilst out for his birthday (which he had club permission to do).

More being on the piss at 5am (combined with the rumours that he has no desire to play for the blues ever again, and that he also is facing major personal/family issues).

 

[spenze]

Lyons + 30 for Pears + pick 50. Get it done Disco.

So our pick 30 for your pick 50?

Only if you take Camporeale off our hands

 

[etsal1]

More being on the piss at 5am.

Really? Then why wasn't he arrested like the other thugs who bashed him?

He was on the piss so much that when he fronted up to recovery that morning and was fine?

 

[spenze]

What would Shane Edwards be worth on the table?

Second rounder. He'd be worth more to a GWS or Melbourne than some other teams though. His dad was a gun footballer back in the 80s though

 

[spenze]

Jarryd Lyons and Pick 10
For Toumpas and their 2nd.

Maybe Douglas, Lyons and pick 10

For Toumpas and their Frawley comp pick.

 

[Suma Magic]

Really? Then why wasn't he arrested like the other thugs who bashed him?

He was on the piss so much that when he fronted up to recovery that morning and was fine?

Read my edit.

I'm happy to agree to disagree with you about his value.

And I never suggested he should have been arrested.

 

[etsal1]

Read my edit.

I'm happy to agree to disagree with you about his value.

And I never suggested he should have been arrested.

I didn't respond to your original post because I disagree about you thinking he has no value. I want to know why being bashed (ie. the victim) makes him such an unwanted commodity?

You may not have suggested he should be arrested - but you sure don't appreciate that Jeff was the victim. I'm not condoning him being out @ 5am, but that doesn't give anyone the right to assault someone because they're out late.

 

[etsal1]

More being on the piss at 5am (combined with the rumours that he has no desire to play for the blues ever again, and that he also is facing major personal/family issues).

Nice edit to make sure you don't look like a tool.

 

[Suma Magic]

I didn't respond to your original post because I disagree about you thinking he has no value. I want to know why being bashed (ie. the victim) makes him such an unwanted commodity?

You may not have suggested he should be arrested - but you sure don't appreciate that Jeff was the victim. I'm not condoning him being out @ 5am, but that doesn't give anyone the right to assault someone because they're out late.

Him being bashed (of course he is the victim - I never said anything different) has got nothing to do with it. It's just him being out on the piss at 5am.

I don't appreciate your bullshit accusations. Re-read my posts.

 

[etsal1]

Him being bashed (of course he is the victim - I never said anything different) has got nothing to do with it. It's just him being out on the piss at 5am.

I don't appreciate your bullshit accusations. Re-read my posts.

i'm sorry but how do you know he was on the piss?

for someone so sensitive about 'false' accusations, it's a bit rich for saying he was on the piss when you clearly have zero idea.