Trade hypotheticals

[Super Hans]

But if he doesn't want to be there it makes perfect sense

He hasn't indicated that he does want to leave, though.

If he does that's a different story, but otherwise trading a 24 elite midfielder for a team who 'desperately needs midfielders' just makes no sense.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Wont happen as good as Beams is Rockliff is better and we won't trade our future captain anyway.

So says a Lions follower as a supporter of neither side, id take Beams for sure

 

[blueiris]

So says a Lions follower as a supporter of neither side, id take Beams for sure

I'd rather have both maybe you should watch some Lions games

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

I'd rather have both maybe you should watch some Lions games

Nobody's saying he's not a good player. You said Rockliff is better than Beams. Some people disagreed and think Beams is better.

Neither side would do the trade anyway.

 

[nickrebellious]

I'd take Rockliff over Beams

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

I'd rather have both maybe you should watch some Lions games

Dint say i didn't think Tom was not a good player, maybe do a bit of thinking before writing. it was a question of what player was better in peoples opinion. i said Beams.

 

[bloke_]

So says a Lions follower as a supporter of neither side, id take Beams for sure

Nah

 

[etsal1]

How many did Waite kick in the VFL? Grimley would be playing seniors at Visy.

And I hope he is next year

 

[bumsonseats]

And I hope he is next year

I am not expecting a balanced opinion, but interested in what you think Grimley is worth.

IMO he gets traded or delisted.....

 

[bumsonseats]

And I hope he is next year

I am not expecting a balanced opinion, but interested in what you think Grimley is worth.

IMO he gets traded or delisted.....

 

[etsal1]

I am not expecting a balanced opinion, but interested in what you think Grimley is worth.

IMO he gets traded or delisted.....

Well if he's a chance of getting delisted as you say, pick him up as a delisted free agent

 

[eth-dog]

I've been interested in Grimley for a while. Better tap ruckman than Lowden and Hale IMO

 

[grouse mate]

Delisted?????? Jeezus, I know the list is strong but that's crazy.

 

[Oddhawk]

That's where we're at this year. We need to delist 3. Kelly is one, Sewell to retire.... Then it's either Grimmers or Hale gone. Surely Melbourne, GWS or the bully's will give up a 3rd for him

 

[dazbroncos]

Is Ben Griffiths still on the FA /OOC list at Tigerland?

Go Catters

 

[etsal1]

Is Ben Griffiths still on the FA /OOC list at Tigerland?

Go Catters

Yep. And apparently has had a contract in front of him since May. Interesting.

 

[dazbroncos]

Yep. And apparently has had a contract in front of him since May. Interesting.

Very actually..

Looks like Dawson Simpson is out for rest of year for us and maybe for good with his back issues.
Leaves us Hmac as #1 and Blitz as our #2 and nothing else.

Would be very interested I feel….

Go Catters

 

[etsal1]

Very actually..

Looks like Dawson Simpson is out for rest of year for us and maybe for good with his back issues.
Leaves us Hmac as #1 and Blitz as our #2 and nothing else.

Would be very interested I feel….

Go Catters

Saints very much into him.

 

[dazbroncos]

Saints very much into him.

Makes me sad….
We could not offer as much but should offer a 2nd and a player….

Go Catters

 

[etsal1]

Makes me sad….
We could not offer as much but should offer a 2nd and a player….

Go Catters

You'd think Geelong was a more attractive destination though. If Griffiths nominates you, doesn't really matter what Saints offer.

 

[dazbroncos]

You'd think Geelong was a more attractive destination though. If Griffiths nominates you, doesn't really matter what Saints offer.

Would get games too. We bat pretty deep ( not bragging) but that is our thinnest spot. Defininte chances to play a lot.

And wold also help our Forward options too as he can take a grab and kicks a few.

Go Catters

 

[Zach Package]

That's where we're at this year. We need to delist 3. Kelly is one, Sewell to retire.... Then it's either Grimmers or Hale gone. Surely Melbourne, GWS or the bully's will give up a 3rd for him

Garlett would count as one wouldn't it?

If Grimley is indeed delisted i'd be very interested, can never have too many mobile big blokes

 

[eth-dog]

Very much want Grimley. Perfect fit for Essendon. 3rd in line, if either of Bellchambers/ Ryder goes down, slots in and plays 30% ruck in the AFL

 

[halfback dasher]

Hawks will be big players at yrs end ....mark my words .
So with that in mind would love a gauge on value and interest in the following ...
1. Suckling
2. Hallahan
3. Stratton
4. Lowden
5. Shoey

 

[Masto]

Hawks will be big players at yrs end ....mark my words .
So with that in mind would love a gauge on value and interest in the following ...
1. Suckling
2. Hallahan
3. Stratton
4. Lowden
5. Shoey

I could see the Eagles being interested in the Hawks castoffs since our gameplan is largely based on yours. The first two particularly could be of interest but you would think a 1st round pick would be off the table.