Trade hypotheticals

[dazbroncos]

*Kersten.

Probably the most promising of their young forwards.

Not gonna happen. He is the most promising and is OOC but I believe the wheels are turning to get him done.

EDIT - misunderstood context - Yes Kersten is the best of the group and the one he forgot. As for contract, should be sort soon…

Go Catters

 

[eth-dog]

from Freo I'd be putting Duffield and Clancee Pearce on the table. No real reason other than we need to be turning our list over even while we are close to the top. They are two players who we can cover without much difficulty. Pearce is depth and sutcliffe and suban shuffle around to cover duffields exit opening a spot in the 22 for sheridan/mora to make their own.

Duffield? Seriously? Bloke's a gun.

 

[thetradesman]

...

I guess you're just doing well with what you've got then?

Who would want Frawler over Vickery or Chaplin anyway?

Once Astbury comes back and Grimes has a run at it I don't see the need for Frawley.

 

[thetradesman]

Duffield? Seriously? Bloke's a gun.

What would you give up for him?

 

[Footy Smarts]

I would like him as a tagger for a late pick.

Not sure how many picks Geelong will take this draft so not sure how deep we'd be happy to accept. Would you give up your 3rd rounder in the early-mid 40s? If not some sort of upgrade is more likely.

 

[HBFlanker]

Once Astbury comes back and Grimes has a run at it I don't see the need for Frawley.

Ive heard rumours of Grimes wanting to go to Melbourne to link up with his brother.

Jack has been singing Roos' praises form what i hear

 

[thetradesman]

Ive heard rumours of Grimes wanting to go to Melbourne to link up with his brother.

Jack has been singing Roos' praises form what i hear

Really? What would be a suitable deal.

 

[Chaisa]

Really? What would be a suitable deal.

As a neutral, their 2nd rounder perhaps?

 

[juss]

Ive heard rumours of Grimes wanting to go to Melbourne to link up with his brother.

Jack has been singing Roos' praises form what i hear

He's definetely not un-tradable, but it would suprise me. We have carried him through years of injury issues and he "reportedly" loves the club. Wouldn't be completely against it, depending what was offered.

 

[thetradesman]

As a neutral, their 2nd rounder perhaps?

What would their second pick be? Late 20s?

 

[bloke_]

from Freo I'd be putting Duffield and Clancee Pearce on the table. No real reason other than we need to be turning our list over even while we are close to the top. They are two players who we can cover without much difficulty. Pearce is depth and sutcliffe and suban shuffle around to cover duffields exit opening a spot in the 22 for sheridan/mora to make their own.

Clancee I'd be open to trading, but Duffield is way more important than people give him credit for. It wouldn't be as easy as replacing him with Sutcliffe.

As for currency I'd say Clancee an early third and Duff an early second

 

[blueiris]

What would their second pick be? Late 20s?

23 or 24 depending on what happens with Frawley at least that's what it is at the moment

 

[thetradesman]

23 or 24 depending on what happens with Frawley at least that's what it is at the moment

I would do that reluctantly if he wanted to go.

 

[nottenthagain]

If it were not for the ASADA situation I'd take Carlisle over a top 5 pick.

I think your drugs might be stronger than the Bombers ones... Carlisle is a good player but I wouldn't consider him to be worth a top 10 pick.

 

[eth-dog]

What would you give up for him?

At Essendon we have a surplus of his type but on a neutral market a mid teens pick, or a mid 20's pick and a player.

 

[Zach Package]

I think your drugs might be stronger than the Bombers ones... Carlisle is a good player but I wouldn't consider him to be worth a top 10 pick.

he was pretty much the form tall in the comp for the first 3 months of last season. Wouldn't be open to anything less than a pick in the top half a dozen to be perfectly honest.

 

[Pegasaur]

he was pretty much the form tall in the comp for the first 3 months of last season. Wouldn't be open to anything less than a pick in the top half a dozen to be perfectly honest.

Half a season of great form doesn't justify a top 6 pick imo. Definitely worth a pick in the first round though, 8-11.

 

[thetradesman]

He is worth 10 - 20.

 

[TradeDraft]

I have heard the Pies are Keen on John O’Rourke from GWS.

That be a Hard Trade to be done for the Pies. With almost Certain to have the 1st Round used on Moore

 

[Pegasaur]

He is worth 10 - 20.

Helbig is worth pick 5 though right?

 

[TradeDraft]

Interested to see what others think these players are worth from Freo. (I've put my opinion in brackets)

Crozier (late 2nd/early 3rd)
Sheridan (2nd rounder)
Hannath (3rd rounder)
Silvagni (early 2nd rounder)

What would clubs offer for these guys?

Pies could be interested in Hannath as we need a Mature Age Ruck to help Support Grundy and Witts

 

[thetradesman]

Helbig is worth pick 5 though right?

I said third rounder?

 

[TradeDraft]

What about Golby to StKilda for pick 21or22 depending on which pick is Stkilda's second round pick hear Stkilda are highly into him at least that's what Mark Fine said on SEN

and we all Believe Finey

 

[bloke_]

Pies could be interested in Hannath as we need a Mature Age Ruck to help Support Grundy and Witts

I think he's the same age as Grundy. Not really mature

 

[Zach Package]

Half a season of great form doesn't justify a top 6 pick imo. Definitely worth a pick in the first round though, 8-11.

well yeah, that might be his objective worth, but it'd have to be a bloody good offer to pry away a contracted 22 year old key position player we clearly want to keep and someone who would have already walked if he wanted to.

Similar concept to the 'overpaying' for a free agent to pry them away from their current club