Trade hypotheticals

[willoblue]

how about Deledio for Freo's first pick & Crozier?
probably both sets of fans would hate that.
would any team consider Clancee Pearce for a pick upgrade?
Jack Hannath may also be looking for more opportunities.

 

[bone2468]

how about Deledio for Freo's first pick & Crozier?
probably both sets of fans would hate that.
would any team consider Clancee Pearce for a pick upgrade?
Jack Hannath may also be looking for more opportunities.

Crozier or Sheridan plus Hannath and first pick for Deledio?

 

[Pegasaur]

how about Deledio for Freo's first pick & Crozier?
probably both sets of fans would hate that.
would any team consider Clancee Pearce for a pick upgrade?
Jack Hannath may also be looking for more opportunities.

It seems a bit pointless to trade out our first pick and depth for a player who plays in a position we're already well stocked in.

 

[bone2468]

It seems a bit pointless to trade out our first pick and depth for a player who plays in a position we're already well stocked in.

We could play Deledio of half back?

 

[Pegasaur]

We could play Deledio of half back?

Duffield?

 

[bone2468]

Duffield?

Duffield and Deledio our 2 running Half Backs = Dangerous

 

[willoblue]

It seems a bit pointless to trade out our first pick and depth for a player who plays in a position we're already well stocked in.

Deledio can play in many positions & would certainly be best 18 in any team.
I reckon we are in the "premiership window" & need to look at such deals if possible.
kind of like Hawthorn getting Lake.

 

[Pegasaur]

Duffield and Deledio our 2 running Half Backs = Dangerous

I still think we're better off looking for a KPP.

 

[willoblue]

I still think we're better off looking for a KPP.

Carlisle for Hannath & C Pearce?

 

[bone2468]

I still think we're better off looking for a KPP.

Yeh we do need a KPP but you cant dissagree them 2 of half back would cause havic for opposition teams.

 

[eth-dog]

Carlisle for Hannath & C Pearce?

In all seriousness; Tayte Pears?

 

[willoblue]

In all seriousness; Tayte Pears?

I wouldn't but I have zero influence over the club, so you never know. good luck with that

 

[bone2468]

In all seriousness; Tayte Pears?

I'd give Hannath or Clancee and 2nd rounder for Pears.

 

[Zach Package]

I'd give Hannath or Clancee and 2nd rounder for Pears.

i'd rubber stamp this

 

[bone2468]

i'd rubber stamp this

so yes or no trade? or keep wishing

 

[Zach Package]

so yes or no trade? or keep wishing

yeah, i'd do it.

Would lean towards Hannath rather than Clancee though, feel like we've got a fair few similar types to Pearce, but we could really use a mature 3rd ruckman

 

[bone2468]

yeah, i'd do it.

Would lean towards Hannath rather than Clancee though, feel like we've got a fair few similar types to Pearce, but we could really use a mature 3rd ruckman

So the done deal would be Hannath and 2nd rounder for Pears as he is contracted til i think 2015 or 1016

 

[bumsonseats]

What is the general consensus on Matt Suckling....
Bit of talk on the Hawthorn board about who has any trade value that we might be willing to trade out.

My personal feel is that he is a required player, but if we was on the table then the best we could hope for would be a straight 2nd rounder, an upgraded first round pick (no greater than pick 10), or packaged up with our first round pick for a semi-decent young mid.

Thoughts......??

 

[gillon]

We'd be lucky to get a second rounder by itself for Pears to be honest.

 

[thetradesman]

What is the general consensus on Matt Suckling....
Bit of talk on the Hawthorn board about who has any trade value that we might be willing to trade out.

My personal feel is that he is a required player, but if we was on the table then the best we could hope for would be a straight 2nd rounder, an upgraded first round pick (no greater than pick 10), or packaged up with our first round pick for a semi-decent young mid.

Thoughts......??

Would you do Deledio for Suckling + Anderson + second rounder.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Would any West Coast fans entertain the possibility of trading a player to Adelaide and Hawthorn?

Like, maybe Schoey to Hawthorn for a 2nd or 3rd round pick.

Sam Butler to Adelaide for the same thing.

 

[Yoda_]

Of the Essendon listed players;

- Leroy Jetta
- Tayte Pears
- Kyle Hardigham
- Nick O'Brien

could all add something to your team. step right up and offer up your best deal

 

[bloke_]

Would any West Coast fans entertain the possibility of trading a player to Adelaide and Hawthorn?

Like, maybe Schoey to Hawthorn for a 2nd or 3rd round pick.

Sam Butler to Adelaide for the same thing.

As much as I'd hate to say it, Shuey is worth a lot more than a second rounder pick. It would take the Hawks first pick but the Eagles wouldn't do it.

Butler they would give up and it would only take a third I think

 

[RedmanWasHere]

As much as I'd hate to say it, Shuey is worth a lot more than a second rounder pick. It would take the Hawks first pick but the Eagles wouldn't do it.

Butler they would give up and it would only take a third I think

Schoey is short for Schofield BTW.

 

[Suma Magic]

Would any West Coast fans entertain the possibility of trading a player to Adelaide and Hawthorn?

Like, maybe Schoey to Hawthorn for a 2nd or 3rd round pick.

Sam Butler to Adelaide for the same thing.

Sam Butler isn't worth much. Doubt he would leave. Would take a third rounder.

Would prefer to keep Schoey, but if he wanted out then I'd still turn down Hawthorn's second. That would be late 30s, which is slightly unders.