Trade hypotheticals

[bumsonseats]

Would you do Deledio for Suckling + Anderson + second rounder.

I dont speak for the club, but in a nutshell......No
Anderson will be a future leader at Hawthorn if we can get him fit.
Everyone has their price, and I suspect Anderson has significant upside and in his case it is a sellers market.

Why is there this push to offload Deledio.....??

 

[bloke_]

Schoey is short for Schofield BTW.

Oh sorry I read it wrong, in that case probably a second rounder.

 

[ArdentEagle]

Oh sorry I read it wrong, in that case probably a second rounder.

Picks 20-25 IMO.

 

[thetradesman]

I dont speak for the club, but in a nutshell......No
Anderson will be a future leader at Hawthorn if we can get him fit.
Everyone has their price, and I suspect Anderson has significant upside and in his case it is a sellers market.

Why is there this push to offload Deledio.....??

I just think we can get something good for him now and he's not that good, I understand he has a injury but big calls need to be made and he would be one I'm open to offers, Conca would be another one.

 

[bloke_]

Picks 20-25 IMO.

I wouldn't pay that for a guy who is mid 20s and still gets dropped to the WAFL.

I was thinking the Hawks 2nd rounder which will he mid-late 30s

 

[juss]

Would you do Deledio for Suckling + Anderson + second rounder.

Any Deledio deal ain't getting done without a first rounder involved, or definite gun player, of which Suckling or Anderson are not.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I'm talking about Nathan Vardy.

We're not going to get a ruckman like Sinclair or Lycett etc. If those guys move it's for gametime, and Hamish is a walkup start when fit, and Simpson somewhere after him, so those guys are not going to move to us to be fringe options, they will pick a club where they have more certain gametime.

We do need a backup ruck as Simpson and Vardy are not durable, but we will probably have to draft one.

 

[Super Hans]

Of the Essendon listed players;

- Leroy Jetta
- Tayte Pears
- Kyle Hardigham
- Nick O'Brien

could all add something to your team. step right up and offer up your best deal

I'd give a third round pick for Obrien. He has been dominate in the VFL this year.

 

[Ambrosia]

We're not going to get a ruckman like Sinclair or Lycett etc. If those guys move it's for gametime, and Hamish is a walkup start when fit, and Simpson somewhere after him, so those guys are not going to move to us to be fringe options, they will pick a club where they have more certain gametime.

We do need a backup ruck as Simpson and Vardy are not durable, but we will probably have to draft one.

I see Sinclair as more a forward ruck of which Geelong only have one.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I see Sinclair as more a forward ruck of which Geelong only have one.

Yeah but they have Kersten and Walker as key forwards they rate and Blicavs best position is 2nd ruck.

If I am Sinclair I look for a club where I can get more gametime, I would be happy to have him but I don't see why he would want to come.

 

[BlueMaster1]

My possible predictions

Mitchell - Carlton
Gaff - ST Kilda
Garlett - Sydney
Trengrove - Adelaide
Kennedy - Port Adelaide
Higgins - Carlton
Malceski - ? Any where in melbounre
Frawley - Hawthorn
O'Rouke - Collingwood
Frost - GWS
Golby - ST Kilda
Dempsey - Brisabne

 

[RedmanWasHere]

My possible predictions

Mitchell - Carlton
Gaff - ST Kilda
Garlett - Sydney
Trengrove - Adelaide
Kennedy - Port Adelaide
Higgins - Carlton
Malceski - ? Any where in melbounre
Frawley - Hawthorn
O'Rouke - Collingwood
Frost - GWS
Golby - ST Kilda
Dempsey - Brisabne

There's your straight swap.

Interesting you have Mitch to Carlton as that's another team his old man played for.

Also, with Golby to St Kilda and Dempsey to Brisbane, what about a Saint to Essendon and there's your 3 club deal.
Maybe Brodie Murdoch.

 

[aussierulesrules]

Maybe Brodie Murdoch.

I'm not really familiar with Golby, but even so I wouldn't be in any hurry at all to trade Brodie Murdoch, who has a lot of attributes to work with (elite marking for his height, probably elite kicking- thumping and accurate left foot-, built like a truck, good speed for his size and shape, good tank, competitiveness and the ability to play forward, back and hopefully midfield- where he could be that "big-bodied mid" who can also push forward, take marks and kick goals). Was apparently Sandy's best in the VFL today, after some promising games for St Kilda about a month ago and will hopefully be back in our senior team next week.

 

[Wild Bill]

Statistics say so. Average 11 goals against/game, 4th best points against and held the 2 best forward sides (averaging 115 and 105 points/game) to 90 and 60 points repectively. Our defence is elite

Roos are top 4 for points against - by your maths we must be elite!!! We also defeated both best forward sides.

 

[BlueMaster1]

There's your straight swap.

Interesting you have Mitch to Carlton as that's another team his old man played for.

Also, with Golby to St Kilda and Dempsey to Brisbane, what about a Saint to Essendon and there's your 3 club deal.
Maybe Brodie Murdoch.

Just a 2nd round pick I reckon Essendon would love to get a earlier pick in the draft

 

[blueiris]

My possible predictions

Mitchell - Carlton
Gaff - ST Kilda
Garlett - Sydney
Trengrove - Adelaide
Kennedy - Port Adelaide
Higgins - Carlton
Malceski - ? Any where in melbounre
Frawley - Hawthorn
O'Rouke - Collingwood
Frost - GWS
Golby - ST Kilda
DEMPSEY-BRISBANE

You haven't explained why Brisbane would be interested in Dempsey

 

[Two Planks]

After hearing Barry Mitchell speak about how his time at the blues ended I doubt Tom will be going to Visy

 

[Two Planks]

I would be happy to trade the cats 1st pick for Tom Mitchell as a starting point. Would be happy to throw in another pick or a player outside our best 8 or 10 as well.

 

[BlueMaster1]

Home

 

[blueiris]

Home

I thought Gold Coast was closer to home for Dempsey

 

[eaglesfan99]

Would anyone trade one of their good mids for lycett such as beams for lycett and 7.

 

[Two Planks]

Would anyone trade one of their good mids for lycett such as beams for lycett and 7.

Unlikely. Would think Cox would retire and Sinclair traded leaving NicNat and Lycett the tag team for the next 8 years. Surely Lycett would be happy with that.

 

[eth-dog]

I thought Gold Coast was closer to home for Dempsey

Played for Morningside, a suburb in Brisbane.

 

[willoblue]

We're not going to get a ruckman like Sinclair or Lycett etc. If those guys move it's for gametime, and Hamish is a walkup start when fit, and Simpson somewhere after him, so those guys are not going to move to us to be fringe options, they will pick a club where they have more certain gametime.

We do need a backup ruck as Simpson and Vardy are not durable, but we will probably have to draft one.

How about Hannath as he is a bit behind the best 3 at Freo & therefore not looking likely despite some OK games.
perfect backup for 1st ruckman
but not forward/2nd ruck option IMO
It just so happens that the number 2 number 1 ruckman (sorry) for Freo is Griffin who could be a number 1 number 1 ruckman at a few clubs

 

[bloke_]

How about Hannath as he is a bit behind the best 3 at Freo & therefore not looking likely despite some OK games.
perfect backup for 1st ruckman
but not forward/2nd ruck option IMO
It just so happens that the number 2 number 1 ruckman (sorry) for Freo is Griffin who could be a number 1 number 1 ruckman at a few clubs

I think Hannath will either be traded or delisted at seasons end for that reason. He isn't a required player really. A 3rd rounder would be good compensation