Trade hypotheticals

Chris_2593 · Jul 20, 2014

Essendon supporters. What is the go with Bellchambers? Wouldn't mind him at Collingwood.

Yoda_ · Jul 20, 2014

Chris_2593 said:
Essendon supporters. What is the go with Bellchambers? Wouldn't mind him at Collingwood.

lower leg/achilles injury early in the season. Still effecting any continuity in his game this year. Sporadic at best without getting any free flowing footy. With only Paddy a mature ruck men, doubt we are letting TBC go, even if it were a serious win for Essendon.

Chris_2593 · Jul 20, 2014

Yoda_ said:
lower leg/achilles injury early in the season. Still effecting any continuity in his game this year. Sporadic at best without getting any free flowing footy. With only Paddy a mature ruck men, doubt we are letting TBC go, even if it were a serious win for Essendon.

I remember him having a good year last year kicked a few bags of goals aswell. Has he been playing in the VFL?

Yoda_ · Jul 20, 2014

Chris_2593 said:
I remember him having a good year last year kicked a few bags of goals aswell. Has he been playing in the VFL?

Every now and again. Like I mentioned, hasn't had a chance for any continuity in his game this year

markm106 · Jul 20, 2014

master bate said:
Port are a fascinating team come trade time I reckon. They have so much young talent but are probably getting to the stage where they consider some moves to round out the team.

If I was them I'd put Butcher on the table and see what you can get for him.
And despite his flaws I'd be keen on Waite as a free agent pick up as well even if he was just depth. Port are getting to the stage where they need to consider having depth so they can reach that next level.

Their weakest spot does seem to be that other option for either 2nd key forward or 2nd ruck depending on how you want to use Westhoff. I'd want Westhoff to play his CHF and floating up to the wing and backline role and not have to ruck. So I'd go after a second ruck who has the mobility to play forward and not get in the way of Schulz, Wingard etc.

I'd be signing Waite as a free agent, then offering up Butcher in a deal with Carlton for Kreuzer with a swap of picks as well. I think Kreuzer would work really well at Port as a back up to Lobbe.

Agree re Butcher. Bulldogs could be another suitor.

Suma Magic · Jul 21, 2014

Jack Package said:
Leroy Jetta? Genuinely think that he's got something to give and it could just be a matter of a fresh start and all that.

wouldn't even take a spud for spud deal, some swapping of picks would definitely get it done

Surely he would be free if we wanted him?

LukeParkerno1 · Jul 21, 2014

Chris_2593 said:
Essendon supporters. What is the go with Bellchambers? Wouldn't mind him at Collingwood.

Not going to be on the table. From all reports we turned down a GWS offer last year. Can't see us going into next season with Ryder and I guess at a pinch Daniher when our aim all things being equal will be top 6. Would have to be an offer WELL ABOVE what we think he is worth and even then I doubt he would be traded.

LukeParkerno1 · Jul 21, 2014

ArdentEagle said:
Wish they'd hurry up and sort it out.
ASADA aside, I'd love us to have a look at Myers and Zaharakis.

Both are not going to be on the table...Myers is our next captain and Zaka is one of our most important linebreaking mids, even your first pick wouldn't get Zaka.

Zach Package · Jul 21, 2014

Suma Magic said:
Surely he would be free if we wanted him?

oh absolutely, I'd consider anything we get a bit of a bonus. I was thinking more 'token pick in the 60s or 70s to get it done quickly' kind of thing. But i guess it depends on how keen you guys are.

We don't tend to announce de-listings as early as some other clubs, probably for this reason, why delist a player when someone else might surprise you with an offer?

Now, Lowden/Grimley? Attainable?

GUMBLETRON · Jul 21, 2014

Chris_2593 said:
Essendon supporters. What is the go with Bellchambers?

Would be playing if he was fit.

Suma Magic · Jul 21, 2014

Jack Package said:
oh absolutely, I'd consider anything we get a bit of a bonus. I was thinking more 'token pick in the 60s or 70s to get it done quickly' kind of thing. But i guess it depends on how keen you guys are.

We don't tend to announce de-listings as early as some other clubs, probably for this reason, why delist a player when someone else might surprise you with an offer?

Now, Lowden/Grimley? Attainable?

Yeah I agree that it sounds right.

I don´t think we will be interested though, but you never know. I think we will prioritise Jeff Garlett this October.

C4[2]Yo`DooR · Jul 21, 2014

Suma Magic said:
Yeah I agree that it sounds right.

I don´t think we will be interested though, but you never know. I think we will prioritise Jeff Garlett this October.

What do you think your mob will offer up for Garlett?

Suma Magic · Jul 21, 2014

C4[2]Yo`DooR said:
What do you think your mob will offer up for Garlett?

We've been pretty reasonable in recent years, but I feel there may be some pressure to try to get cut-throat. Our second rounder will be used on Waterman, so that makes it tough.

We will definitely offer our third, which will be turned down. I don't think we'll add much to that apart from fringe players I think. Guys like Smith would be free I think.

If we were to offer more then I'm not sure if Sinclair would hold much value for the Blues.

If he nominated us, I see it as a tough deal to get done. I personally would value him around 35-40, given he isn't getting a game and reportedly having off-field issues.

BlueMaster1 · Jul 21, 2014

Is Tom Mitchell still injurd ????

C4[2]Yo`DooR · Jul 21, 2014

Suma Magic said:
We've been pretty reasonable in recent years, but I feel there may be some pressure to try to get cut-throat. Our second rounder will be used on Waterman, so that makes it tough.

We will definitely offer our third, which will be turned down. I don't think we'll add much to that apart from fringe players I think. Guys like Smith would be free I think.

If we were to offer more then I'm not sure if Sinclair would hold much value for the Blues.

If he nominated us, I see it as a tough deal to get done. I personally would value him around 35-40, given he isn't getting a game and reportedly having off-field issues.

Agree, it will be a tough task given the likely lack of your second round pick.

ArdentEagle · Jul 21, 2014

bombersno1 said:
Both are not going to be on the table...Myers is our next captain and Zaka is one of our most important linebreaking mids, even your first pick wouldn't get Zaka.

If by chance, Myers did want to leave, what would you place his value at?
***Hypothetical thread***

Oddhawk · Jul 21, 2014

Would West Coast give up their 2nd rounder for Hallahan?

C4[2]Yo`DooR · Jul 21, 2014

Oddhawk said:
Would West Coast give up their 2nd rounder for Hallahan?

West Coast will not have a second round pick.

It will be going towards their father son (Waterman).

Oddhawk · Jul 21, 2014

I'll rephrase that then.

What do we think he's worth. I'd suggest a mid twenties pic?

Thoughts?

bloke_ · Jul 21, 2014

Oddhawk said:
I'll rephrase that then.

What do we think he's worth. I'd suggest a mid twenties pic?

Thoughts?

I think that's slightly overs. He does look like being a great player, but he's still only played a handful of games. Maybe 30-40 would be closer. Late second early third for mine.

DEagles · Jul 21, 2014

West coast trade lycett or Sinclair for a second rounder
Trade Shuey and one of their second rounders for myers and howlett ?

ArdentEagle · Jul 21, 2014

DEagles said:
West coast trade lycett or Sinclair for a second rounder
Trade Shuey and one of their second rounders for myers and howlett ?

I would trade Sinclair for a second rounder, not Lycett. (may get a late 2nd rounder for him)
We must keep Shuey and find another way to bring in a class mid or two.

Miltz · Jul 21, 2014

C4[2]Yo`DooR said:
West Coast will not have a second round pick.

It will be going towards their father son (Waterman).

Trade your second and then use your third pick ( now second) on waterman. All you need to do is use your next available pick after a club nominates him. Doubt a team within the first 6-8 would pick him

markm106 · Jul 21, 2014

ArdentEagle said:
I would trade Sinclair for a second rounder, not Lycett. (may get a late 2nd rounder for him)
We must keep Shuey and find another way to bring in a class mid or two.

Can't imagine WC allowing Lycett to go for a 2nd round pick. Has shown promise this year. Would be wanting more

C4[2]Yo`DooR · Jul 21, 2014

Miltz said:
Trade your second and then use your third pick ( now second) on waterman. All you need to do is use your next available pick after a club nominates him. Doubt a team within the first 6-8 would pick him

Father-Son nomination takes place before the trade period.

Log In or Create New Account

Trade hypotheticals

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Post-Human

Post-Human

Prespakis2Tsatas2Kondogiannis

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Platinum

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Premium Platinum

The Baron of Bourbon

Norm Smith Medallist

Premium Platinum

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

Debutant

The Baron of Bourbon

Senior List

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Platinum

Similar threads