Trade hypotheticals

[Oddhawk]

Trade your second and then use your third pick ( now second) on waterman. All you need to do is use your next available pick after a club nominates him. Doubt a team within the first 6-8 would pick him

Father Son Nominations are done before trade period

 

[ArdentEagle]

Can't imagine WC allowing Lycett to go for a 2nd round pick. Has shown promise this year. Would be wanting more

The value of him to our side even out weighs his current market value too.
95% sure Coxy will retire and become full time ruck coach.

I'd want an offer so good, you'd have to be crazy.

 

[DEagles]

Can't imagine WC allowing Lycett to go for a 2nd round pick. Has shown promise this year. Would be wanting more

How about Lycett for 2 rounder and Ah Chee

Then do the trade with Essendon?

 

[markm106]

How about Lycett for 2 rounder and Ah Chee

Then do the trade with Essendon?

I propably wouldnt trade Lycett at all. As ArdentEagle mentioned Cox likely to retire.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

I'll rephrase that then.

What do we think he's worth. I'd suggest a mid twenties pic?

Thoughts?

Not the type of player we need . We have enough inside plodders . It's the same reason you put him up for trade
If I was to value him 3rd rounder . Or steak knives in a trade like savage was

I know we needs midfielders but not that type .

 

[DEagles]

Fair enough, did any eagles/port or Essendon fans like the sound of something like that?

Think Ah Chee would be a good pick up as well as myers and howlett.

Sinclair and ? to port for 2nd rounder and ah chee?

Then trade with Essendon?

 

[eth-dog]

If by chance, Myers did want to leave, what would you place his value at?
***Hypothetical thread***

Signed on until end of 2016. Due to that, your first pick.

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Think Ah Chee would be a good pick up as well as myers and howlett.

Sinclair and ? to port for 2nd rounder and ah chee?

I think we could get Ah Chee in a Lewis Stevenson type deal . Throw away pick to get him somewhere he wants .

Like Myers not howlett ( fringe 22 at best ) but don't like asada hanging over Myers head so pass .

 

[eth-dog]

Myers won't be traded. Howlett is being played out of position atm, would be a good get for the Eagles (as much as I would love Benny to be the first Essendon player to play 100 games in the #40)

 

[Miltz]

Father-Son nomination takes place before the trade period.

Thanks. Didn't think the loophole would be that easy.....it is the afl after all

 

[Oddhawk]

May as well throw your selwood shuey trade at gold coast for Ablett...

More chance of that one.

Clearly I'm being facetious. Hill is one of our 3 most important players in my belief.

 

[bloke_]

May as well throw your selwood shuey trade at gold coast for Ablett...

More chance of that one.

Clearly I'm being facetious. Hill is one of our 3 most important players in my belief.

Don't see why it wouldn't get done? I'd trade Hill for Selwood in a heartbeat.

Well, Brad Hill.

 

[eskimo]

Would West Coast really be interested in trading Shuey?
How bout Andrew Gaff?

Would gladly give our first pick for either, with maybe a second rounder back our way (debatable?), especially if Frawley leaves and we end up with 2 top 5 picks.

Same with Jack Steven. If saints want another top pick I'd give Melbourne's for him also, in a heartbeat.
A late pick for Malceski so as not to mess with our Frawley Compo, maybe 3rd/4th rounder?

Would any teams be interested in Sam Blease? I like the kid, but can hardly crack a senior game. Same with Tapscott? Apart from that I don't see many players on our list that could attract anything that we could afford to lose, unless the offer was ridiculous. I can't see too many ridiculous offers for Melbourne players coming our way.

I'd be interested in Richard Douglas from Adelaide, for our second rounder? and maybe a 3rd/4th rounder back our way? I think Douglas is probably worth around the 25-30 mark at his best, and our second rounder is a bit high. Adelaide fans?

From all reports Melbourne had a bit crack at David Myers last year, but Essendon weren't remotely interested. Given his better form this year I couldn't see them parting with him now.

Any other teams willing to part something for a top 5 pick?

 

[LukeParkerno1]

If by chance, Myers did want to leave, what would you place his value at?
***Hypothetical thread***

Top 10 pick bare minimum. Worth more to us than he would on the market

 

[footyfan000001]

Adam Cooney or Shaun Higgins and a 3rd round pick for John Butcher?

 

[eth-dog]

Adam Cooney or Shaun Higgins and a 3rd round pick for John Butcher?

Port would sign immediately

 

[Wild Bill]

Port would sign immediately

The 3rd rounder should be enough. No need for steak knives.

Not sure he would be much of a solution or a big upgrade from Jones.

 

[markm106]

Adam Cooney or Shaun Higgins and a 3rd round pick for John Butcher?

30 goals in the SANFL this year, I think the doggies should chase him. Although Schulz will be 30 next year and although he has a few yars left Port won't be letting him go to quickly.

 

[eth-dog]

The 3rd rounder should be enough. No need for steak knives.

Not sure he would be much of a solution or a big upgrade from Jones.

He isn't

 

[POKsPies252]

Brisbane fans, what would a combo of QLD boys Lachie Keeffe and Josh Thomas net us?

 

[RippaRiley43]

Would West Coast really be interested in trading Shuey?
How bout Andrew Gaff?

Would gladly give our first pick for either, with maybe a second rounder back our way (debatable?), especially if Frawley leaves and we end up with 2 top 5 picks.

Same with Jack Steven. If saints want another top pick I'd give Melbourne's for him also, in a heartbeat.
A late pick for Malceski so as not to mess with our Frawley Compo, maybe 3rd/4th rounder?

Would any teams be interested in Sam Blease? I like the kid, but can hardly crack a senior game. Same with Tapscott? Apart from that I don't see many players on our list that could attract anything that we could afford to lose, unless the offer was ridiculous. I can't see too many ridiculous offers for Melbourne players coming our way.

I'd be interested in Richard Douglas from Adelaide, for our second rounder? and maybe a 3rd/4th rounder back our way? I think Douglas is probably worth around the 25-30 mark at his best, and our second rounder is a bit high. Adelaide fans?

From all reports Melbourne had a bit crack at David Myers last year, but Essendon weren't remotely interested. Given his better form this year I couldn't see them parting with him now.

Any other teams willing to part something for a top 5 pick?

Not interested by that personally. Some people on our board would trade Dougie. He's been quite a bit down this year, but I still think he's worth more to us as an experienced player than a pick in the early twenties, especially considering you want a late sweetener back, and we have good picks again this year.

Have you heard of Jarryd Lyons? 22 tomorrow and he has absolutely dominated the SANFL each week since the start of last year (30+ disposals and a couple of goals fairly common), but for whatever reason does not get a fair run of games in the AFL to reward his excellent form, and he doesn't seem to be played as an inside midfielder to help take the pressure off Dangerfield. Much of the Crows board is worried that we will lose a good player in Jarryd for practically nothing. From my understanding, your mob chased Lyons last year, but for whatever reason he stayed here. Wonder if you'll try again. We won't get much for him, will probably end up using him to upgrade our third rounder and watch some other team reap the rewards.

Also, might be slightly off topic, but how's Aidan Riley going? As my name alludes to, he was my favourite player until you snapped him up (I like having weird favourites). Has he done enough to stay on your list for next year?

 

[Two Planks]

I would happily offer cats 1st round pick (15ish) for Shuey from the eagles. Would that be enough.

I would also offer Mitch Duncan for Scott Selwood in a straight swap.

Eagles fans what do you think.

 

[bloke_]

I would happily offer cats 1st round pick (15ish) for Shuey from the eagles. Would that be enough.

I would also offer Mitch Duncan for Scott Selwood in a straight swap.

Eagles fans what do you think.

Not an Eagles fan, but....

Shuey for 15

Scooter for Duncan

 

[ArdentEagle]

Not an Eagles fan, but....

Shuey for 15

Scooter for Duncan

I would happily offer cats 1st round pick (15ish) for Shuey from the eagles. Would that be enough.

I would also offer Mitch Duncan for Scott Selwood in a straight swap.

Eagles fans what do you think.

I'd have it the opposite way around to bloke.

 

[bloke_]

I'd have it the opposite way around to bloke.

Really? I thought Scooter was better than Shuey?

Well from what I've seen he is