Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Trade hypotheticals

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Brendan Goddard supported Carlton, Stewart Crameri supported Essendon, Angus Monfries supported Adelaide, Chris Judd supported Melbourne, Bachar Houli supported Carlton, I could go on. Means sweet FA
 
Igloo said:
I'd rather have Henderson and pick 6 rather than Boyd, tbh.
Click to expand...

Pick 6 won't be included with Henderson.

GWS have openly been pleading for quality 23/24yo's to go to their Club. They would be absolutely wrapped to have Henderson to partner Phil Davis for 8 years.

Carlton get Boyd.
GWS get Henderson.
Boyd gets to play in Melbourne for his preferred Club.
Henderson gets a big pay rise.

As usual with GWS, the sticking point will be getting the quality 24yo to agree to go there. But that might be changing now that their uncompetitive years are passing.

IF....IF....Boyd wants to leave, to me it is the deal that makes sense all round and might be do-able.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Igloo said:
I'd rather have Henderson and pick 6 rather than Boyd, tbh.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't.

The trade table is a gamble. You need to give to get back especially when the player you are after is contracted.

A contracted Boyd is likely going nowhere this year and if he does clubs will have to pay a premium. Even pick 1 alone likely doesn't get him. You would need to throw in player (obviously not to the level of Henderson) or pick upgrade down the draft order.
 
Last edited:
Nemisis said:
Westhoff is a champion player - full stop. he's not going anywhere but would be worth a fair bit to premiership contenders Freo and the Hawks
A unique talent that doesn't get the accolades he deserves.
Click to expand...
He's a good player, not even close to a great player let alone champion.
 
TerryWallet said:
Pick 6 won't be included with Henderson.

GWS have openly been pleading for quality 23/24yo's to go to their Club. They would be absolutely wrapped to have Henderson to partner Phil Davis for 8 years.

Carlton get Boyd.
GWS get Henderson.
Boyd gets to play in Melbourne for his preferred Club.
Henderson gets a big pay rise.

As usual with GWS, the sticking point will be getting the quality 24yo to agree to go there. But that might be changing now that their uncompetitive years are passing.

IF....IF....Boyd wants to leave, to me it is the deal that makes sense all round and might be do-able.
Click to expand...

Your essentially saying Henderson is worth pick one. He's not in my opinion.
 
If you seriously think GWS will trade Boyd for Henderson you're off ya rocker. More chance of Melbourne making this year's GF
 
Oddhawk said:
Ummm I didn't say a spud for Boyd....

Shoeys no longer a whipping boy.
Click to expand...
Clangers? Maybe not within the club but outside of the club...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

eth-dog said:
Clangers? Maybe not within the club but outside of the club...
Click to expand...

Shoey has had ONE for the year... ONE

Brent Stanton has had 28....

Just let that sink in...
 
Last edited:
But Ryan is a forward. Doesn't need to defend. Has simply been made to defend over the last while.
 
Oddhawk said:
But Ryan is a forward. Doesn't need to defend. Has simply been made to defend over the last while.
Click to expand...
I never said he was a defender.

Dawson is a better defender then Shoey is a forward
 
Oddhawk said:
Shoey has had ONE for the year... ONE

Brent Stanton has had 28....

Just let that sink in...
Click to expand...
I call bullshit. Every time I see him he has 2-3 howlers
 
Oh ouch,

I reckon I may be looking at clearances!!

Feel a bit like a d**k

Struggling to find the stat now
 
Last edited:

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Yeah just found that myself.

See comment above.

Either way... Point of that was would be as much chance of Shoey for Boyd as there would be Henderson for Boyd

Either way it's bucleys!!
 
Oddhawk said:
Yeah just found that myself.

See comment above.

Either way... Point of that was would be as much chance of Shoey for Boyd as there would be Henderson for Boyd

Either way it's bucleys!!
Click to expand...
Nah, Hendo would be a 1% chance, Schoey 0.000000000001%
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom