Trade hypotheticals

[thetradesman]

How's this HYPOTHETICAL DEAL.

Carlton gain - Tom Boyd

Richmond gain - Will Hoskin Elliot

GWS gain - Gibbs, Pick 6, pick 9?

 

[Lionmoe21]

How's this HYPOTHETICAL DEAL.

Carlton gain - Tom Boyd

Richmond gain - Will Hoskin Elliot

GWS gain - Gibbs, Pick 6, pick 9?

Why would carlton trade someone they signed long term about a month ago, I know it's hypothetical but still it has make some kind of sense

 

[Lionmoe21]

Just FYI, I think it's a fair deal

 

[bloke_]

Fair enough I reckon.

I wanna see more 3 way trades in this thread.

 

[arrow_dactyl]

Fair enough I reckon.

I wanna see more 3 way trades in this thread.

J Griffin to Port from the Dockers

Jake Neade + 2nd round to Essendon

Tayte Pears + 2nd Round to Dockers

Thoughts?

 

[thetradesman]

J Griffin to Port from the Dockers

Jake Neade + 2nd round to Essendon

Tayte Pears + 2nd Round to Dockers

Thoughts?

Yeah pretty fair.

 

[bloke_]

J Griffin to Port from the Dockers

Jake Neade + 2nd round to Essendon

Tayte Pears + 2nd Round to Dockers

Thoughts?

Lets do it

 

[thetradesman]

Melbourne gain - Dylan Shiel

Carlton gain - Jacsch

GWS gain - pick 4, pick 6?

 

[Theo X]

Melbourne gain - Dylan Shiel

Carlton gain - Jacsch

GWS gain - pick 4, pick 6?

Yes please! biased in our favour too much though.

 

[thetradesman]

Yes please! biased in our favour too much though.

Pick 4 = Shiel

Pick 6 = Jacsh

 

[Theo X]

Pick 4 = Shiel

Pick 6 = Jacsh

I get that. Carlton are overpaying. GWS get unders, we make out like bandits.

 

[thetradesman]

I get that. Carlton are overpaying. GWS get unders, we make out like bandits.

Not sure if overrating the pick 4 or Shiel.

 

[Theo X]

Not sure if overrating the pick 4 or Shiel.

I think Shiel is easily better than what we would get for pick 4 this year in the draft. Maybe I'm overrating Shiel.

 

[Bob77]

J Griffin to Port from the Dockers

Jake Neade + 2nd round to Essendon

Tayte Pears + 2nd Round to Dockers

Thoughts?

Essendon don't have a second rounder this year, and Griffin for a second rounder and a player seems over the top. How about:

Fremantle get Pears and Port's 3rd rounder
Port get Griffin and Essendon's 3rd rounder
Essendon get Port's 2nd rounder

 

[Defacto]

You wot?

Seriously horrible, horrible trade from a swans perspective

i concede defeat.

 

[bloke_]

Essendon don't have a second rounder this year, and Griffin for a second rounder and a player seems over the top. How about:

Fremantle get Pears and Port's 3rd rounder
Port get Griffin and Essendon's 3rd rounder
Essendon get Port's 2nd rounder

Could work. I think Port would be giving too much for what they're getting though

 

[bloke_]

How bout

Freo get Mason Shaw and Bombers third (48?)
Port get Pears and Griffen
Bombers get Freos second 36

Am I underating Pears?

 

[thetradesman]

I think Shiel is easily better than what we would get for pick 4 this year in the draft. Maybe I'm overrating Shiel.

I think so, Wright, Brayshaw both will probably be there.

It's fair IMO.

 

[arrow_dactyl]

Essendon don't have a second rounder this year, and Griffin for a second rounder and a player seems over the top. How about:

Fremantle get Pears and Port's 3rd rounder
Port get Griffin and Essendon's 3rd rounder
Essendon get Port's 2nd rounder

Forgot about that, you're changes might work, depending what picks port finish with.

 

[thetradesman]

Carlisle to the doggies for pick 6 + fringe?

 

[pinot]

How's this HYPOTHETICAL DEAL.

Carlton gain - Tom Boyd

Richmond gain - Will Hoskin Elliot

GWS gain - Gibbs, Pick 6, pick 9?

WHAT???

 

[captain cotch 9]

IMO GWS need to stop trading players for picks.
They need to start trading players for players.

 

[De Iulio2Wiggins]

How's this HYPOTHETICAL DEAL.

Carlton gain - Tom Boyd

Richmond gain - Will Hoskin Elliot

GWS gain - Gibbs, Pick 6, pick 9?

This really is my favourite part of the footy year

 

[Oddhawk]

You could even suggest they need to go down the path of picks for players.

 

[thetradesman]

WHAT???

Good or bad?