Trade hypotheticals

[Super Hans]

Hawks will be big players at yrs end ....mark my words .
So with that in mind would love a gauge on value and interest in the following ...
1. Suckling
2. Hallahan
3. Stratton
4. Lowden
5. Shoey

I'd happily give our second pick (around 25) for Stratton or Suckling.

Rest aren't worth much.

 

[halfback dasher]

I'd happily give our second pick (around 25) for Stratton or Suckling.

Rest aren't worth much.

Gee interesting , i would have thought that those 2 would be at the bottom of the list for the Dogs ....Grimmers
/ Shoey ??

 

[Two Planks]

Hawks will be big players at yrs end ....mark my words .
So with that in mind would love a gauge on value and interest in the following ...
1. Suckling
2. Hallahan
3. Stratton
4. Lowden
5. Shoey

I think all would be 2nd round picks. Somewhere between 20-35.

 

[Super Hans]

Gee interesting , i would have thought that those 2 would be at the bottom of the list for the Dogs ....Grimmers
/ Shoey ??

Grimley is worth nothing. I'm sure he's a good player but we wouldn't give more than a fourth round pick.

Would do a second round pick for Shoey, but would prefer the other two. Especially Stratton.

 

[halfback dasher]

Grimley is worth nothing. I'm sure he's a good player but we wouldn't give more than a fourth round pick.

Would do a second round pick for Shoey, but would prefer the other two. Especially Stratton.

Fair enough .

 

[eth-dog]

halfback dasher what would you ask from Essendon for Grimley or Lowden?

 

[halfback dasher]

halfback dasher what would you ask from Essendon for Grimley or Lowden?

Its hard to know ... there will be interest in both which as we know may over inflate there true value. Grimmers still has a yr to run , Lowden out of contract ...again governing factors .

 

[Kakkle]

I'd trade a 4th rounder for Lowden. Out of contract + 1 gamer. Can't exactly ask for much.

 

[Oddhawk]

I think we're more likely to keep lowden and try to trade the frosty medalist.

Shoey for the dogs 2nd
Grimmers and our 3rd for the Dons second
Suckling and our first for the Eagles first?

Gives us 9, 24, 30... ish...
And our second

 

[Dogsman16]

I think we're more likely to keep lowden and try to trade the frosty medalist.

Shoey for the dogs 2nd
Grimmers and our 3rd for the Dons second
Suckling and our first for the Eagles first?

Gives us 9, 24, 30... ish...
And our second

Happy to trade for Schoenmakers and exchange our 2nd rounder. Stating the obvious but we need KPP at either end and he certainly fits the bill.

 

[Oddhawk]

Essendon and Eagles fans?

 

[Suma Magic]

Essendon and Eagles fans?

We'd have to make finals and to win one for the trade to be worth it. If it was 10 for 19 and Suckling I'd say no. If it was 13 for suckling and 17 I'd say yes. It's more likely to be the former so I'd probably decline. Interested in Suckling though.

 

[eth-dog]

Essendon and Eagles fans?

We don't have a second round pick. And I wouldn't do that deal regardless, Grimley would be more our 3rd for your 3rd

 

[Oddhawk]

Maybe there's a 3 way deal to be had there.

Hawks out
Suckling, grimley 1st rounder, 2nd rounder
In
Eagles 1st and 3rd Bombers 3rd

Bombers out
Gleeson and 3rd
In
Grimley and Hawks 2nd

Eagles
Out
First and Third
In Gleeson and Suckling Hawks 1st

Seems fair and needs based. Gleeson the sticking point I reckon

 

[eth-dog]

Gleeson ain't going nowhere.

 

[Igloo]

Hawks will be big players at yrs end ....mark my words .
So with that in mind would love a gauge on value and interest in the following ...
1. Suckling
2. Hallahan
3. Stratton
4. Lowden
5. Shoey

If we got a 2nd round pick for Higgins, I'd probably give that for Schoenmakers or Stratton.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Maybe there's a 3 way deal to be had there.

Hawks out
Suckling, grimley 1st rounder, 2nd rounder
In
Eagles 1st and 3rd Bombers 3rd

Bombers out
Gleeson and 3rd
In
Grimley and Hawks 2nd

Eagles
Out
First and Third
In Gleeson and Suckling Hawks 1st

Seems fair and needs based. Gleeson the sticking point I reckon

So we get screwed....lol nice try! We don't need to do much trading but we aint trading out Gleeson!

 

[Oddhawk]

If we got a 2nd round pick for Higgins, I'd probably give that for Schoenmakers or Stratton.

Stratton isn't likely to be in the table

 

[thetradesman]

What would people give up for Grimes?

Starting to get back to his best again and might have some currency.

 

[eth-dog]

What would people give up for Grimes?

Starting to get back to his best again and might have some currency.

3rd round downgrade tbh

 

[pokerspiv]

Just a thread for posters to see what other posters think a player in there team is worth and so on.

I'll kick it off, Anyone interested in Vickery/Griffiths?

Fremantle would be very interested in a player like Griffiths with the retirement of McPharlin, and likely 2015 will be the last year for both Pavlich and Sandilands. We have some decent other ruckmen in Zac Clarke and Jon Griffin, but neither are very effective forwards. Someone like Griffiths who can play forward most of the game and chop out in the ruck is last piece of the puzzle for us. That is effectively why we recruited Gumbleton, but it's likely he will retire at season end too.

As for what we have to offer, we have a fair bit of midfield depth would be willing to part with 1 or 2 of the 2nd tier ones. Guys like Nick Suban, Clancee Pearce, Matt De Boer, Colin Sylvia and Anthony Morabito can't get a game for us at the moment.

 

[MrNatural]

I'd take Suckling at Collingwood.
2nd rounder

 

[TigerTime88]

Fremantle would be very interested in a player like Griffiths with the retirement of McPharlin, and likely 2015 will be the last year for both Pavlich and Sandilands. We have some decent other ruckmen in Zac Clarke and Jon Griffin, but neither are very effective forwards. Someone like Griffiths who can play forward most of the game and chop out in the ruck is last piece of the puzzle for us. That is effectively why we recruited Gumbleton, but it's likely he will retire at season end too.

As for what we have to offer, we have a fair bit of midfield depth would be willing to part with 1 or 2 of the 2nd tier ones. Guys like Nick Suban, Clancee Pearce, Matt De Boer, Colin Sylvia and Anthony Morabito can't get a game for us at the moment.

Gee Anthony Morabito would be very tempting assuming his body is good.

 

[Ambrosia]

I've been interested in Grimley for a while. Better tap ruckman than Lowden and Hale IMO

Agreed especially considering how useless Daniher is in the ruck

 

[boncer34]

Maybe there's a 3 way deal to be had there.

Hawks out
Suckling, grimley 1st rounder, 2nd rounder
In
Eagles 1st and 3rd Bombers 3rd

Bombers out
Gleeson and 3rd
In
Grimley and Hawks 2nd

Eagles
Out
First and Third
In Gleeson and Suckling Hawks 1st

Seems fair and needs based. Gleeson the sticking point I reckon

No.