Trade hypotheticals

[Andre the Giant]

Yep definitely rate him when fit, he can do a job

 

[northmagpie]

and if fit walks straight back in to collingwoods side

 

[dylan93]

Carlton wishes to trade Mitch Robinson. Straight swap for Watts???

 

[Nemisis]

Carlton wishes to trade Mitch Robinson. Straight swap for Watts???

Melbourne loses big time.

 

[The Facepainter]

Carlton wishes to trade Mitch Robinson. Straight swap for Watts???

Sold

 

[The Facepainter]

How about reuniting Robinson with Betts and the blues third rounder, pick 43ish?

Wouldn't be opposed to getting Douglas, maybe Wanganeen and our 3rd rounder?

 

[Two Planks]

The Nathan Brown from 2010 wont be seen again after injury problems. Pies need quality tall defenders themselves, so have to be concerned if they are trying to ship him off.

 

[LeverPuller]

What/who would Dees supporters want for Jack Trengove?

Top 10. He isn't going anywhere. Lot of Dees supporters excited about him for next year, he's had an undiagnosed navicular fracture since 2012 which ruined his running and kicking when he played.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

The Nathan Brown from 2010 wont be seen again after injury problems. Pies need quality tall defenders themselves, so have to be concerned if they are trying to ship him off.

We will have Keeffe, Reid, Frost, Brown and Moore all 196cm+ who could play KPB next year. 4 of those are proven reasonably good defenders. Imagine if Frawley wanted to come our way. We would have to trade one of Brown or Keeffe at least.

 

[Two Planks]

Moore wont play consistent AFL football for about 3-4 years.

 

[Mego Red]

How about reuniting Robinson with Betts and the blues third rounder, pick 43ish?

For Douglas? Who won the Crows b&f and was runner up the last two years? You want to give up a potential delistee and a meaningless pick?

Ummm ... Probably not, no.

 

[Mego Red]

What about ...

Dayne Beams to Brisbane
James Aish to the Crows
Kerridge and pick 9 to Collingwood?

 

[chinggis77]

I reckon there are a few fringe players at Freo who may be interested in a more stable career elsewhere:

De Boer - leadership group, tough as nails, has played a defensive forward role in his time at Freo, yet in the odd occaision when thrown into the middle has shown he can be a very good inside mid (got 28 poss incl 20 contested, 12 clearances, 8 tackles in one game from memory vs Richmond at the G when played as a mid). Great endurance. Leader on and off the field. 35 poss on the weekend for Peel.

Clancee Pearce - 2014 ruined by injury early, led to his role being taken by others. Averaged almost 20 last year at over 80% DE and was very good for us. Very good kick despite the unusual action. Tough as nails. Really hard worker. Can go through the middle. Has had a few 30+ poss games for Peel when fit.

Nick Suban - fringe player, tough as nails. Really hard worker. Elite very penetrating kick. Has not generally been given key midfield roles, but played more as a half forward. Has shown when given responsibility in the midfield he can rack up big numbers as a long kicking, goal kicking midfielder. Has been pumped up by Ross repeatedly this season due to how hard he has been working off the track.

All three I think would thrive if given more responsibility. All three are tough as nails and leaders.

What do people think they would be worth?

 

[Mateyman]

What about ...

Dayne Beams to Brisbane
James Aish to the Crows
Kerridge and pick 9 to Collingwood?

Kerridge+9 for Beams...yeah nah

 

[Mego Red]

Kerridge+9 for Beams...yeah nah

Yeah. I posted that assuming no one would think Brisbane would give up pick 4 for Beams. Seems on the other thread that some do. Seems unlikely to me they'll want to give up such a large chunk of salary and such a valuable pick, but maybe I'm alone in that view.

 

[Mego Red]

Try again.

Dayne Beams and pick 9 to Brisbane
James Aish to the Crows
Kerridge and pick 4 to Collingwood

 

[SterlingArcher]

Carlton wishes to trade Mitch Robinson. Straight swap for Watts???

Ummm...yes everyday of the week.

Robinson is gone, out of the club, no matter what he can bring. Was nice having him put his body on the line for the jumper but he's out.

If we can get a player who is less speculative than pick 50 I'd be stoked. Watts is less speculative than pick 50. Watts just needs to accept he's a terrible inside, soft player and use his strengths to his advantage. We have some excellent tough players in our team, think Watts would add to Yarran/Walker as good outside players.

 

[LeverPuller]

Hrovat + 7 for 3 (assuming Frawley compo) ?

 

[bone2468]

I think if Carlton traded Robinson to Melbourne for Jack Spud Watts Carlton are getting ripped of big time ahahaha

 

[yeewww]

Try again.

Dayne Beams and pick 9 to Brisbane
James Aish to the Crows
Kerridge and pick 4 to Collingwood

be closer to
danger > collingwood
beams> brisbane
aish + something to crows, just cant work out the something

 

[Two Planks]

Hrovat + 7 for 3 (assuming Frawley compo) ?

I think a deal between these 2 clubs is a big chance. Bulldogs would hate to lose Hrovat, but they have to try something to get KPP.

 

[Defacto]

I reckon there are a few fringe players at Freo who may be interested in a more stable career elsewhere:

De Boer - leadership group, tough as nails, has played a defensive forward role in his time at Freo, yet in the odd occaision when thrown into the middle has shown he can be a very good inside mid (got 28 poss incl 20 contested, 12 clearances, 8 tackles in one game from memory vs Richmond at the G when played as a mid). Great endurance. Leader on and off the field. 35 poss on the weekend for Peel.

Clancee Pearce - 2014 ruined by injury early, led to his role being taken by others. Averaged almost 20 last year at over 80% DE and was very good for us. Very good kick despite the unusual action. Tough as nails. Really hard worker. Can go through the middle. Has had a few 30+ poss games for Peel when fit.

Nick Suban - fringe player, tough as nails. Really hard worker. Elite very penetrating kick. Has not generally been given key midfield roles, but played more as a half forward. Has shown when given responsibility in the midfield he can rack up big numbers as a long kicking, goal kicking midfielder. Has been pumped up by Ross repeatedly this season due to how hard he has been working off the track.

All three I think would thrive if given more responsibility. All three are tough as nails and leaders.

What do people think they would be worth?

the fact de boer is in a leadership group, says more about freo than de boer

pearce = spud

suban = spud that gets whipped hard by ross. so whipped potatoe

 

[bone2468]

the fact de boer is in a leadership group, says more about freo than de boer

pearce = spud

suban = spud that gets whipped hard by ross. so whipped potatoe

They may be spuds but they'd help your (Spud) of a club

 

[Defacto]

They may be spuds but they'd help your (Spud) of a club

sadly they wouldnt

i'd rather play dunstan, weller, armitage in the middle before any of the above three you mentioned. thats before we name other young players that have more upside than of suban, de boer and pearce

 

[mtooler]

be closer to
danger > collingwood
beams> brisbane
aish + something to crows, just cant work out the something

Would have to be two first round picks for Beams.