Trade hypotheticals

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

If GWS want the 1st pick, Saints should request Plowman, Tomlinson and 2nd rnd pick.

 

[dazbroncos]

Danger to Geelong
Duncan to West Coast
S Motlop + 10 to Adelaide

Started well and faded badly at the end…

We have very few not tradable assets. Duncan and Mots are two of them.

Fully aware you have to give to get and Danger would be a big get which means big give….

Go Catters

 

[Two Planks]

Beams to brisbane
Leuenberger to geelong
Picks 5 and 14 to collingwood

 

[dlanod]

Beams to brisbane
Leuenberger to geelong
Picks 5 and 14 to collingwood

Surprisingly plausible.

 

[dazbroncos]

Beams to brisbane
Leuenberger to geelong
Picks 5 and 14 to collingwood

Aren't we done getting hurt big men?


Go Catters

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Carlton's Pick #7 + Jeff Garlett to Melbourne for Pick #3 (Frawley Compo).

Would allow us a shot at whoever is left of McCartin/Wright/Petracca and would allow Melbourne more 'bang for their buck' by adding a Best 22 player whilst still having access to a good kid at Pick #7.

They did something similar last year with GWS (allowing them to get Tyson and moving down 6 spots).

 

[Tragic sainter]

Just bizarre trading. Two first eighteen players both with ten plus years to go for one unknown -jack watts tom scully nic natuniai Richard tambling Matthew kreuzer BryceGibbs all are top draft picks. In the system just plodded.

I've never forgotten that Roos was willing to offer 6 and 14 to the tigers for dustin Martin. And you know what - Martin is a good player. But jetta and rohan are serious talents, and I would never do a 2 for 1 deal of this nature. You know what you are losing and it is still speculative what you are getting.

Dusty>Jetta and Rohan

 

[Tragic sainter]

Carlton's Pick #7 + Jeff Garlett to Melbourne for Pick #3 (Frawley Compo).

Would allow us a shot at whoever is left of McCartin/Wright/Petracca and would allow Melbourne more 'bang for their buck' by adding a Best 22 player whilst still having access to a good kid at Pick #7.

They did something similar last year with GWS (allowing them to get Tyson and moving down 6 spots).

Dreaming. Garlett is worth almost nothing, especially to a team like melbourne.

 

[Theo X]

Carlton's Pick #7 + Jeff Garlett to Melbourne for Pick #3 (Frawley Compo).

Would allow us a shot at whoever is left of McCartin/Wright/Petracca and would allow Melbourne more 'bang for their buck' by adding a Best 22 player whilst still having access to a good kid at Pick #7.

They did something similar last year with GWS (allowing them to get Tyson and moving down 6 spots).

Garlett is no Tyson. He's worth a 3rd rounder.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Dreaming. Garlett is worth almost nothing, especially to a team like melbourne.

Garlett's goal return over the past four seasons would mean he is easily in their 22 so not sure how you can claim he is worth "almost nothing to Melbourne".

Melbourne move down four spots (while still keeping their #2 pick), they are merely maximizing their free hit for Frawley.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Garlett is no Tyson. He's worth a 3rd rounder.

Different landscapes.

You still would have Pick #2, #7 + Garlett in this setting

As opposed to Tyson + Pick #9.

I agree that Garlett + #7 wouldn't be enough to secure Pick #2 by itself, but given the Frawley compo is basically "a bonus" - could see how Melbourne would want to get the most out of it.

 

[Theo X]

Different landscapes.

You still would have Pick #2, #7 + Garlett in this setting

As opposed to Tyson + Pick #9.

Just because we will (more than likely) have pick 3 doesn't mean it's worth less because we have another top 3 pick.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Anyway it was just an idea.

"I CAST THEE OUT!"

 

[tenderwarrior]

Different landscapes.

You still would have Pick #2, #7 + Garlett in this setting

As opposed to Tyson + Pick #9.

I agree that Garlett + #7 wouldn't be enough to secure Pick #2 by itself, but given the Frawley compo is basically "a bonus" - could see how Melbourne would want to get the most out of it.

You said it yourself. Melbourne could do much better than Garlett in a deal involving Pick 3

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

You said it yourself. Melbourne could do much better than Garlett in a deal involving Pick 3

Yep, fair enough then.

 

[melbournehammer]

Dusty>Jetta and Rohan

People musnt value our players much. Without jetta no flag 2012.

Jetta this year less obvious but to my mind more damaging. He has just been amazing in traffic.

True Rohan is only just starting to show something after leg shattered Nathan brown like. So perhaps he is steak knives at the moment. But his last seven weeks very very good (apart from first half freo - where it was really one bad kick)

Watch a lot of Martin. Super player. More inside outside and brutal strength wise. Very hard to tackle. But he still shanks some kicks and defensively he just plods.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Here's the thing. GWS know full well what it takes to get pick 1, as they have been putting pick 1 on the table previously and presumably demanding a hell of a lot for it, so they will know that if they really want it this year they will have to put up the sort of deal that they were demanding and not receiving in previous years.

Thing is though, they can afford to pay that sort of price, while other clubs that haven't been given the Earth as start-up concessions haven't been able to in recent years.

But why would they give up Shiel who most would back to be of a similar, if not better, calibre to Petracca?

 

[Theo X]

Hope GWS will make sure Petracca won't ask to come home in a couple of years time if they're selling the farm to get pick 1.

 

[Tragic sainter]

People musnt value our players much. Without jetta no flag 2012.

Jetta this year less obvious but to my mind more damaging. He has just been amazing in traffic.

True Rohan is only just starting to show something after leg shattered Nathan brown like. So perhaps he is steak knives at the moment. But his last seven weeks very very good (apart from first half freo - where it was really one bad kick)

Watch a lot of Martin. Super player. More inside outside and brutal strength wise. Very hard to tackle. But he still shanks some kicks and defensively he just plods.

I rate Sydney's list extremely highly, in fact I think your list is the most talented by quite a margin.

Replace Jetta with dusty in 2012 and I think you win the flag more easily. He would've developed much faster at sydney and the bloke was built for finals.

 

[theflea]

I rate Sydney's list extremely highly, in fact I think your list is the most talented by quite a margin.

Replace Jetta with dusty in 2012 and I think you win the flag more easily. He would've developed much faster at sydney and the bloke was built for finals.

If you play in a better team, its a lot easier to get a kick than in a weaker team, so if that's developing quicker then I agree.

 

[Andre the Giant]

Hope GWS will make sure Petracca won't ask to come home in a couple of years time if they're selling the farm to get pick 1.

This very thought crosses my mind all the time!! They all say the right things in the interviews (except Wingard).

 

[Andre the Giant]

Garlett's goal return over the past four seasons would mean he is easily in their 22 so not sure how you can claim he is worth "almost nothing to Melbourne".

Melbourne move down four spots (while still keeping their #2 pick), they are merely maximizing their free hit for Frawley.

At his best Garlett is a good player but his best is a long time ago and he has had behavioral issues. He holds v little currency and will get moved for a 3rd rounder or low pick exchange.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Carlton's Pick #7 + Jeff Garlett to Melbourne for Pick #3 (Frawley Compo).

Would allow us a shot at whoever is left of McCartin/Wright/Petracca and would allow Melbourne more 'bang for their buck' by adding a Best 22 player whilst still having access to a good kid at Pick #7.

They did something similar last year with GWS (allowing them to get Tyson and moving down 6 spots).

more chance of Melbourne trading pick 3 for 7 outright

 

[SnowRoo]

Everyone seems focussed on the top tier, ill try a lower tier 3 way

Aaron Mullett + Norths 4th round pick -----> Pies

Josh Thomas + Pies 3rd round pick -----> Bullies

Liam Jones -----> North


Pies get a lumumba replacement, Bullies get a contested ball mid and low pick, North get a KPP they want.

Thoughts?

 

[Dogsman16]

Everyone seems focussed on the top tier, ill try a lower tier 3 way

Aaron Mullett + Norths 4th round pick -----> Pies

Josh Thomas + Pies 3rd round pick -----> Bullies

Liam Jones -----> North


Pies get a lumumba replacement, Bullies get a contested ball mid and low pick, North get a KPP they want.

Thoughts?

We have absolutely no need for a contested ball mid, plus losing a key forward which our cupboard in that area is bare. PASS!