Trade hypotheticals

[eth-dog]

Ryder could walk for nothing, if push came to shove. A few players apparently are interested in walking from Essendon now.

Essendon dont exactly hold all the cards in this one, unless they plan to keep a player against his will, or send him to the courts.

Why would we accept pick 22 for him when someone has publicly admitted that they'd trade a higher pick at the very least for him?

 

[SnowRoo]

They have completely lost it on the Saints board, posters quite seriously claiming that they will receive deals like Shiel and pick 4, or Cameron and pick 4 for pick 1.

I think the Jaksch + JOR + 4 for 1 is crazy dreamworld stuff.

If the Saints are offered Jaksch and 4 they should take it and run. Still an absolute steal by them.

 

[Play by Numbers]

I think the Jaksch + JOR + 4 for 1 is crazy dreamworld stuff.

If the Saints are offered Jaksch and 4 they should take it and run. Still an absolute steal by them.

Not even joking, there are posters now seriously suggesting that the Saints should demand Cameron, Shiel and pick 4. This kind of thing isn't an isolated opinion, there is literally no dissent.

I agree BTW.

We are through the looking glass.

 

[Two Planks]

Why would we accept pick 22 for him when someone has publicly admitted that they'd trade a higher pick at the very least for him?

It does not matter what clubs publicly admit they would offer, it only matters what the club ryder nominates would offer.

 

[eth-dog]

It does not matter what clubs publicly admit they would offer, it only matters what the club ryder nominates would offer.

And as he hasn't nominated any yet, Port are the front runners. Comprender?

 

[GROTTO]

And as he hasn't nominated any yet, Port are the front runners. Comprender?

Accept it, Ryder has walked out. Dont fight it, resistance is futile.

 

[lion4life]

They have completely lost it on the Saints board, posters quite seriously claiming that they will receive deals like Shiel and pick 4, or Cameron and pick 4 for pick 1.

I'm sorry, what?

 

[SnowRoo]

Not even joking, there are posters now seriously suggesting that the Saints should demand Cameron, Shiel and pick 4. This kind of thing isn't an isolated opinion, there is literally no dissent.

I agree BTW.

We are through the looking glass.

I'd laugh to see.

Jaksch and GWS 2nd for Blues 1st
JOR and GWS 3rd to North for Norths 1st
GWS 1st, Blues 1st, Norths 1st to Adel for Danger

oh yeah

Saints get Petracca.

 

[eth-dog]

Accept it, Ryder has walked out. Dont fight it, resistance is futile.

That's completely beside the point.

 

[Play by Numbers]

I'm sorry, what?

Go to the Saints board. I couldn't believe it at first and when I tried to discuss the issue reasonably, I received a deluge of insanity in response.

These are the dominant opinions, there is little if no dissent.

 

[GROTTO]

That's completely beside the point.

Bye bye Paddy.........

 

[lion4life]

Go to the Saints board. I couldn't believe it at first and when I tried to discuss the issue reasonably, I received a deluge of insanity in response.

These are the dominant opinions, there is little if no dissent.

Honestly, doesn't surprise me at all. More and more Saint's fans seem to be taking the same ruthless list management approach as Pelchen. Won't do them any favours in the long run.

 

[Curunir]

Go to the Saints board. I couldn't believe it at first and when I tried to discuss the issue reasonably, I received a deluge of insanity in response.

These are the dominant opinions, there is little if no dissent.

When did someone say Cameron + Shiel + 4 = 1? Cut me the crap.

Yes it's a far stretch asking for Shiel + 4 for 1. Something more along the lines of Shiel + 4 for 1 + 20 has been suggested as well which you seem to have not mentioned...

 

[SnowRoo]

And as he hasn't nominated any yet, Port are the front runners. Comprender?

Fair to say Ryder has said he wants decent compensation for Ess. He wont walk out for nothing a deal will be struck in good faith.

 

[eth-dog]

Fair to say Ryder has said he wants decent compensation for Ess. He wont walk out for nothing a deal will be struck in good faith.

Wow, an opposition supporter who knows that he won't go as a DFA. Let alone a North supporter .

 

[Play by Numbers]

Honestly, doesn't surprise me at all. More and more Saint's fans seem to be taking the same ruthless list management approach as Pelchen. Won't do them any favours in the long run.

Don't confuse ruthless, with insane.

 

[Two Planks]

So I'm delusional because I use logic to back up my argument, yet you resort to personal insults

Even though beams wants to go to qld under your theory melbourne can offer pick 2 and trump the lions pick 5. Guess what, it doesn't matter what the dees offer he wont go there.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Ryders an idiot if he doesnt go to Port

 

[Play by Numbers]

When did someone say Cameron + Shiel + 4 = 1? Cut me the crap.

Yes it's a far stretch asking for Shiel + 4 for 1. Something more along the lines of Shiel + 4 for 1 + 20 has been suggested as well which you seem to have not mentioned...

I'm not allowed to quote your team board here, but it's there in the last couple of pages. Posters can easily verify.

As for cutting the crap, how about confining it to your team board.

 

[eth-dog]

Even though beams wants to go to qld under your theory melbourne can offer pick 2 and trump the lions pick 5. Guess what, it doesn't matter what the dees offer he wont go there.

No, my theory is that Ryder hasn't nominated a club, but has met 3 clubs: Port, Brisbane and GWS. With that in mind, all 3 are plausible destinations. Therefore, why would Essendon trade him to a club for a lesser deal when both clubs are equally as plausible a destination?

 

[Stylo]

I'm not allowed to quote your team board here, but it's there in the last couple of pages. Posters can easily verify.

As for cutting the crap, how about confining it to your team board.

Just had a look, they're approaching Essendon levels of delusion over there

 

[eth-dog]

Just had a look, they're approaching Richmond levels of delusion over there

efa .

 

[Stylo]

efa .

aawwwhhh very clever

 

[Two Planks]

No, my theory is that Ryder hasn't nominated a club, but has met 3 clubs: Port, Brisbane and GWS. With that in mind, all 3 are plausible destinations. Therefore, why would Essendon trade him to a club for a lesser deal when both clubs are equally as plausible a destination?

Because ryder will give essendon 1 destination not 3.

 

[eth-dog]

Because ryder will give essendon 1 destination not 3.

I didn't think it was possible to see a person this stupid, or be lacking such basic comprehension skills.