Trade hypotheticals

[Oddhawk]

190cm mid/winger.
Good disposal
Needs work on his conditioning.

 

[Sydswans0512]

What about...

Sydney get Ryder and Kelly/Grimley

Essendon get 18 and Jetta

Hawthorn get Mitchell

So we give up Mitchell and Jetta for Ryder? Don't like it at all

 

[kenneje]

So we give up Mitchell and Jetta for Ryder? Don't like it at all

What about:

Sydney: Ryder + Lowden + around 25 (as a result of hawthorn trading Hallahan and pick 38)
Essendon: Jetta + Pick 18
Hawthorn: Mitchell

 

[Sydswans0512]

What about:

Sydney: Ryder + Lowden + around 25 (as a result of hawthorn trading Hallahan and pick 38)
Essendon: Jetta + Pick 18
Hawthorn: Mitchell

If we got Ryder we wouldn't need Lowden

 

[Oddhawk]

So we give up Mitchell and Jetta for Ryder? Don't like it at all

I suppose it depends how much you need Ryder.

 

[Oddhawk]

If we got Ryder we wouldn't need Lowden

That I get. Hallahan would be more use to you

 

[kenneje]

If we got Ryder we wouldn't need Lowden

Yeah fair enough.

 

[Sydswans0512]

That I get. Hallahan would be more use to you

Do you think the Swans would hand Tom Mitchell to the team that just smashed them in a GF?

 

[calumhfc]

What do Melbourne people and some neutrals think of this trade?

Pick 4 and Mitch Clark >> Collingwood
Pick 22 and Lester/Harwood >> Melbourne
Beams >> Brisbane

Is that lester and harwood going to Melbourne or one of them

 

[Skyhooks78]

Do you think the Swans would hand Tom Mitchell to the team that just smashed them in a GF?

Mate you gave us Spangher

 

[Sydswans0512]

Mate you gave us Spangher

After we beat you, totally different circumstances

 

[Dom PC]

Is that lester and harwood going to Melbourne or one of them

Just one of them.

 

[foj1]

Mitchell and Reid for Ryder and Jetta.
Don't strengthen hawthorn. They are too bloody good as it is!

 

[Sydswans0512]

Mitchell and Reid for Ryder and Jetta.
Don't strengthen hawthorn. They are too bloody good as it is!

Do you seriously think we would? Jetta has no value

 

[foj1]

No!
But I do believe you would be foolish to trade with Hawthorn.
I think you will be the power teams next year.
Though I think your footy club could turn Leroy around.

Do you seriously think we would? Jetta has no value

 

[Sydswans0512]

No!
But I do believe you would be foolish to trade with Hawthorn.
I think you will be the power teams next year.
Though I think your footy club could turn Leroy around.

I'd be willing to give Leroy a go but he's been delisted right? Tayte Pears is another id like to try if they're are willing to play for minimum chips

 

[Two Planks]

I think it's glaringly obvious that the swans would benefit from a zippy goal sneak to play at the feet of franklin and tippett. Wether its jetta or garlett or somebody else I think they have to try something.

 

[Sydswans0512]

I think it's glaringly obvious that the swans would benefit from a zippy goal sneak to play at the feet of franklin and tippett. Wether its jetta or garlett or somebody else I think they have to try something.

Or just play Mcgylnn down there full time

 

[Two Planks]

Or just play Mcgylnn down there full time

That could work as well.

 

[NinjaSwan]

I think it's glaringly obvious that the swans would benefit from a zippy goal sneak to play at the feet of franklin and tippett. Wether its jetta or garlett or somebody else I think they have to try something.

I think we would be better off drafting a small forward than trading for one.

 

[blueiris]

Sydney need a ruckman McEvoy and Hale destroyed Pyke last night in the Grand Final Giles would be a good get for Sydney.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Sydney need a ruckman McEvoy and Hale destroyed Pyke last night in the Grand Final Giles would be a good get for Sydney.

Think I'd prefer to have a crack at Zac Clarke or one of the Gold Coast Ruckman

 

[Two Planks]

Sydney need a ruckman McEvoy and Hale destroyed Pyke last night in the Grand Final Giles would be a good get for Sydney.

Ryder will be better.

 

[blueiris]

Ryder will be better.

But Ryder is going to Port

 

[Sydswans0512]

Ryder will be better.

Yeah don't think we can afford 750k