Trade hypotheticals

[Defacto]

Dont understand your first point. What difference does that make, the club still needs to improve its list and will try to do so.

Its been reported that its between Essendon and the dogs.

I think a 3rd/4th round pick is his worth.

really has it?

Sydney considers St Kilda its most likely partner in a trade deal for young forward Tim Membrey, who has told the club he plans to leave in search of improved opportunities.

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-ne...s-underway-20141002-10pin9.html#ixzz3F5RkxbW2

i dont know about you but i'd trust emmas word over jay clark

hit twitter tonight they we have a 3 year deal on the table for him

 

[SnowRoo]

This far out scenario of mine is getting closer to reality.
I think Greenwood is the player that could get the Beams deal done.

was it this crazy?


Levi + Mullett+34 to Pies
Beams to Bris
4 + Merrett to North

4 + 16 to Saints
1 to North

1 to GWS
JOR + 3 to North

 

[Smoocher]

was it this crazy?


Levi + Mullett+34 to Pies
Beams to Bris
4 + Merrett to North

4 + 16 to Saints
1 to North

1 to GWS
JOR + 3 to North

That is a shit load of crazy. You had me up to the Saints bit. Don't think they will accept.

 

[melonhead2011]

was it this crazy?


Levi + Mullett+34 to Pies
Beams to Bris
4 + Merrett to North

4 + 16 to Saints
1 to North

1 to GWS
JOR + 3 to North

Wow North would benefit an insane amount from that. Move on a good but not great midfielder in Greenwood, a forward who they don't really want or need in Mullet and a late second round pick to end up with a key position defender, a former number two midfielder and also a top three pick!

That would be steal of any century. Never ever going to happen

 

[Man of Steele]

North Pick 15 to Lions for leunburger + merrett
Lions Pick 4 to Pies
North sends Greenwood to Pies
Pies send Beams to Lions











Lions get pick Beams + 15
North get Luenburger + Merrett
Pies get Pick 4 + Greenwood

 

[eth-dog]

Port
IN Ryder
OUT Pick 16, Moore

Essendon
IN 19, Moore, Lowden
OUT Ryder

Hawthorn
IN 14
OUT Lowden, Pick 19, Hallahan

Gold Coast
IN 16 + Hallahan
OUT 14

Make it O'Shea instead of Moore and I'd do it.

 

[SnowRoo]

North Pick 15 to Lions for leunburger + merrett
Lions Pick 4 to Pies
North sends Greenwood to Pies
Pies send Beams to Lions











Lions get pick Beams + 15
North get Luenburger + Merrett
Pies get Pick 4 + Greenwood

Leuy no good to North

this is the closest to that ive come.

Bris gain - Beams, Pies 3rd (45)
Pies gain - 4, Greenwood, Norths 3rd (53)
North gain - Bris 2nd (24), Merrett

 

[Keystone agony]

really has it?



Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-ne...s-underway-20141002-10pin9.html#ixzz3F5RkxbW2

i dont know about you but i'd trust emmas word over jay clark

hit twitter tonight they we have a 3 year deal on the table for him

That was on the 2nd so maybe things have changed since

But this was today, not Jay Clark
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-10-03/trade-winds-friday

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

That was on the 2nd so maybe things have changed since

But this was today, not Jay Clark
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2014-10-03/trade-winds-friday

They get most of those trade winds from the Herald Sun.

Very likely Membrey will be joining St Kilda by the sounds of it if the deal is right which he is after a 3 year deal from us.

 

[Keystone agony]

They get most of those trade winds from the Herald Sun.

Very likely Membrey will be joining St Kilda.

Why are you so confident? what makes you

Not saying your wrong by any means

I wouldve thought the saints wouldve had JOR and Jaksch in their trade minds before Membrey?

 

[Defacto]

Why are you so confident? what makes you

Not saying your wrong by any means

I wouldve thought the saints wouldve had JOR and Jaksch in their trade minds before Membrey?

 

[Man of Steele]

Leuy no good to North

this is the closest to that ive come.

Bris gain - Beams, Pies 3rd (45)
Pies gain - 4, Greenwood, Norths 3rd (53)
North gain - Bris 2nd (24), Merrett

Yep looks like a fair deal for all parties

 

[*PAF]

was it this crazy?


Levi + Mullett+34 to Pies
Beams to Bris
4 + Merrett to North

4 + 16 to Saints
1 to North

1 to GWS
JOR + 3 to North

What do we get for losing 16?

 

[Keystone agony]

What do we get for losing 16?

Dare say hes assuming the likelyhood Melb get comp pick which means pick 16 actually ends up as 17 and even a chance of 18. North have that pick behind its their first round.

Its why you guys need to come up with more because if it is pick 18 as Paul Connors was saying than that is no way fair.

Sharrod Wellingham left for more ffs

 

[Keystone agony]

I reckon if Collingwood lose beams as a likely scenario and cant get Danger this year they seriously need to fix hole in what use to be such a strong midfield consisting of Swan, Ball, Macaffer (tagger) and obviously Beams.

I reckon it is almost guaranteed that greenwood will end up at Collingwood, they need him and i reckon North are tight with the cap.

Pick 15 + Greenwood to Pies for pick 8?

 

[Man of Steele]

I reckon if Collingwood lose beams as a likely scenario and cant get Danger this year they seriously need to fix hole in what use to be such a strong midfield consisting of Swan, Ball, Macaffer (tagger) and obviously Beams.

I reckon it is almost guaranteed that greenwood will end up at Collingwood, they need him and i reckon North are tight with the cap.

Pick 15 + Greenwood to Pies for pick 8?

 

[Man of Steele]

Most likely will have to use pick 8 for Darcy Moore as FS so can't trade it

 

[Keystone agony]

Most likely will have to use pick 8 for Darcy Moore as FS so can't trade it

Yeh you will, bugger aye. Maybe piss him off.

 

[Man of Steele]

Yeh you will, bugger aye. Maybe piss him off.

Nah still be happy to use our 1st pick he is rated a top 5-10 draft prospect, and we need a young key forward

 

[Keystone agony]

Nah still be happy to use our 1st pick he is rated a top 5-10 draft prospect, and we need a young key forward

Im not sure thats how it works though is it, i dont know for sure?

But pretty sure you cant downgrade your 1st round pick so you can get a fatherson further down the order than what their value should be. Maybe you can take him at a lower pick ie: 4 but still unsure on that.

 

[Man of Steele]

Im not sure thats how it works though is it, i dont know for sure?
Rules are if any of the sides above Pies in draft order bid for Moore with their 1st round pick eg: Carlton with pick 6 we must match it and use our 1st rnd (pick 8) to secure Moore. If no side above us bid then we can use our 2nd pick for him.
Hope that helps
But pretty sure you cant downgrade your 1st round pick so you can get a fatherson further down the order than what their value should be. Maybe you can take him at a lower pick ie: 4 but still unsure on that.

 

[bloke_]

If the Pies get pick 4 from Brisbane do they have to use it on Moore if a team like GWS nominate him?

 

[MightyPies1]

If the Pies get pick 4 from Brisbane do they have to use it on Moore if a team like GWS nominate him?

LOL, no we don't. We still use pick 8 to bid.

 

[Keystone agony]

Im not stupid. You need to learn how to quote and than reply under the quote for it to be easy to read.

I know how the F/S bidding works.

What im unsure is, if Collingwood trade pick 8 on monday, what happens with Moore, does it make him open to the market.

 

[POKsPies252]

Greenwood is the kind of player the Pies will want along with pick 4. Really he perfect player for the deal, not a star but a good solid player who can fit into the Pies midfield straight away