Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
BigFooty.
So take it with a huge grain of salt. Like, boulder-sized grain of salt. But it's probably the closest thing to something I would be likely to see come trade week.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Trade or Draft?
- Thread starter Krazy Kris
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
BigFooty.
So take it with a huge grain of salt. Like, boulder-sized grain of salt. But it's probably the closest thing to something I would be likely to see come trade week.
supernova_
Premiership Player
BigFooty.
But it's probably the closest thing to something I would be likely to see come trade week.
Massive shafting of Essendon there... I'll take it as well haha
Well it is offensive, especially given my career. Not angry though.
I'm not sure how many people would agree with your statement. I'd argue that Dixon would hold probably twice the value of Day on the market, which would vindicate my opinion. But as I said, let's hope they all turn into Premiership players
bballscout
Cancelled
Well it is offensive, especially given my career. Not angry though.
I'm not sure how many people would agree with your statement. I'd argue that Dixon would hold probably twice the value of Day on the market, which would vindicate my opinion. But as I said, let's hope they all turn into Premiership players
Day is a 20yo pick 3, Dixon is a 22yo zone listed player.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Some of the greatest players in the history of the game started as rookies or late picks. I take your point, but your draft position doesn't guarantee that you'll be an exceptional player.
bballscout
Cancelled
True, but it guarantees he holds more value on the open market right now as what your discussion was about.
I like the sound of that, 37 is probably the deepest the Suns want to go into the draft.
This is just gonna seem like a shit fight given what's happened in the other thread haha but I genuinely like you and have nothing against you, just like discussing this!
I know that we're now talking about what value they'd both hold on the open market. Let's hope we never find out, because I'd love to keep both of them. However, I strongly believe that if, hypothetically, both players were put on the trading block, Dixon would receive more interest from more clubs and command a higher trade value. At a guess, I reckon Dixon could fetch a pick between 6-16 plus a really decent fringe player. I think Day would fetch a 10-20 pick by itself, at absolute best. Happy to be wrong though. What does everyone else think?
I know that we're now talking about what value they'd both hold on the open market. Let's hope we never find out, because I'd love to keep both of them. However, I strongly believe that if, hypothetically, both players were put on the trading block, Dixon would receive more interest from more clubs and command a higher trade value. At a guess, I reckon Dixon could fetch a pick between 6-16 plus a really decent fringe player. I think Day would fetch a 10-20 pick by itself, at absolute best. Happy to be wrong though. What does everyone else think?
He provides another decent sized mature body, which we lack. Interesting though, you'd imagine we'd have to package pick 37 up with something else to move up in the draft or for another singular player. These two for one deals would make our 8 delistings very very difficult.
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
We'll either use #37 on a zone pick or package it up with something else to trade and upgrade the pick.
Scotty_222
Norm Smith Medallist
What about toy, he was a high pick and doesn't hold any value
bballscout
Cancelled
Proposed trade for him is Hooker and pick 37, that ain't value??
Scotty_222
Norm Smith Medallist
rumours..
bballscout
Cancelled
To end this discussion:
Day is being developed to be our long term chf with Lynch ff. Dixon will be backing up both these guys as well as that 2nd string ruck role. Nothing wrong with that, just shows though dicko ain't quite at the ability of our others mentioned. Love his contested mark and will be a great long term backup. Just not as mobile/athletic.
If Tippett comes in, it could hurt Dixon most as he would play that role as combo fwd/ruck.
Day is being developed to be our long term chf with Lynch ff. Dixon will be backing up both these guys as well as that 2nd string ruck role. Nothing wrong with that, just shows though dicko ain't quite at the ability of our others mentioned. Love his contested mark and will be a great long term backup. Just not as mobile/athletic.
If Tippett comes in, it could hurt Dixon most as he would play that role as combo fwd/ruck.
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
I personally think Dixon's days in the forward line (at least for now) are over. At least if Tippett arrives.
With that said, based on what he's shown, I think that he's easily best 22 playing at Full Back, myself. Having someone who has the guts and skill to take a contested mark instead of just punching it away is invaluable. This is what makes him a better option than May at IMO, who just fists everything that comes near him as a defender.
With that said, based on what he's shown, I think that he's easily best 22 playing at Full Back, myself. Having someone who has the guts and skill to take a contested mark instead of just punching it away is invaluable. This is what makes him a better option than May at IMO, who just fists everything that comes near him as a defender.
supernova_
Premiership Player
I disagree, as most likely we'll be playing Day, Lynch, and Tippett all in the same forward line? So if the Tippett deal falls through, wouldn't we be doing the same role with Dixon? Full forward/2nd ruckman?
supernova_
Premiership Player
Ok new idea, we need Goddard. I was really hoping when we picked up Brennan he was going to be our utility, mr fix it type player as he can play anywhere on the ground almost with his athletic ability.
Dropped twice now this year, I'd imagine he's got 1 year left?
Dropped twice now this year, I'd imagine he's got 1 year left?
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Ok new idea, we need Goddard. I was really hoping when we picked up Brennan he was going to be our utility, mr fix it type player as he can play anywhere on the ground almost with his athletic ability.
Dropped twice now this year, I'd imagine he's got 1 year left?
I agree that we do need that 'Mr fix it' type player but personally im not much of a fan of Goddard. Brennan has to go before we put on another similar type aswell.
Scotty_222
Norm Smith Medallist
Goddard testing free agency hopefully we can put a good offer to him
The more players we shed the more likely we would be to be looking at a big salary pick-up.
True or False?
True or False?
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
False. At least I hope it's false.
The more players we shed, the more likely we'll be able to keep our young stars like Bennell, McKenzie, Matera, Swallow etc. when they come out of contract.
Scotty_222
Norm Smith Medallist
the guys we shed probably arent on big salaries ie rookie wages..
unless we shed brennan but we would have to pay his contract out
unless we shed brennan but we would have to pay his contract out