Mega Thread Trade Targets 2018 (2018 Trade Period Discussion)

[Dewy006]

What mature age player are they going to attract with pick 2 and 3?

I will tell you. None as no one will want to go there

If no one wants to go there they will just go to the draft with 2 and 3 and draft absolute elite talent. They won't deal for a myriad of middle first round picks, they already have a ton of that type of player on their list. What they don't have is elite A grade talent. And you know what spots you're more likely to find that in the draft? Picks 2 and 3.

 

[Thetrader15]

Literally all of those deals are pipe dreams

How is 7 for gov and 37 a pipe dream?

 

[GetInMyVanBerlo]

How is 7 for gov and 37 a pipe dream?

It's basically valuing Gov as a top 10 pick, I highly doubt clubs would be willing to do that, contracted or not

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Are some you related to David Noble? Half of these trade suggestions have us getting reamed.

 

[Glenny83]

Mitch Gov? If we could get gov on board I'd think GC might do this

They totally would, they did it for weller. They’d have to offer Gov a big pay day!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[FR0GGY]

If we are serious on Jack or Issac then McGovern is out the door, have to get Carlton a priority pick then they are more likely to give up pick 1 or 2
Gov + ours and Melbourne’s first round pick, for 1 or 2.
To me that’s paying overs but it’s what it’s going to take IMO.

 

[ABAB]

I agree with the bolded part. I don't think he is that big a liability for the type of player that you have described. I just think you only have room for one of those types of players. You have to have a balance. I don't think there is room for him in the team with Matt Crouch and Greenwood. But I will be most grateful to know that we have him running around in the SANFL ready to step in and take that role if Crouch in particular goes down.

Poholke is starting to go pass him.

 

[Pugsley]

Poholke is starting to go pass him.

Huh ?

 

[CROWS84]

So supposedly on talking footy fireman Cornes has said Polec to North is pretty much a done deal.
Meaning they could go into this draft with a reasonable draft hand if that the case ie 8 and 11 approximately, with the hope to trade up I guess too

 

[Jack McKraken]

The only warped opinion is that of Adelaide fans who still believe in a mirage.

NTJanus, I don’t know what the Crouches did to you, but you need to let it go.

 

[latinoheat]

So supposedly on talking footy fireman Cornes has said Polec to North is pretty much a done deal.
Meaning they could go into this draft with a reasonable draft hand if that the case ie 8 and 11 approximately, with the hope to trade up I guess too

Port will get Rankine. What’s the bet

 

[ABAB]

Huh ?

In terms of pecking order in the midfield, he will be ahead of Yolmen end of next year. This year, you see Poholke get into the right spot but his last disposal was poor, it will improve next year.

 

[CROWS84]

Port will get Rankine. What’s the bet

Will prob trade next years first too. Doesn’t look like they’re gonna sit on the outer unfortunately.

 

[ams4crows]

Will prob trade next years first too. Doesn’t look like they’re gonna sit on the outer unfortunately.

They want Steven May though, so will have to send some currency to the Gold Coast

 

[CROWS84]

They want Steven May though, so will have to send some currency to the Gold Coast

Missing piece?

 

[GrommoT]

So supposedly on talking footy fireman Cornes has said Polec to North is pretty much a done deal.
Meaning they could go into this draft with a reasonable draft hand if that the case ie 8 and 11 approximately, with the hope to trade up I guess too

Even if they manage to get North's r1 pick and keep their own, wouldn't it be better for them to draft in 2 potentially really good round one players? Their list doesn't seem too strong to me so getting in two good players is better than trying to trade up for an early pick (especially give it's going to cost quite a lot to do it this year).

 

[Aussie_boy]

If we are serious on Jack or Issac then McGovern is out the door, have to get Carlton a priority pick then they are more likely to give up pick 1 or 2
Gov + ours and Melbourne’s first round pick, for 1 or 2.
To me that’s paying overs but it’s what it’s going to take IMO.

Wouldn't the priority pick likely be pick 19 after Gold Coast gets a compensation pick?

 

[Elite Crow]

So supposedly on talking footy fireman Cornes has said Polec to North is pretty much a done deal.
Meaning they could go into this draft with a reasonable draft hand if that the case ie 8 and 11 approximately, with the hope to trade up I guess too

Another reason to lose to North

 

[ams4crows]

Missing piece?

Something something Destination club something Something Ken Hinkley GC players still love him something something Dixon's mate.....

 

[Crowked]

Rankine would be shattered to end up at Port.

 

[Crow till I die]

Port will get Rankine. What’s the bet

They should just take their picks to the draft rather than trade up. Rankine and lukosius are crows supporters and would hate to be drafted by those flogs and it is totally unfair to ask these kids to play for them

 

[I Lost My Keays]

I still think Polec will stay. He came to PA due to homesickness but also was a supporter growing up. Port will do anything to keep considering he's pretty important to their structure

 

[ABAB]

They want Steven May though, so will have to send some currency to the Gold Coast

May would be on decent coin so they don't want to pay someone who will finish in their top 3 players this year and entering his prime and have said he wants to stay but fork out for a GC player......if it does happen, it will have Hinkley's finger print all over it.

 

[Firewalker]

I would ring the Gold Coast Suns and ask about a package deal for pick 2 and 3.

Adelaide sent Mitch McGovern to Fremantle for pick 7 (1644 points)

Adelaide give the Gold Coast Pick 7 (1644 points), our pick 8 (1551 points), Melbourne Pick 13 (1212 points) and pick 37 (483 points) or pick 2 (2517 points), pick 3 (2234 points) and pick 42 (395 points)

Adelaide loses: Pick 7 (McGovern), pick 8, pick 13 and pick 37 = 4890 points

Adelaide gain: pick 2, 3 and 42 = 5146 points

*Turns on PlayStation*

I reckon we do something similar, again only in the case of McGovern going and Freo giving up pick 7. I think we’ll finish 11th, with Bombers losing next 2 and Adelaide end up with picks 9, Melb 1st, Carl 2nd (20), 27, 45, 63.

Part 1:

Send 7, 9, Melbourne pick (12-15), CEY, 45 to Gold Coast for picks 2 & 3.

Reasoning: Keep 2 first round picks for players they have identified as willing to go to GC whilst gaining another 1st rounder to secure Academy player. Add a big senior body in the middle that they desperately want in CEY + 45 for even more Academy points.

Part 2:

Send picks 20, 27, 1st round 2019 to North Melbourne for Picks 10 and 46

Reasoning: 20 & 27 ( 1,615 points = pick 7) used to secure North Academy player Tarryn Thomas + Crows 2019 1st rounder to secure trades.

Final Result:

Adelaide
Pick 2 - Lukosius
Pick 3 - Rankine
Pick 10 - Rozee
Pick 46 -

That’s how it’s done people.

 

[kulak]

Rankine is prodigiously talented, but that’s never enough

Would anyone be happy with Chad Wingard at the crows given how much he would have cost to get him?

I can see the arguments against.

Intuitively he seems like a great pick from 10+, and Port took him at 6

However, I’d be happy with him over most of the following picks. Given he’s SA, I think it looks like the right pick in hindsight.

TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 6 Chad Wingard Sturt SANFL Port Adelaide
1 7 Nick Haynes Dandenong Stingrays TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 8 Billy Longer Northern Knights TAC Cup Brisbane Lions
1 9 Adam Tomlinson Oakleigh Chargers TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 10 Liam Sumner Sandringham Dragons TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 11 Toby Greene Oakleigh Chargers TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 12 Sam Docherty Gippsland Power TAC Cup Brisbane Lions
1 13 Taylor Adams Geelong Falcons TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 14 Devon Smith Geelong Falcons TAC Cup Greater Western Sydney
1 15 Brandon Ellis Calder Cannons TAC Cup Richmond
1 16 Tom Sheridan Calder Cannons TAC Cup Fremantle
1 17 Clay Smith Gippsland Power TAC Cup Western Bulldogs
1 18 Brad McKenzie Sturt SANFL North Melbourne
1 19 Elliot Kavanagh Western Jets TAC Cup Essendon
1 20 Hayden Crozier Eastern Ranges