Trade Targets

[Son_Of_God29]

Guys,

Would anyone be interested in Rohan from the Swans does anybody know why he cant get a game is he injured? If we were interested what would we give up

 

[krisholio14]

How about trading for Jacob Surjan from Port? Reportedly wanting out of Port, and could be that shut down, back pocket we've needed for a while.

I don't think Hunt is accountable enough sometimes and what I've seen of Jacob Surjan has been impressive. He just needs to get on the park

Surjan is a shit truck. Do not want!

 

[The rabbi]

Surjan is a shit truck. Do not want!

Why don't you just say what you really think.

 

[Iago]

How about trading for Jacob Surjan from Port? Reportedly wanting out of Port, and could be that shut down, back pocket we've needed for a while.

I don't think Hunt is accountable enough sometimes and what I've seen of Jacob Surjan has been impressive. He just needs to get on the park

Would not want this bloke anywhere near Geelong. Poisonous behind the scenes, nothing is ever his fault, why do you think he is not getting a game with Port. Primus can't wait to get him out the door.

 

[Turbocat]

Guys,

Would anyone be interested in Rohan from the Swans does anybody know why he cant get a game is he injured? If we were interested what would we give up

LOve to have him but recently signed another contract for the Swans. Out injured atm. But if he wanted home I'd be wiling to seriously trade for him.

 

[Selective Retention]

I don't see the love for Bate.

If we didn't have Menzel then maybe he'd be a decent foil if you were going in with a Ruck, Fwd, Ruck/Fwd set up like we were earlier in the year with Ottens, Pods and Hawkins.

As it is he wouldn't offer us any improvement on what we have.

 

[krisholio14]

Would not want this bloke anywhere near Geelong. Poisonous behind the scenes, nothing is ever his fault, why do you think he is not getting a game with Port. Primus can't wait to get him out the door.

One of the most overrated players in the history of the game as well.

I have never been able to figure out why anyone rates him. He's hopeless.

 

[Rosso]

Is there any love still for Lewis Johnston from the Swans. There was a fair bit of interest in him on this board prior to the draft a few years back.

Had a bad run of injuries when he arrived in the harbour city so didn't make much of a splash up there. Debuted earlier in the year for the Swannies but was pretty much straight out a week or so later. Maybe not up to it, may not in Horse's plans??

Big kid who could hold down a key position and probably wouldn't break the bank to send him down south. After Mummy, the Swans owe us.

Edit - Forget it. Signed for another 2 years a week ago. Back to the drawing board.

 

[Partridge]

Geelong are generally crap at trading players. I prefer they just go to the draft and get the best young blokes they can. if this years draft is as good as some say then get some fresh blood.

We've built an extremely strong team over a long period of time by almost exclusively NOT trading. Develop young players. It's by far the best way to go. Unless there's a bargain floating around I wouldn't even look at trading.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

We've built an extremely strong team over a long period of time by almost exclusively NOT trading. Develop young players. It's by far the best way to go. Unless there's a bargain floating around I wouldn't even look at trading.

Um Otto?

In any case I see where you are coming from but I don't think it's an either or scenario, draft and develop (which we do extremely well) and when there's a player who fits our list needs, target as well.

 

[you pick one]

Have a look at post no61 in the, imagine Geelong with Pavlich thread,on the main board.