A couple of things....
1. No way Dawes finds himself at Carlton. Collingwood very rarely trades with us at the best of times. After appointing MM and going after Cloke there is no way in hell they'll be dealing with us (if we are even interested that is).
2. Isnt this 2012 draft the one many have been calling the 'super draft' for the last couple of years? If so and the calibre of kids is so high, why would we consider trading our first rounder for Caddy?
3. Waite, Mitchell, Casboult, Hampson, Henderson, Jamison, Watson, McCarthy, McInness etc and we want more KPs? Give them time I say. Much rather some midfield depth (without giving away our pick 11).