Trade week thread #2

[King Elvis]

With Hutchy reporting that mark seaby is meeting with port today, do port have enough currency to land both seaby and Ebert? Would require giving up pick 8 or a player I would have thought to get both.

Seaby wouldn't have huge currency, would he?

Second rounder or equivalent I would've thought...

 

[pext]

A pick in the 20's I'd have thought would be seaby's value.

 

[dylan123]

If Seaby is worth a pick in the 20's then so is Maric.

 

[Crow About It]

A pick in the 20's I'd have thought would be seaby's value.

I guess they're hoping to use 29 for seaby and 33 for ebert? Or vice versa.

Good luck to them if they can

 

[King Elvis]

I guess they're hoping to use 29 for seaby and 33 for ebert? Or vice versa.

Good luck to them if they can

If they get Ebert for less than Seaby, WCE should feel violated.

If Seaby is worth a pick in the 20's then so is Maric.

Agreed.

 

[pext]

If Seaby is worth a pick in the 20's then so is Maric.

That's what we're asking for!

Plus Seaby > Maric IMO.

 

[Lawrst]

That's what we're asking for!

Plus Seaby > Maric IMO.

This..

I think Seaby is a very good ruckman!

 

[jackster83]

If Seaby is worth a pick in the 20's then so is Maric.

Wouldn't they be better off just going for Maric then? Or does he hate Port too much?

 

[Crow About It]

If they get Ebert for less than Seaby, WCE should feel violated.
.

Yep.

The problem for port is 6 is too much and 29/33 is too little.
I don't think they have any players they are willing to part with that West Coast would want...

It's funny because pick 24 is about right for him I reckon.....

 

[Crow About It]

Plus Seaby > Maric IMO.

I agree and there's the problem. If port get Seaby for 29 then where are we at with Maric? 37 would prob be about right. That's where we're going to have to throw in a bit extra if we want more.

 

[PyroCrow]

In unrelated news it seems that Melbourne wants to go all out to get M.Clark. Freo might miss the boat on this if they are not careful. If Brisbane get Pick 12 I wonder if this would affect us?

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Yep.

The problem for port is 6 is too much and 29/33 is too little.
I don't think they have any players they are willing to part with that West Coast would want...

It's funny because pick 24 is about right for him I reckon.....

Port can easily trade Pick 6 to GWS for say Picks 9 and 25.

 

[FR0GGY]

Wouldn't they be better off just going for Maric then? Or does he hate Port too much?

He plays for them already. Just in a differnet guernsey

 

[Ned_Flanders]

With Hutchy reporting that mark seaby is meeting with port today, do port have enough currency to land both seaby and Ebert? Would require giving up pick 8 or a player I would have thought to get both.

Reading the Port board, they seem to be thinking:

Ebert - 29, but likely to need a little more (maybe a lower pick)

Seaby - third round pick

 

[Lawrst]

Port can easily trade Pick 6 to GWS for say Picks 9 and 25.

They would rather a chance at Wingard you would have thought.

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Well, yes, just depends on what they are after really.

If they wanted Seaby desperately and didn't want to give up any players, they'd try something like this.

 

[Crow About It]

Port can easily trade Pick 6 to GWS for say Picks 9 and 25.

I guess it depednds on how much port actually want ebert and how high they rate him. It's not just as simple as trading picks 6 for 9 and 25

 

[NikkiNoo]

Port can easily trade Pick 6 to GWS for say Picks 9 and 25.

Not so easily if the rumours about the interest in Goddard are true. Terry Wallets seems to think it would need to be two top ten draft picks as part of that trade. Not sure if that is what GWS would be willing to give. Until that is sorted out, Port could try and test the waters with GWS but it seems it would have to wait on discussions between Saints and GWS.

 

[Crow-eater]

Noble to be on TWR around 1:20 (12:50 Adelaide time)

 

[WheresGroomgone]

Terry Milera to the Saints as a pre listed GWS player in a deal with picks,
I wonder if that will give brother Tim a kick up the bum - who has decided to move back to Adelaide {the place not the team!].

 

[Mad Fan of AFL]

Did i hear wrongly..saint kilda wants Saad and Tim Milera..surely TWR meant Tim Mohr?

 

[spexau]

Terry Milera is his older brother, no?

 

[PyroCrow]

Did i hear wrongly..saint kilda wants Saad and Tim Milera..surely TWR meant Tim Mohr?

I was hoping we could get Saad

 

[Gets!]

I was hoping we could get Saad

I'd rather be Happy.

 

[WheresGroomgone]

Terry Milera is his older brother, no?

Yes he is, I heard about this trade yesterday but wasn't sure if it was going to be through trade week or the draft but there ya go, he's off to the Saints.