Trade Week

[Sideshow Fev]

Just checking out the Footy Games board and K.Simpson who was controlling Carlton made some pretty good moves. Just wondering what you guys would think if our trade week went like this:

Ins:Jaymie Graham, Troy Makepeace, Josh Drummond, Pick 8, 13, 38

Outs: Jordan Russel, Nick Stevens, Paul Bower, Matthew Lappin, Bret Thornton

Draft Picks:
1. Carlton
8. Carlton
13. Carlton
17. Carlton
19. Carlton
35. Carlton
38. Carlton

 

[TommyMcG]

Def wouldn't want to trade bower, not sure who would want matty lappin. Stevens is an interesting one. Wonder if his name will be floated around come trade week... I'd be all for it.

 

[Jeremias]

Only player I would really not want to trade is Bower-looks an excellent prospect.

Don't really want to trade Russell either.

Wouldn't REALLY mind if we traded either Lappin or Stevens, as long as we got picks and/or youth for them.

 

[Salaryman]

Just checking out the Footy Games board and K.Simpson who was controlling Carlton made some pretty good moves. Just wondering what you guys would think if our trade week went like this:

Ins:Jaymie Graham, Troy Makepeace, Josh Drummond, Pick 8, 13, 38

Outs: Jordan Russel, Nick Stevens, Paul Bower, Matthew Lappin, Bret Thornton

Draft Picks:
1. Carlton
8. Carlton
13. Carlton
17. Carlton
19. Carlton
35. Carlton
38. Carlton

I would almost take that: For arguments sake

IN:Jaymie Graham, Troy Makepeace, Josh Drummond, Bryce Gibbs, Albert Proud, Daniel Connors, Brock O'Brien, Travis Boak, Brent Renouf, David McKay

Outs: Jordan Russel, Nick Stevens, Paul Bower, Matthew Lappin, Bret Thornton

 

[blues4flag]

Just checking out the Footy Games board and K.Simpson who was controlling Carlton made some pretty good moves. Just wondering what you guys would think if our trade week went like this:

Ins:Jaymie Graham, Troy Makepeace, Josh Drummond, Pick 8, 13, 38

Outs: Jordan Russel, Nick Stevens, Paul Bower, Matthew Lappin, Bret Thornton

Draft Picks:
1. Carlton
8. Carlton
13. Carlton
17. Carlton
19. Carlton
35. Carlton
38. Carlton

No way would I want Makepeace at the club, besides, at 27 he doesn't fit in with the youth policy .

 

[Dramoth]

Keep Bower... he has the makings of a damned fine player... didnt get all that flustered in his couple of games at the end of the year and had a couple of good touches...

Might have to take pick 15 and Thurgood from the Hawks for Thornton...

 

[HBF]

Pretty good effort, but would prefer to keep Bower. Looks like an excellent prospect.

 

[Dramoth]

Plus you have to love the afro

We need people with a little character in the club!

 

[jj1978]

In relation to Bower, I think I read in an article on the AFL website how a current recruit said his worst game was against Bower.... Bower towelled him up.

 

[zoofest43]

I think Bower has shown enough to stay a blue for a long time to come, but in saying that i think J.Waite should be tried at CHB and left there all year to learn. with the likes of J.Kennedy and B.Fisher across half foward having Waite down there seems to me like a bit of over kill. would be interested to see what others think on the matter cheers.

 

[blues4flag]

No chance of Bower being traded, I don't think. Can't trade our talented youngsters, he has heaps of potential.

 

[blangerang]

How are we getting Jamie Graham?

 

[DIG]

Just checking out the Footy Games board and K.Simpson who was controlling Carlton made some pretty good moves. Just wondering what you guys would think if our trade week went like this:

Ins:Jaymie Graham, Troy Makepeace, Josh Drummond, Pick 8, 13, 38

Outs: Jordan Russel, Nick Stevens, Paul Bower, Matthew Lappin, Bret Thornton

Draft Picks:
1. Carlton
8. Carlton
13. Carlton
17. Carlton
19. Carlton
35. Carlton
38. Carlton

Pretty radical, as you'd expect in a game, but 5 picks in the top 20 of this draft, plus Graham and Drummond? Sounds good to me.

Lose Stevens, Lappin for short term pain plus Thornton who's going anyway. Would hurt to lose the 2 young-uns, but yeah i'd still take that. Would be the draft that would set us up for future glory.

 

[blangerang]

How are we getting Jamie Graham?

i want answers

 

[HBF]

How are we getting Jamie Graham?

Don't worry bud, it's only a draft game.

 

[blangerang]

Don't worry bud, it's only a draft game.

mama magooza mweeee

 

[K.Simpson]

Ok, to answer some questions:

I traded N.Stevens and J.Russel to WCE for pick 13 and J.Graham
IMO pick 13>stevo and graham>russel

AND! im in with a shot at winning this!

so, if you reckon ive done ok vote for me! im vsing adelaide, i beat essendon

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=275098

CARLTON
B: J Graham, N Brown, A Walker
HB: J Drummond, L Whitnall, H Scotland
C: R Houlihan, M Murphy, K Simpson
HF: B Fisher, J Waite, A Carrazzo
F: E Betts, B Fevola, M Thorp
R: C Bryan, B Gibbs, A Koutafidies
INT: B Renouf, S O'Hailpin, J Riewoldt, A Bentick

 

[Sideshow Fev]

I voted, you still need a few more votes to get you over the line

 

[BlueBelle]

I voted for you too although I would prefer to keep Stevo than gain Graham