Trade?

[RangaInTeal]

Just throwing this out there, looking for some response getting nothing on the Port Board...

I would love to give StKilda, Seccond round pick (#23), Daniel Perce and Toby Thurstans, we also give Fremantle our Third round pick, StKilda give Fremantle there seccond round pick , Fremantle give us Josh Carr and StKilda Scott Thornton.

Port
Pick #5
Justin Kossi
Josh Carr
pick #55

StKilda
Pick #10
Pick #23
Pick #44
Pick #60
Toby Thurstans
Daniel Pearce
Scott Thornton

Fremantle
Pick #3
Pick #21
Pick #28
Pick #39
Pick #53

Looking at this I wouldn't mind a midle range pick, but... Josh Carr and Justin Kossie could be the difference between 2007 and 2009, and we still have pick #5...

Pretty much Fremantle get three second rounders (rebuilding a club with bad culture) for Josh Carr and Scott Thornton, StKilda get Scott Thornton and a premiership player in Toby Thurstans to cover Matt Maguire and Max Hudgton if they cant get up next year and Daniel Pearce to inject some pace into there rather lethargic midfield, maybe Pearcy cover Harvey's wing next year, if this is his last, and Port get a GOOD Full forward and/or Second runckman a premiership winning in and under onballer to add some MORE mongrel and a bit of strength around the stoppages and keep their early pick...

Fremantle finishing 14th Port finishing 12th Saints finishing 7th...

 

[Goedy]

???? why

 

[RangaInTeal]

Cause I have a man crush on Kossie and would like Josh Carr back in the Teal! and this is one way i could see three teams agreing on letting players go...

 

[TassieSaint]

Nice try. Toby Thurstans is a terrible player, leaks goals. Scot Thornton shouldn't be playing AFL. Danyle Pearce is alright, but I'd much rather we draft a fast mid than trade for one.

We've had enough of trading for players and I'll be dissappointed if we recycle anymore. If we are going to trade it will be for picks, for instance Kosi for pick 5 straight swap (we gave you pick 6 for Brooks, least you could do is give us that deal )

 

[Squizz]

If we are going to trade it will be for someone who has some pace and can kick.

I like the look of Daniel Connors, who we could get for nothing?

 

[RangaInTeal]

If we are going to trade it will be for picks, for instance Kosi for pick 5 straight swap (we gave you pick 6 for Brooks, least you could do is give us that deal )

Ild rather McEvoy for pick #5... I can't see it happening but hey...

 

[Squizz]

What's wrong with Lade and the Bogan?

 

[RangaInTeal]

What's wrong with Lade and the Bogan?

Lade is well past it, he was up and down last season and now, this season, he has just been down... DeLuca seems to be an OK ruckman, and Giles looks like he needs another 5 year (starting to look a bit Cain Acklandish), Kossie and McEvoy look to be the two best ruck prospects along with Wood that might be within reach!

 

[Squizz]

After taking Ackland and Brooks off your hands, I can't see the Saints getting burned again with Port.

Good to hear Lade is off his game, as I'm sick of him giving the Burgoyne's an armchair ride in games against us. The Bogan just sits at CHB and we kick to him like we've already traded for him.

 

[TassieSaint]

Kossie and McEvoy look to be the two best ruck prospects along with Wood that might be within reach!

McEvoy is probably one of the least within reach ruckmen in the comp. Not only is he contracted for 2 years, but he was drafted with the intention of holding up the ruck duties at St Kilda for the next decade and is our only young ruck prospect. Not to mention the fact his family and friends all live in Victoria. There is simply no way he will be traded at the end of this year.

 

[biscay]

No more re cycled players.thankyou ,unless you got a Ablett etc

 

[HoldenMCaulfield]

... Saints finishing 7th...

Don't take it personally, but that's the only part I liked about your idea.

I admit, I do like Pearce, but he's not really in his 2006 form any more, is he ?

 

[SaintsSeptember]

After taking Ackland and Brooks off your hands, I can't see the Saints getting burned again with Port.

Good to hear Lade is off his game, as I'm sick of him giving the Burgoyne's an armchair ride in games against us. The Bogan just sits at CHB and we kick to him like we've already traded for him.

Add Watts and make it any S.A. based club.

 

[Kram]

Scot Thornton shouldn't be playing AFL.

He should be lucky to even play WAFL..

 

[Sainters66]

Justin Kossie could be the difference between 2007 and 2009, and we still have pick #5...



Sorry mate. We're not trading Kosi. Putt Kosi in the ruck. Kosi and McEvoy will be rucking for the Saints for the next ten years.

 

[RoJo Junior]

Ahh Sainters you guys are the freo of victoria, when it comes to trades and performances. What is with all the recycled players, you guys like freo had the potential for a premiership years ago but stuffed it and then had your clear out and "rebuild" with old hasbeens. I just dont get it, and the talk of you guys gettin cousins... why?? Cuzzy is a gun but.. You wont win a premiership in the next 2 years your wasting perfectly good youngsters development. Plus last thing u need is Cuz n Gardy together again. Stopping being a freo!!! Oh well at least you can beat them

 

[Benchwarmer77]

If we are going to trade it will be for someone who has some pace and can kick.

I like the look of Daniel Connors, who we could get for nothing?

I dont think the tigers would let this kid go for nothing, should be a good player for us just needs his fitness up

You can trade us Dal Santo if you want lol

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Ahh Sainters you guys are the freo of victoria, when it comes to trades and performances. What is with all the recycled players, you guys like freo had the potential for a premiership years ago but stuffed it and then had your clear out and "rebuild" with old hasbeens. I just dont get it, and the talk of you guys gettin cousins... why?? Cuzzy is a gun but.. You wont win a premiership in the next 2 years your wasting perfectly good youngsters development. Plus last thing u need is Cuz n Gardy together again. Stopping being a freo!!! Oh well at least you can beat them

The discussion was whether the saints supporters would want your cast of piece of s***.
Why don't you go away and reminisce about the good old days?
Has Lynch kicked many goals lately?

 

[Squizz]

I dont think the tigers would let this kid go for nothing, should be a good player for us just needs his fitness up

You'd want to give him a game soon, or he might want to play with his brother at the Saints!

 

[Benchwarmer77]

You'd want to give him a game soon, or he might want to play with his brother at the Saints!

Yeah your probably rite mate

I would hate to see him go

 

[Sir Robert]

Yeah we'll take Connors fo shoure.

Re Daniel Pearce... Would be nice but I'd prefer Kosi.

I'd love to pay out on that WCE supporter after they won the GF they annoyed the sh!t outta me... However 1) they won a gf, and 2) off-loading Judd I think will almost make them stronger, even if it isn't the case at the moment.

Fu&k it.... Eat sh!t mate. Enjoy the cellar!

 

[beaver fever]

I hear that St.Kilda are pretty keen on daniel connors. What would be on offer for him?

 

[sainter12riewoldt]

Port
Pick #5
Justin Kossi
Josh Carr
pick #55

StKilda
Pick #10
Pick #23
Pick #44
Pick #60
Toby Thurstans
Daniel Pearce
Scott Thornton

StKilda get Scott Thornton and a premiership player in Toby Thurstans to cover Matt Maguire and Max Hudgton if they cant get up next year and Daniel Pearce to inject some pace into there rather lethargic midfield, maybe Pearcy cover Harvey's wing next year,

Wouldnt trade Kosi, not even for those three players. stkilda have got enough players to cover wing. (Hayes,Goddard,Gram,Geary) just to name few.
stkilda have premiership players, King (cats vfl/afl 2007, Schiender (syd 2005), Demster (syd 2005).
max will play on

 

[sainter12riewoldt]

You'd want to give him a game soon, or he might want to play with his brother at the Saints!

lets get him and jack riewoldt and give them Raph Clarke?

 

[sainter12riewoldt]

Ahh Sainters you guys are the freo of victoria, when it comes to trades and performances. What is with all the recycled players, you guys like freo had the potential for a premiership years ago but stuffed it and then had your clear out and "rebuild" with old hasbeens. I just dont get it, and the talk of you guys gettin cousins... why?? Cuzzy is a gun but.. You wont win a premiership in the next 2 years your wasting perfectly good youngsters development. Plus last thing u need is Cuz n Gardy together again. Stopping being a freo!!! Oh well at least you can beat them

can u please tell me where you heard this rubbish about cousins. i dont want him, saints dont need him, he doesnt deserve to play for neone, then again he'll fit in well with collingwood, lol!