Transfer discussion thread

[Marcel Proust]

Ill make a

The case that no lfc players are world class discussion

So that the latest transfer news is the prominent posts here

 

[jod23]

Lewandowski
Kane
Aguero
Suarez
Werner*
Mbappe*
Immobile

Not always playing as the CF*

Haaland??

Firmino isn't really a CF. He's like a false 9. He's definitely would class for mine. Not sure edgy you think he's a system player. Was very good at Hoffenheim which is why we bought him and has been amazing at Liverpool.

 

[jod23]

Ill make a

The case that no lfc players are world class discussion

So that the latest transfer news is the prominent posts here

Wait did you just say you don't think any LFC players are world class?

 

[Procrastinator35]

Ill make a

The case that no lfc players are world class discussion

So that the latest transfer news is the prominent posts here.

Joddy & Cruyffy need new material…..The last page reads like a confession of just how badly scarred they've both become, at the hands of United.

"We shall overcome some-day."

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Firmino isn't really a CF. He's like a false 9. He's definitely would class for mine. Not sure edgy you think he's a system player. Was very good at Hoffenheim which is why we bought him and has been amazing at Liverpool.

False 9, poacher, second striker, centre forward. Define it however you want, when you put 11 dots on a football pitch it is the position of the focal point. The central attacking player, of which there are others who play different roles in the same position who are IMO better.

He may be the best false 9, but that doesn't mean he's the best in the nominal CF slot.

 

[jod23]

False 9, poacher, second striker, centre forward. Define it however you want, when you put 11 dots on a football pitch it is the position of the focal point. The central attacking player, of which there are others who play different roles in the same position who are IMO better.

He may be the best false 9, but that doesn't mean he's the best in the nominal CF slot.

I didn't say he was the best CF. I just said he's world class. Oozes quality. Knits or entire team together.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

I didn't say he was the best CF. I just said he's world class. Oozes quality. Knits or entire team together.

Nevermind Jod. I was using your own metric against you.
Lordy

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Multiple PL winner and once England’s no.1 now cut by Ginger Mourinho.

 

[SM]

Multiple PL winner and once England’s no.1 now cut by Ginger Mourinho.

Reckon he could end up at one of the promoted clubs, maybe Fulham if they come up. But hard to say where he goes otherwise unless he goes back abroad.

 

[Pykie]

Agree on the others, but Firmino isnt for mine

Liverpool have good players in a good system being played to within an inch of their strengths.

TAA and Robertson wouldn't get a game at Bayern, Barca or Real. If they would, they would be all over them.

I just don't think they would be anywhere near as effective in a different system.

They aren't world class for mine. Just possibly the best 2 possible role players in their position for Klopps system in English football.

Firmino fits into the same category for mine.

Anyway, back to the transfers.

 

[jod23]

Nevermind Jod. I was using your own metric against you.
Lordy

I know what you were trying to do. I said a world class player was probably best 5ish in the world in his position and then you named a bunch of CFs who score more goals. I then said Firm isn't really a CF... more a false 9. They're ain't more than 5 false 9's in world football that does what Firmino does better.

 

[Bradesmaen]

Who is Minamino going to be sold to in the summer? Or loaned to

 

[Art Vandelay_]

I know what you were trying to do. I said a world class player was probably best 5ish in the world in his position and then you named a bunch of CFs who score more goals. I then said Firm isn't really a CF... more a false 9. They're ain't more than 5 false 9's in world football that does what Firmino does better.

Whoosh

 

[Cruyff14]

Joddy & Cruyffy need new material…..The last page reads like a confession of just how badly scarred they've both become, at the hands of United.

"We shall overcome some-day."

What?

Bizarre post. Even for your standards.

 

[chef]

Not sure anyones scarred by United anymore, they've been crap for a while now.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Bizarre post. Even for your standards.

ah Yes, the usual Cruyffy tactic….Pull the word 'bizarre' out of his clacker, when he's got no other come-back.....King of the 'bizarre'.

Don't ever become too obvious or too predictable.

 

[UnitedWarrior93]

Not sure anyones scarred by United anymore, they've been crap for a while now.

those days are gone, really not any team worth being ‘scared’ of these days.

 

[Cruyff14]

ah Yes, the usual Cruyffy tactic….Pull the word 'bizarre' out of his clacker, when he's got no other come-back.....King of the 'bizarre'.

Don't ever become too obvious or too predictable.

What?

To be honest I try to avoid engaging with you whenever possible. Your knowledge - or lack there of - on here has been exposed more often than not.

I like how you conveniently ignored chef's comment too.

Your comment made no sense to begin with. Hence the bizarre. It's not rocket science.

 

[Marcel Proust]

* Odegaard to not play for real next season again

 

[chef]

 

[mike123]

Allison for example wouldn't get a game at City or Barca

Doesn’t Allison play ahead of Cities keeper for Brazil?

 

[chef]

Doesn’t Allison play ahead of Cities keeper for Brazil?

Yeah, I'd only have Oblak clearly ahead of Allison.

Hes a gun and Chelsea stuffed up big time not buying him when we had the chance. Hesitated and allowed Liverpool to swoop in.

 

[Marcel Proust]

Doesn’t Allison play ahead of Cities keeper for Brazil?

Yeah but would he start at City ?

 

[Marcel Proust]

Yeah, I'd only have Oblak clearly ahead of Allison.

Hes a gun and Chelsea stuffed up big time not buying him when we had the chance. Hesitated and allowed Liverpool to swoop in.

Yet he isn't world class going by the criteria he'd get a game at any team - A Madrid

MTS is better too...

 

[Cruyff14]

Doesn’t Allison play ahead of Cities keeper for Brazil?

Yeah but why let facts get in the way of a good story?