Transfer discussion thread

[Magma]

34 games in the U18s

1 LM, 1 CB, 2 RB and 30 at LB. 4 caps for England U20 at LB. Plays for the senior team at LB. if he is a RB there certainly isn’t much evidence of it

united should clearly stop playing him out of position.

 

[11kgm]

Don't think ole will be targeting back up players with United 60odd points behind LFC

Rw, dm, cb, lb.

If ighalo stays, another striker isn't required

34 points

 

[Marcel Proust]

united should clearly stop playing him out of position.

It's not that easy to get a game at right back for United

 

[chef]

How many other players have scored in every month of the year? Thats gotta be worth a few years on his new contract.

Im happy for him to be Hakim's backup. He'll be good depth for someone.

 

[chef]

Whoever is doing the DoF role at cfc, has a point not wanting to give big money to an old winger. That relies a bit on Pace. Who might not make the bench of the best side , game1 next season. Given the deep squad upfront

Petr Cech is our technical and performance adviser. Him, Marina and Frank seem to be all on the same page and its working well.

 

[Magma]

It's not that easy to get a game at right back for United

especially if you're a natural left back

 

[Marcel Proust]

especially if you're a natural left back

Williams has been the 2nd choice rb this season

So chilwell and shaw + awb and Williams is possible

 

[pantskyle]

Cause williams is a rb - he was lb cause shaw was rubbish or has injury. Awb and Williams locks down the 2 position for ten years

And they don't really need anything outside of

Rw
6
Cb

I wrote it in detail 15 pages back but people were getting shitty

He is 100% a LB.

 

[pantskyle]

Williams has been the 2nd choice rb this season

So chilwell and shaw + awb and Williams is possible

No he hasn't. Has been second choice LB. In fact he was almost first choice when Shaw hit some poor form.

The only reason he has played RB is when he is coming on just to get minutes. Has even been used as a LWB.

 

[Marcel Proust]

Shaw and cash for chilwell might work too. Swap deals seem more popular.

No he hasn't. Has been second choice LB. In fact he was almost first choice when Shaw hit some poor form.

The only reason he has played RB is when he is coming on just to get minutes. Has even been used as a LWB.

So who the back up rb?

Dalot seems to have fallen out favor.

Williams right footed too

 

[Buckleys Jocks]

Williams right footed too

I think you've got this confused.

Williams was a natural right back but he has broken into the first team as a left back and is very obviously only being considered as an option on that left side now.

Also, Shaw plus cash for Chilwell is an awful idea. Shaw has been one of our best on this unbeaten run and is linking superbly with Rashford. Williams has also been more than adequate as his understudy. A new left back is way, way down on the list of priorities for this team IMO, but this is a subject that should be discussed in the United thread...

 

[pantskyle]

Shaw and cash for chilwell might work too. Swap deals seem more popular.



So who the back up rb?

Dalot seems to have fallen out favor.

Williams right footed too

Not sure why you're attempting to argue against a fact.

United are not interested in Chilwell and why would we get rid of Shaw and cash for him? Shaw is better.

 

[chef]

 

[Art Vandelay_]

The part at the end misquotes him as he says “attacking players” but hope this means the Willian hype is BS and it will be fullbacks, CDM and central defence.

Not some campaigner winger who dogged us in his prime now wants a top up to his pension. Should tell him to **** off to West Ham for an easy pay day and no ****s needing to be given

 

[kaiserchief13]

"We can't get better players than what we have" because everyone better wont want to go there

 

[Art Vandelay_]

"We can't get better players than what we have" because everyone better wont want to go there

Life is much easier being a Bayern plastic. You follow the campaigners of European football, congrats.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Life is much easier being a Bayern plastic. You follow the campaigners of European football, congrats.

7-2 must still be keeping you up going by that response

BTW I was a fan of Bayern during their lean years as well early this century, so there are fans that haven't just existed recently

 

[Art Vandelay_]

7-2 must still be keeping you up going by that response

No. Cos I’m normal.
If a sports result over 6 months ago keeps you up you’ve got some deep problems.

Juve and Bayern are two peas in a pod. cannibalise their leagues and neutrals hate them.

 

[kaiserchief13]

No. Cos I’m normal.
If a sports result over 6 months ago keeps you up you’ve got some deep problems.

Juve and Bayern are two peas in a pod. cannibalise their leagues and neutrals hate them.

How many players in Bayern's squad come from other top German clubs? Majority are from other leagues or small-mid table teams, which is the same as the likes of Real, Barca, Man City, Liverpool

 

[11kgm]

How many players in Bayern's squad come from other top German clubs? Majority are from other leagues or small-mid table teams, which is the same as the likes of Real, Barca, Man City, Liverpool

Lewa
Nueur
Hummells
Gotze
Sule

 

[kaiserchief13]

Lewa
Nueur
Hummells
Gotze
Sule

Lewandowski was free transfer
Neuer from Schalke, a mid table team
Hummels was a Bayern youth product that went to Dortmund then came back
Goetze is not even at Bayern anymore and is actually back at Dortmund now
Suele again from a mid table team

Do Liverpool, Man Utd etc not sign players from Leicester, Arsenal, Everton etc?

 

[pantskyle]

Lewandowski was free transfer
Neuer from Schalke, a mid table team
Hummels was a Bayern youth product that went to Dortmund then came back
Goetze is not even at Bayern anymore and is actually back at Dortmund now
Suele again from a mid table team

Do Liverpool, Man Utd etc not sign players from Leicester, Arsenal, Everton etc?

I don't dislike BM at all, terrific club but they are a very hypocritical club. But that's life.

 

[kaiserchief13]

I don't dislike BM at all, terrific club but they are a very hypocritical club. But that's life.

How are they hypocritical?

 

[11kgm]

Lewandowski was free transfer
Neuer from Schalke, a mid table team
Hummels was a Bayern youth product that went to Dortmund then came back
Goetze is not even at Bayern anymore and is actually back at Dortmund now
Suele again from a mid table team

Do Liverpool, Man Utd etc not sign players from Leicester, Arsenal, Everton etc?

generally transfers don't happen between the top 4 sides

 

[pantskyle]

How are they hypocritical?

Rummendige bitches constantly about English clubs spending and literally does the same thing.