Roast Treloar’s partner fumes after being made the ‘scapegoat’ by Collingwood

[nut]

I can’t imagine how bad the pies would be if they had of kept Treloar ... they dodged a bullet there.

 

[Jamolad]

Think the netty season started this weekend. Hope they've done a welfare-check on Treloar, given Collingwood's serious concerns.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Think the netty season started this weekend. Hope they've done a welfare-check on Treloar, given Collingwood's serious concerns.

Hope treloar dominates from here on just to make the pies look even dumber

 

[rumply]

I can’t imagine how bad the pies would be if they had of kept Treloar ... they dodged a bullet there.

 

[Toump Ass]

I can’t imagine how bad the pies would be if they had of kept Treloar ... they dodged a bullet there.

Couldn't agree more.

They have been very well served by keeping De Goey around on $750,000 a year too.

Bit unfortunate about having to pay Beams though... but what can you do? Completely unforeseeable turn of events, that one.

 

[Back One Out]

Is it true that Collingwood are paying Adam Treloar to play for the Bulldogs?

 

[Dazb86]

Is it true that Collingwood are paying Adam Treloar to play for the Bulldogs?

Only 300k per season

 

[Back One Out]

Only 300k per season

Oh well, in that case, I suppose they are getting pretty good value for their money

Treloar is playing better than De Goey, who they're paying $1.5 mill

 

[Mofra]

Oh well, in that case, I suppose they are getting pretty good value for their money

Treloar is playing better than De Goey, who they're paying $1.5 mill

* also paying $1.5m

It's $300k pa for five years to Treloar.
Trade for the equivalent (on current ladder positions) of pick 44.

 

[Back One Out]

* also paying $1.5m

It's $300k pa for five years to Treloar.
Trade for the equivalent (on current ladder positions) of pick 44.

We got Tom "Bargain Bin" Phillips for pick 65 in that fire sale, but I think we're paying his wages unfortunately

 

[beema limapep]

I can’t imagine how bad the pies would be if they had of kept Treloar ... they dodged a bullet there.

Especially considering "nobody liked him' at Collingwood. Could have been a real performance issue for the playing group and buckley.

 

[Astro_]

We got Tom "Bargain Bin" Phillips for pick 65 in that fire sale, but I think we're paying his wages unfortunately

Hawks are paying his wages because he only cost you pick 65

 

[nut]

Clubs using the term ... “it’s a cut throat business” ... to justify treating people like Treloar like s**t, are just lazy.
... it’s not hard to treat people the right way.

 

[living_in_syd]

* also paying $1.5m

It's $300k pa for five years to Treloar.
Trade for the equivalent (on current ladder positions) of pick 44.

Hope we can hit up Ned Guy for some deals at the end of the season

 

[76woodenspooners]

Pretty amazing how much media time / column inches / minutes is being dedicated to this silly jumper issue ...

Irrespective of whether you think the jumper issue is ‘silly‘, it does show the club‘s character that they’re prepared to fight on the moral high ground ... selectively.

... and they are letting Maguire run free on non-issues instead of hammering him on his poor leadership on Treloar.

Ed has gone. He’s ancient history ...

... but worth noting what the new President has since done:

Apology to Lumumba? Yep

Admit Treloar thing was handled poorly? Yep. Apology to Ravillion? Nup

The fact they cooked their salary cap and hung one of their "side by side' players out to dry is ridiculous.

Um, two players actually.

Something that seems to have escaped mention in all of this is that Ravillion had been a Collingwood player too (netball). You don’t treat your own like that. And you don’t treat their WAG / HAB like that either.

 

[76woodenspooners]

They have been very well served by keeping De Goey around on $750,000 a year too.

DeGoey has a day in court in his future - that makes him untradeable.

 

[Mofra]

We got Tom "Bargain Bin" Phillips for pick 65 in that fire sale, but I think we're paying his wages unfortunately

Most pick 65s play about 20 games over their career. You still got an absolute steal

 

[00Stinger]

Clubs using the term ... “it’s a cut throat business” ... to justify treating people like Treloar like sh*t, are just lazy.
... it’s not hard to treat people the right way.

meh Treloar walked out on a club himself only weeks after saying he loved the place and the rumors of him leaving were totally false

 

[kozi]

* also paying $1.5m

It's $300k pa for five years to Treloar.
Trade for the equivalent (on current ladder positions) of pick 44.

It’s an interesting investment strategy. Let’s see if it works out for them.

 

[Anja_Nees]

DeGoey has a day in court in his future - that makes him untradeable.

The thing is it probably meant you could pay him a whole lot less when he re-signed. All this salary talk is speculation so it might be you did, but the reports are that he’s on a very good wicket.

Were it me I would have punted him and kept one or two of the others but we probably know 10% of what has actually happened.

 

[Norm De Guerre]

Clubs using the term ... “it’s a cut throat business” ... to justify treating people like Treloar like sh*t, are just lazy.
... it’s not hard to treat people the right way.

Its a lot easier sell than telling your supporter base that you list management practices are bordering on the incompetent.

Especially when they were in the business of selling pre-season hope for what was shaping up and has proven to be a disastrous season.

 

[The 747]

Hope we can hit up Ned Guy for some deals at the end of the season

There is going to be a line for the Collingwood table at trade and draft time if Ned Guy is still there.