sr36
Hall of Famer
That's the technicality, but the practicality is that Roughed has already been replaced by Carmichael in the list of 42. We still need to create 3 vacancies in the list before the draft - after trades. Carmichael being a rookie helps salary cap, because ideally you run at 36 and 6 rookies, but the Roughy list spot in the 42 is already taken.The effect is the same, but to be technical, no, Carmichael hasn't replaced Roughy in the 42. Rough still on it. Think it was Kreuger who had the season ender, but that is no matter. The MSRD effectively creates a temporary extra spot on the rookie list. That is where Carmichael will sit. This is important because Carmichael can stay on the rookie list rather than being on the senior list.