Trent Cotchin or Marc Murphy, who has disappointed the most?

[OnceKicked50]

Pretty similar players. In 2011 Murphy won All-Australian, a B&F and was named the AFLCA player of the year. The following year Cotchin won a Brownlow, B&F and All-Aus selection. Both were named captains of their respective clubs in 2013.

If we rewind back to 2011/2012 each of these players were loved by most neutral supporters and considered fait accompli to become top 10 players of the competition. Today, both are derided by opposition supporters and fans alike. Murphy in 2011, Cotchin in 2012, neither has had a better season since.

Who has been the biggest disappointment?

 

[Lethality]

I would say Cotchin, due to his September form.

 

[ManOfClay]

Too hard to split.

Both victims of being pumped up by being at big clubs. Haven't delivered on the hype

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Thread serves no purpose other than to pot players.

"Biggest disappointment"? Is that really want you want to see discussed?

OP, I think you need to think hard before starting another thread.