Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day Trial V Pear 20.2

  • Thread starter Thread starter beartoo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Ryan & Sholl... as not much else in the other team.
I can just see it:

Nicks: "Ok Oscar, you're not getting a game. You're not the last player on the list but you're close. That Welsh kid who was hiding KFC in his locker all year and that new kid who hasn't played football for 5 years are behind you".

Ryan: "Aw. What about Lachie?".

Nicks: "Oh he's in front of you".

Ryan: "Aw. He's literally worn a North Melbourne guernsey for most of the preseason".

Nicks: "Hah! Yeah. Don't worry, you'll get a game".

Ryan: "Really?"

Nicks: "Nah, god you're gullible".
 
Last edited:
Sholl should have left in the offseason he'd be getting a game at Carlton Melbourne Richmond.

I can't believe he's been left out completely, he does have AFL qualities and it seems we've put him out to pasture
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Live streamed via port site
The port site says it's on Kayo.

But you can get a cheap $5/month Kayo membership here for 2 months as a new subscriber:

 
I'd imagine he's just far down the list in the As and McAndrew will still be the main guy? Please? Nicks come on it is not a hard decision to make.
Says players from the squad will play SANFL trial and there’s only 18 named there so still coukd easily see th clear pecking order emerge
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Ryan must have run over Nicks' dog or something. Can't even get selected with an extended team with half the A's out
Didn’t Ryan have a serious injury at the end of last season and that impacted the start of his pre season?

8 week hamstring and then broke his jaw.
 
Last edited:
He does but this means he's in our bottom 8 or so players in the Nicks pecking order

I actually thought he was delisted. There isn't anyone on the selected list of 29 that would be behind him IMO. I probably would've said Cook twelve months ago but they're trying something new with him off half back.
 
Marsh named in the ones is cool. Good to see Billy, Cheddar and Ibis there, too

Will ROB actually play? Or is he just in the squad for numbers?
I figure we will run a bench of 23 at any point in time, but will give some who play in the sanfl a quarter or so later in the game.

Allow us to manage players like Soligo who i doubt we would want to have a full hit out.
 
There's not much value in Sholl playing in the trial match.

We already know exactly what kind of player he is, and there's likely no development left in him. He's a useful depth option, nothing more. We may as well put time into players who are either first-choice options, or else still have question marks over their ongoing development.

I feel for Ryan, though. He's at the point in his career where he should absolutely be playing a trial match.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I actually thought he was delisted. There isn't anyone on the selected list of 29 that would be behind him IMO. I probably would've said Cook twelve months ago but they're trying something new with him off half back.

If you were selecting a 23rd player for an actual AFL side this week, he would be ahead of Marsh, T. Murray and Edwards. But those players may yet become more than just a depth option. Sholl never will.
 
There's not much value in Sholl playing in the trial match.

We already know exactly what kind of player he is, and there's likely no development left in him. He's a useful depth option, nothing more. We may as well put time into players who are either first-choice options, or else still have question marks over their ongoing development.

I feel for Ryan, though. He's at the point in his career where he should absolutely be playing a trial match.
I thought for the bits I saw last week Ryan wasn’t too bad.
 
Amended A Team...

B: Michaelanny, Butts, Murray
HB: Cook, Worrell, Milera
C: Jones, Dawson, Dowling
HF: ANB, Fogarty, Keays
F: Pedlar, Thilthorpe, Walker
R: McAndrew, Rachele, Peatling
I: Laird, Berry, Edwards, Nankervis, Taylor

im all for star players missing this game. means very little. Nicks is simply not a coach who rewards players for form in the Sanfl. So the only way to put your hand up for selection unfortunately is to basically put your name up in lights in trial games. If Dowling, Ryan, Edwards, Taylor cant do it in these games they may as well kiss their AFL hopes good bye ad pray for injuries.
 
There's not much value in Sholl playing in the trial match.

We already know exactly what kind of player he is, and there's likely no development left in him. He's a useful depth option, nothing more. We may as well put time into players who are either first-choice options, or else still have question marks over their ongoing development.

I feel for Ryan, though. He's at the point in his career where he should absolutely be playing a trial match.

They play the B Team dont they after 3 qrtr time?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom