MRP / Trib. Tribunal Thread - rules and offences discombobulation

[RussellEbertHandball]

Not quite correct, appeals against fines are being challenged by written submissions this season. Only appeals against suspensions are being heard by the tribunal.

Guilty or not? Tribunal makes call on Grimes and Vlastuin's staging charges

The AFL confirms outcomes from Tuesday's Tribunal relating to the written submissions from Dylan Grimes, Nick Vlastuin, Lachlan Murphy, and Ed Langdon

www.afl.com.au

The AFL wishes to confirm the outcomes from last night's AFL Tribunal relating to the written submissions from Richmond's Dylan Grimes, Richmond's Nick Vlastuin, Adelaide Crows' Lachlan Murphy, and Melbourne's Ed Langdon.

......
Please note: As previously communicated, Tribunal proceedings have been simplified for challenges to financial sanctions, where at the election of the charged player, a single legally trained jury member may decide the matter on the basis of written submissions only. The charged player is not required to attend a Tribunal hearing. The AFL then communicates the outcome on behalf of the Tribunal.

 

[Spadge]

that to date is the most disgusting act I’ve seen on a footy field and I played ammos in Elizabeth in the 90’s

Judd was a sh*t bloke on the field.

you could have stopped after "bloke"

 

[Spadge]

Riewoldt was the only one upset about it

People forget that McEvoy was Riewoldts team mate at St Kilda between 2008 and 2013

says it all really

 

[philreich]

I wonder if Stevie Wonder is interested in a position within the AFL. In certain cases, he couldn't be a worse umpire, he'd be a better CEO than McLaughlin, and he'd certainly do a better job than Christian.

 

[Hammer#8]

Out of all this, theres nothing in how SPP plays that needs to be changed. Him bringing that intensity to the contest is what he needs to bring week in, week out.

Should he get unlucky and cop a fine here and there, then so be it.

 

[Waspy79]

 

[sobrave]

that to date is the most disgusting act I’ve seen on a footy field and I played ammos in Elizabeth in the 90’s

Judd was a sh*t bloke on the field.

Funny how he never got booed, but Goodes did. Goodes used to s**t me on field with some of his sneaky trips, tunnelling and pushing blokes into packs. He never did anything out and out dirty like Judd did. Judd also had multiple instances of eye gouging

 

[It Just Is]

I’d like to see the justification for Grimes getting off. If that’s not staging nothing ever will be.

 

[Powerade 08]

I’d like to see the justification for Grimes getting off. If that’s not staging nothing ever will be.

Famous Olympic diver Kane Cornes is the only player to ever do it. No prizes for guessing which club he played for.

AFL puts Kane Cornes on notice for 'diving'

Kane Cornes becomes first footballer to be officially investigated for staging.

www.theage.com.au

 

[Janey]

Funny how he never got booed, but Goodes did. Goodes used to sh*t me on field with some of his sneaky trips, tunnelling and pushing blokes into packs. He never did anything out and out dirty like Judd did. Judd also had multiple instances of eye gouging

Was it Judd that also had the 'pressure point' incident, or am I getting mixed up with someone else. Either way Judd was just a dirty player. Not tough, just underhanded, cowardly stuff.

 

[sobrave]

Was it Judd that also had the 'pressure point' incident, or am I getting mixed up with someone else. Either way Judd was just a dirty player. Not tough, just underhanded, cowardly stuff.

Yeah that's right, hence fevola goading him about Steven Seagal when he was pissed at the Brownlow. IMO Joel Selwood is of a similar ilk

 

[sobrave]

Lmao, this happened in the same round. We are to believe that Michael Christian watched this, thought it was fine, then watched SPP and decided that was worth a week.

#sackmichaelchristian

 

[Alberton Proud]

AFL worried about the repercussions of upholding staging sanctions on the gambling revenue they generate

#moneyoverintegrity

 

[EskimoPAFC]

that to date is the most disgusting act I’ve seen on a footy field and I played ammos in Elizabeth in the 90’s

Judd was a sh*t bloke on the field.

Good bloke Hodgey trying to decapitate Wingard still worse for me. Should have been given a full season off for it.

 

[sobrave]

Good bloke Hodgey trying to decapitate Wingard still worse for me. Should have been given a full season off for it.

In terms of risk yeah. There's more chance of death or permanent injury from that than there was from Barry halls king hit

 

[PowerBaz]

Hang on, was this. It even cited? Seriously not??

 

[sog35]

Hang on, was this. It even cited? Seriously not??

The head was protected via a very strong headlock, a great example of duty of care.

Shambles.

 

[PowerBaz]

Lmao, this happened in the same round. We are to believe that Michael Christian watched this, thought it was fine, then watched SPP and decided that was worth a week.

#sackmichaelchristian

I can’t believe that, that’s the tackle that’s worth three weeks.

 

[OneGreatClub]

Hang on, was this. It even cited? Seriously not??

Obviously Christian spends the majority of his time trolling PAFC videos for any indiscretions.
He can’t cover every team so wants best bang for his buck?

 

[Ateen7tee]

Obviously Christian spends the majority of his time trolling PAFC videos for any indiscretions.
He can’t cover every team so wants best bang for his buck?

Doesn't need to..

7 news are happy to offer their services for free by reviewing all available media regarding the Power whether it be on or off the field, or better still, on social media...

 

[El_Scorcho]

I think Butters is probably heading to the tribunal.

Our best case scenario is careless/high/high.

Wouldn't shock me to see intentional/high/severe.

Pretty sure if it's severe it's an automatic trip to the tribunal, and intentional/high/high would be as well.

Anyone got the chart?

 

[Dav]

Definitely at least a week, I think 2 is the most likely outcome.

 

[PowerForGood]

I think Butters is probably heading to the tribunal.

Our best case scenario is careless/high/high.

Wouldn't shock me to see intentional/high/severe.

Pretty sure if it's severe it's an automatic trip to the tribunal, and intentional/high/high would be as well.

Anyone got the chart?

Is this the Bontempelli “2k for fracturing Haynes’ larynx throat” version, or the “lets hang the non Vic player version”?

 

[Brian McGee]

Careless high and high is what it will be. In play so won’t be intentional.

 

[PowerBaz]

The north guy changes his step and almost runs into him. I still think it looks like butters almost braces, he definitely keeps his shoulders and elbows down, but I reckon the North guy changes his step and makes it worse.