Troy Menzel

[David the Cat]

Debatable now, the youngest is a highly desirable player and may end up being the best; he may have been B&F this year for WCE, and they had a good year. Joel is obviously superb, but let's see.

Scott is a fine player, but I dont think there would be much debate now over who is the better player. Joel is widely recognised as one of the best in the competition....I would suggest in the elite class.

Scott is in the very good player class....but I would think most neutrals would take Joel in a heartbeat if they could recruit either of them.

No...right now...Joel by a good margin.

 

[bulletproof]

Debatable now, the youngest is a highly desirable player and may end up being the best; he may have been B&F this year for WCE, and they had a good year. Joel is obviously superb, but let's see.

He has some catching up to do, even if Joel retired now Scott won't match his achievements.

Not debatable at all, never will be.

Joel is a different class all together to his brothers, always has been.

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

Really? Scott vs Joel?

Scott isn't even the best mid at West Coast let alone better then his Bro...

Don't think he has taken a tag and hasn't carried the midfield like Joel did for the first half of the year....

Had 8 superb games at the start of the year when West Cost dominated but he declined when they did..

 

[footscore]

Joel's just getting warmed up
his best is still to come

 

[Senatorguesty]

Joel's just getting warmed up
his best is still to come

Agreed. He hasnt won his Brownlow yet guys.

 

[footscore]

As far as I can tell...they are both boys that you sort of struggle to define as a pure forward or mid, as they float somewhere in between but kick plenty of goals running forward.

Dan hasn't had enough time in the league to judge properly but before he did the knee in the finals of 2011, you saw what he was doing...he tore an All-Australian defense of Collingwood's to shreds and then started dominating the Hawthorn defenders in his final before the knee went on him.
Kid is the most talented footballer I seen but from all reports, his brother is suppose to be just as good.

 

[footscore]

Agreed. He hasnt won his Brownlow yet guys.

having Caddy alongside him will elevate his game also because that kid is going to be a freak and both will excel their games in the coming years but as long as Bundy & Duncan can continue to improve then
hopefully Corey's imminent retirement won't hurt us as much as it did when Ling left.

 

[Hot Tin Roof]

Thats a cardable offence posting offensive pictures like that on this board......

Disclaimer: No Tenzels were harmed during​

incineration of this hideous AFL apparel.​

​

Green Carded? ​

 

[AlterRob]

​

Disclaimer: No Tenzels were harmed during​

incineration of this hideous AFL apparel.​

​

Green Carded? ​

LOL

 

[Moggy]

Remember, as George Orwell said:
All Selwoods are equal, but Joel is more equal than others

 

[manboob]

Joel's just getting warmed up
his best is still to come

He's only 24...

 

[James1970]

joel gunned it from day one. his highlights from his fourth game were shown to the players to set an example. harley was stunned by him from the first decision making drill they did. the other brothers are good players, joel will retire a champion.

Champion is not the right word - he'll retire closer to a God.

He'll could well be the first player granted membership to the AFL Legends Hall of Fame while still playing at Selwood Stadium.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Joel V scooter really? ok what ever floats your boats.Do you think the club would of drafted scooter if not for necessary needs? I wood like another selwood in the hoops oldman selwood better get back on the horse.

 

[Hot Tin Roof]

Warning:
Don't read The Hun today!

 

[barmy44]

Warning:
Don't read The Hun today!

now i want to read it

 

[Hot Tin Roof]

now i want to read it

If you really must ~ Lock up the kids and keep all sharp objects out of reach. Grab the spew bag just in case....
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/afl/mor...s-talent-to-burn/story-e6frf9jf-1226527048134

 

[dazbroncos]

I just threw up in my mouth......

a lot...

Go Catters

 

[Senatorguesty]

I dont get it.
I youtubed Menzel and found this awesome highlights package of Dan Menzel tearing AFL sides apart.

 

[David the Cat]

The boy should stand up and get his shoulders straight. Looks too wimpy standing next to Malthouse in that picture.

Obviously a spud.

 

[kimodgers]

The boy should stand up and get his shoulders straight. Looks too wimpy standing next to Malthouse in that picture.

Obviously a spud.

You say potato, I say potato ( you have to heard of Frank Sinatra to understand that)

Troy will be no spud.

 

[Moggy]

You say potato, I say potato ( you have to heard of Frank Sinatra to understand that)

Or Fred Astaire, to be more accurate

[pedantry is my business]

 

[kimodgers]

Or Fred Astaire, to be more accurate

[pedantry is my business]

Fred might be right.

Frank might have been more into Tomato v Tomato

 

[FredLeDeux]

Fred might be right.

Frank might have been more into Tomato v Tomato

Fred is always right.

 

[David the Cat]

Forget the tomato v tomato/ potato v potato........

Frank was more into Luciano v Gotto

 

[Hot Tin Roof]

Let's Call The Whole Thing Off